Skip to main content

The Best American Unaged Rum

The Manual Spirit Awards recognize the best craft liquors distilled in the U.S. We blind-tasted bottles from around the country in eight categories — Bourbon, Single Malt Whiskey, Rye Whiskey, Gin, Vodka, Unaged Rum, Aged Rum, and Liqueur — to determine our champions. Each of the winners was judged on aroma, palate, and finish. Cheers to your next drink and to American craft spirits.

Best Unaged Rum

Iron Fish Distillery Michigan White Rum

Thompsonville, Michigan

The Manual Spirit Awards 2019 Best Unaged Rum
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Rum is a distillate made from fermented sugar cane juice, sugar cane syrup, molasses, other sugar cane byproducts, or some combination thereof. The product is distilled at less than 190 proof and bottled at no less than 80 proof. Typically known as Caribbean spirits, rums are produced around the world and were a key product during the colonial era here in the United States.

Made with Caribbean molasses and Michigan honey, the Michigan White Rum from Iron Fish Distillery — the winner of the Unaged Rum category in The Manual Spirit Awards 2019 — manages to capture the joy of tropical rum from (nearly) the shores of Lake Michigan. The rum is light and easy-drinking, making it great for everything from a rum and coke to a more complex cocktail. The addition of honey created another layer of intricacy to the rum, adding what we registered as floral notes. These gave a nice counterpoint to the inherent nature of the spirit.

Iron Fish Distillery’s Michigan White Rum is 40% alcohol by volume and available in Michigan and Illinois.

About the Distillery

Iron Fish Distillery, located in Thompsonville, Michigan, is the state’s first farm distillery, located on the grounds of a now-reclaimed farmstead from the 1890s. The founders, Heidi Bolger, David Wallace, and Sarah and Richard Anderson, set out to create small-batch spirits that utilized the rich environment around Michigan. From growing grains to sourcing them from other Michigan farmers to working with native yeast strains found on the farm, the distillery’s goal is to make everything as local as possible while still maintaining a high level of excellence.

Iron Fish makes a variety of spirits, including gin, rye vodka, winter wheat vodka, barrel-aged gin, an experimental barrel-aged gin, white whiskey, maple bourbon whiskey, Caribbean cask bourbon whiskey, dark rum, tawny port cask bourbon whiskey, and imperial stout bourbon whiskey. As the team works on a native yeast program, they will also release special spirits from those experiments.

best unaged rum iron fish distillery michigan white rum mojito cocktail
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Tasting Notes

Nose Crisp and clear, with vegetal characteristics mixed with sugar cane and slight floral notes.
Palate Soft pineapple notes are mixed with cooked banana. Light on the tongue, sweet molasses flavors also come through, mixing with the lightest hint of honey-coated citrus peels.
Finish A short, clean finish with notes of caramelized bananas.

How to Enjoy It in a Cocktail

The mojito is a staple drink for countless around the world thanks to its simplicity: rum, lime, mint, soda, and sugar. You’ve got some power in the rum, crisp freshness in the mint, a zesty pick-me-up from the lime and the bubbles, and sweetness thanks to the sugar — all of which make a pretty perfect drink that can be enjoyed at just about any time of the day, especially in tropical climates. It was created in Havana, although the year of its birth is highly debated, as is the case with many classic cocktails.

Mojito

Glass: Collins

Tools: Muddler, straw

  • 1.5 oz Iron Fish Distillery Michigan White Rum
  • 1 oz lime juice
  • 2 tsp white sugar
  • 5-7 mint leaves, and 1 sprig for garnish
  • Soda water, to fill

Method: Add mint leaves, lime juice, and sugar to glass and muddle together. Add rum and ice. Top with soda water and use a straw to mix. Garnish with a sprig of mint.

Best Unaged Rum Runners-Up

Owney’s Distiller’s Reserve

Owney’s Distillery – Brooklyn, New York

Image used with permission by copyright holder

The first rum distilled in Brooklyn, this release from Owney’s is big and bold with plenty of flavor from beginning to end.

4 Spirits Silver Rum

4 Spirits Distillery – Corvallis, Oregon

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Tropical and slightly sweet, this rum is a blend of molasses and sugar cane for a more complex flavor.

Credits

Written by Sam Slaughter

Copy editing by Nicole Raney and Jeremy Abrams

Photography by  Riley Young and Dan Baker

Video by Riley Young

Art direction and page layout by Genevieve Poblano

Creative team: Will Hawkins and Chris Raymond

Sam Slaughter
Sam Slaughter was the Food and Drink Editor for The Manual. Born and raised in New Jersey, he’s called the South home for…
These are the best CBD gummies you can buy, period
Check out the best CBD gummies, according to experts
best cbd gummies 2021

CBD's hot streak shows no signs of cooling down any time soon, as shown by the eagerness with which consumers snap up products containing this cannabis compound. The benefits of cannabidiol create a high demand for CBD products. This results in a somewhat flooded market, which can seem like a good problem to have, that is, until you're planning to buy a container of high-quality CBD gummies you can munch on, and you don't know where to start. Having been in this challenging position a few times myself, I thought it prudent to seek advice from the experts, and ten cannabis industry pros came through with recommendations for the best CBD gummies that are currently available on the market.

Looking for something else to consume? We've also rounded up the best CBD drinks and CBD snacks for you to consider.

Read more
These are the best rums, according to bartenders
There's good rum and there's great rum. Here, we ask bartenders for their top picks
Santa Teresa rum flight.

Santa Teresa Santa Teresa

When it comes to spirits, there's hardly anything more summery than rum. The drink evokes the very sun-kissed beaches where the sugarcane is grown, whether it's enjoyed neat or mixed into a classic like a dark 'n' stormy.

Read more
The 9 best rums for Mojitos that you can get behind
Making a Mojito? You're going to need a nice light rum, like one of these standout selections
A hand serving a glass of Mojito on a table.

In the vast land of rum cocktails, the Mojito is an elite player. This classic cocktail, born in Cuba, is both a cinch to make and extremely rewarding to drink. Made of rum, lime, mint, sugar, and soda water, the beverage is basically the liquid definition of refreshing.

While often pegged as a summer drink, the Mojito is really accessible year-round. In fact, like a good tiki drink, the cocktail can be even more desirable during the colder months as it can deposit you somewhere sun-kissed and tropical. Yet, because the drink is so dependent on its spirit base, it can only be as good as the rum that goes into it.

Read more