Skip to main content

Creatine vs. protein powder: How do they affect your gains?

Which supplement is better for you?

creatine three tubs protein pre workout shake drink on table
Aleksander Saks / Unsplash

Nutrition is crucial to fitness and sports performance. As a trainer and nutritionist, I personally utilize various supplements for nutrition, and I recommend them to many clients as well. Progress toward your fitness goals can be hindered without proper nutrition.

Two of the most popular supplements for athletes and fitness enthusiasts are creatine and protein powder. They have proven to be effective with numerous benefits. These include increased energy levels, fast recovery, enhanced performance, and weight management.

Recommended Videos

Hence, we will explore the creatine vs. protein debate. What can the supplements do for you? Which one is better for your body and personal goals? It’s time to dive in!

What is creatine?

Creatine in a spoon on top of spilled creatine
HowToGym / Unsplash

Creatine is an amino acid that provides a steady energy supply to the muscles when active, especially during exercise. While this compound is present naturally in the body, taking it in supplement form helps enhance its availability. This, in turn, promotes muscle strength, increased mass, and efficient athletic performance.

You can get creatine from your diet, especially protein-rich foods. Likewise, your liver, kidneys, and pancreas produce it. Manufacturers make them as supplements in tablets, powders, liquids, capsules, and energy bars as well.

How does creatine benefit the body?

man powerlifting dead lift holding barbell competition
Charles Walton / Pexels

Improves performance

Creatine directly impacts your performance during exercise or sports regardless of your fitness level, from increased muscle mass to brain performance, ballistic power, strength, resistance to fatigue, muscle endurance, and sprint ability. It is one supplement you can never go wrong with, regardless of the activities you decide to partake in.

Provides energy for muscle cells

This is the most significant benefit of creatine and is often why many people take it. During exercise, your body breaks down adenosine triphosphate (ATP) to get energy, and creatine increases your muscles’ phosphocreatine stores, which aids the formation of ATP. So, if you use more ATP than your body produces, you may not be able to sustain high-intensity exercise for a longer time. But with creatine supplements, you can easily balance the supply and demand of energy for your body.

Aids muscle recovery

A study suggests that ‘’Creatine supplementation may reduce muscle damage and/or enhance recovery from intense exercise.’’ Exercise usually results in muscle soreness due to micro-tears in the muscle. In severe cases, it can impair muscle functions. However, creatine helps hasten the recovery of these muscles after your workout, allowing you to get back in the gym sooner. It activates satellite cells that heal the micro tears.

What does protein powder do for the body?

close up biceps bicep curl one arm muscles muscular
Tima Miroshnichenko / Pexels

Muscle growth

Protein is a primary focus among those who consistently include lifting weights as part of their lifestyle. Consuming protein through both food sources and supplements can be great for aiding muscle growth and maintaining overall muscle mass.

A 2018 systematic review supports this idea, as it shares that protein supplements can improve muscle size and strength in healthy adults actively involved in resistance training.

Weight management

An effective way to manage your weight is by increasing your protein intake. Protein is the most satiating macronutrient and helps with appetite control. So, it is easier to consume fewer calories when you include plenty of protein in your diet. Additionally, protein contributes to a faster metabolism, increases fat burning, and prevents muscle loss. Overall, it can be your one-way ticket to burning fat and building muscle or simply managing your weight.

Faster recovery after exercise

Protein is the main building block for cell renewal, tissue growth, and repair. It contributes significantly to faster recovery after exercise and tissue repair after an injury. With protein supplements like powders and bars, soreness and muscle damage from exercise can be reduced.

Is creatine or protein powder a better supplement?

person scooping protein powder out of canister
jdoms / Adobe Stock

Creatine and protein powder are both beneficial supplements that have different roles to play when it comes to your fitness goals. Creatine provides extra energy to help you get the most out of your exercise sessions and push harder, while protein helps build and repair muscles. So, both supplements are of equal value when it comes down to how they can support you.

How to optimize your nutrition routine with both

man in gym taking supplement drinking protein shake powder electrolyte mineral
Andres Ayrton / Pexels

Taking creatine and protein supplements together is ideal for optimal results. You can take them either before or after your training sessions, and there is no clear evidence suggesting one is better than the other. Just be sure to stick to the recommended dosage and be consistent. This is especially important for creatine, as you want your muscles to be constantly saturated for the best results. Also, since creatine increases water retention in the muscles, staying hydrated is a must.

Frequently asked questions

Male athlete drinking protein shake while sitting in gym.
Westend61 / Adobe Stock

Do I need creatine if I take protein?

Not necessarily. While no one needs to take creatine in general, taking the two together has maximum benefits for increased energy, muscle growth, and recovery.

Is there a downside to creatine?

Creatine is safe as long as you stick to the recommended dosage. However, possible side effects may include dehydration, muscle cramps, and stomach upset.

Can I build muscle without protein or creatine?

Yes, you can build muscles without supplements like creatine and protein. These supplements amplify your efforts, but you can still put on muscle without them. It may take longer, but with consistency and a proper diet, you will likely get your desired results.

Christine VanDoren
Christine is a certified personal trainer and nutritionist with an undergraduate degree from Missouri State University. Her…
11 delicious low-glycemic foods to improve your overall health
Vegetables, eggs, and more
Vegetables on cutting board

Do you wish you could maintain your energy levels and consume a lot of nutrient-dense foods without accumulating too much sugar? As a trainer and nutritionist, this is a common goal that many clients share with me. Luckily, certain diet plans can help you achieve this easily, with one of them being the low-glycemic diet.

Low glycemic foods can aid weight loss, help manage diabetes, reduce overall cholesterol levels, improve athletic performance, and reduce blood pressure. So, if you want to learn more about the low-glycemic diet, keep reading for information on the glycemic index, the benefits of low-glycemic foods, and more!
What is the glycemic index?

Read more
What is clean eating: How it influences weight loss and bulking
Should eating clean be your new goal?
Healthy low carbs products. Ketogenic diet concept. Top view

As a nutritionist, many new clients come to me sharing the diet trends they have tried that ultimately weren’t sustainable. Clean eating is one of the newest diet trends that everyone is currently enthusiastic about, especially in the U.S., because they keep hearing that it's healthy and natural. However, there are no regulations around "clean eating," so many people have their own thoughts on what it actually means.

According to a recent study, "Definitions for the culturally trendy 'clean' eating phenomenon vary; whereas some characterize it as natural and healthy, others adopt more restrictive, moralizing, and affectively laden definitions that may reflect disordered eating."

Read more
How to run with proper form: Tips to enhance your endurance and speed
Seven-time marathoner and personal trainer Carissa Galloway reveals how to improve technique and performance.
Man getting ready to run on running track

Running feels natural, human, and refreshing. Plus, it’s one of the most accessible and rewarding types of physical exercise. I love simply feeling the breeze on my face and being out in nature. Even if it’s just my neighborhood, it feels energizing going jogging or running by the vibrant rose and flower bushes and tall, enchanting trees draping Spanish moss. 

When I took a running hiatus, I felt like a beginner starting out again. I’d forgotten my proper technique, and it took some time to harness the power of my mind to keep going and fine-tuning my running form.

Read more