Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Health & Fitness
  3. Evergreens

Your guide to how running shoes should fit for optimal performance

Tips for picking the best running shoes for you

Running shoes sneakers outside park bench sunrise sunset
Karl Solano / Pexels

Running shoes need to be as comfortable as possible, as running is an intense activity that requires support. Hence, any discomfort can affect performance, and this is why knowing how to buy running shoes that fit perfectly is vital. As a fitness enthusiast and casual runner, I have tried a few different shoe brands, and the difference is notable.  

In this guide, we will discuss how running shoes should fit, including how to tell if your shoes are too tight or loose, how to accurately measure your feet for the perfect fit, and some mistakes you should avoid when buying running shoes. 

Why does the proper fit matter for running performance?

A 2018 study found that wearing incorrectly fitted footwear can lead to numerous issues. It states, “A large proportion of the population wears incorrectly sized footwear, which is associated with foot pain and disorders. Greater emphasis should be placed on both footwear fitting education and the provision of an appropriately large selection of shoes that can accommodate the variation in foot morphology among the population, particularly in relation to foot width.” 

Recommended Videos

This even more critically applies to running shoes. If your running shoes do not fit properly, they can lead to blisters, bruised toenails, chafing, and overheating. They can also cause severe issues like plantar fasciitis, knee pain, or shin splints. However, with well-fitted shoes, you will get adequate cushioning and support to absorb impact as you run and prevent injuries. 

In addition, using comfortable running gear helps you maintain focus since you don’t have to worry about your feet. It also makes you more confident, knowing you have reliable shoes with arch support, adequate toe box space, and heel lockdown.

Key signs your running shoes are too tight or too loose

When you wear the shoes, if you don’t have enough toe room to spread your toes widely and wiggle them, they’re too tight. If your feet slide around in the shoe, they are too big. 

Also, if you can’t remove your shoes without completely loosening the laces, they’re too tight. However, if your feet can slip out of the shoe when fully laced, it’s too big. If your toe grazes the front of your shoe or you feel numbness on your foot, it’s too tight. 

Your running shoes should fit snugly with enough toe room to spread out your toes. If you have wider feet, look for shoes with wide feet options to get comfortable.

How do you measure your feet for the best fit?  

Wear socks similar to those you would wear when running, then stand up straight with your full weight on your feet. Place one foot on a piece of paper, and get someone to help you trace around the edges with a pen. Now, use a ruler to measure the outline from the longest toe to the back of your heel. Do the same for the other foot, and use the bigger foot to determine your shoe size.

Common mistakes when buying running shoes

Trying on only one shoe

Studies have shown that it’s very common for one foot to be larger than the other because our bodies are not symmetrical. However, if you try on one shoe without trying the other, you may end up with a small fit because you are meant to buy a shoe based on the size of your bigger foot to ensure the comfort of both feet.

Assuming your size

If you haven’t bought running shoes for some time, don’t assume you still know your size. Get your feet resized to know your current size before buying shoes. 

Ignoring surface material

Aside from determining the correct width, size, fit, and material for your running shoes, the running surface is another crucial factor. Certain shoes are made for different running surfaces, and ignoring this could lead to accidents and injuries. 

Choosing shoes based on looks

It’s okay to want to be fashionable and stylish when picking running shoes. However, placing too much emphasis on looks may make you ignore important qualities and pick shoes simply because of their appearance.

Tips for trying on running shoes like a pro

Understand your foot type 

Some people have slender feet, while some have wider feet. Shoe brands make shoes specific to each foot type. So, first, identify your foot type before trying on different running shoes. 

Wear appropriate socks

Running socks take up some space in your shoes, so if you don’t test the shoes with socks, they might become tight later when you are ready to run. Hence, wear appropriate socks when trying on your running shoes. 

Check the fit for both feet

It is best to wear both shoes and lace them completely before concluding if they are your perfect size. Because in some cases, one foot is larger than the other, so wearing one shoe can be misleading. 

Walk and jog around

Test your shoes to see how they feel. Although you may not be able to tell completely, jogging will reveal if the shoes are comfortable enough for running. 

Frequently asked questions

How much room should a running shoe have?

Running shoes should have about one inch of space, which would be just enough room to spread out your toes, prevent injuries, and allow your feet to swell without discomfort. Also, your feet should feel secure but not squeezed after lacing your shoes. 

Should running shoes be a size bigger?

It’s better to buy running shoes that are half a size and a full size bigger than your regular shoes. Because when running, your feet tend to swell due to increased blood flow. Plus, you also need to prevent blisters and jamming on your toes, especially when running downhill.

Should a running shoe be loose or tight?

Running shoes should fit perfectly, not too tight or loose. They should be able to hold your feet in place while still providing enough toe room and breathability.

Christine is a certified personal trainer and nutritionist with an undergraduate degree from Missouri State University. Her… Read Full Bio
Fitness 101: The perfect biceps curl with fitness expert Liz Baker Plosser
Liz Baker Plosser

There is no shortage of examples of the male bicep becoming the driver of confidence in men and desire for women. Men have been fed this narrative since we were kids, from Popeye winning the love of Olive Oil when he eats spinach and is awarded with bulging biceps, allowing him to be the hero (I won’t go on a tangent about how this was also used to manipulate me into eating vegetables…which I have thankfully overcome as an adult) to Captain America displaying his hulking biceps by holding down a literal helicopter. The bro culture makes memes of men like Arnold Schwarzenegger locking hands with Carl Weathers and showing off the boulders under their tee sleeves, resulting in all of us men wanting to learn how to get the giant arms to show off our hard work.

Of course, that means one of the first things we reach for in the gym when we first get our membership is the dumbbell so we can start our journey towards attaining our own Olive-Oil-rescuing muscle. But, like anything, it is best to listen to experts. Liz Baker Plosser is a fitness and wellness expert who has spent two decades teaching others on the same journey to attain their fitness goals. From being the editor and chief at Women’s Health to appearing on national shows like Live with Kelly and Mark and The TODAY Show, she has become a staple in the fitness industry.

Read more
Get the “Extraction” body before Chris Hemsworth’s threequel
Extraction Workout

Movies lied to me when I was a kid. When I joined the Army, I had dreams of being an Army Ranger. Too many movies made me think I could be a special operator and maybe even get myself a great nickname like the GI Joes. Instead, I told one of the sergeants of my aspirations, and he flat out said I wouldn’t make it. Not that I couldn’t do it, but that they wouldn’t let me. I was too big. 6’5″ and 220 pounds was going to require too many calories. You see, Arnold Schwarzenegger, Sylvester Stallone, and Dwayne Johnson made me think that the elite soldiers needed to be hulking giants. Or world-class martial artists like Bruce Lee, Chuck Norris, or Jean-Claude Van Damme. And since I couldn’t do a roundhouse, I decided to follow the more practical path of the everyman like Bruce Willis, Nic Cage, and Tom Cruise.

You see, special operators need to be agile. They need mobility. That is why Chris Hemsworth adopted a workout with that goal to prepare for his third turn as Tyler Rake in his new Netflix film, Extraction 3.

Read more
The Manual’s Health & Wellness Awards Are Open for Submissions
Clothing, Footwear, Shoe

For years, The Manual has told readers which products actually work. Not which ones arrived in the nicest box, and not which brand bought the most media. Which ones held up after weeks of real use, and were still worth reaching for at the end.

Now we’re bringing that same approach to health. Introducing The Manual Health & Wellness Awards 2026, our first awards program dedicated to the products that help men sleep, train, recover, and feel better. And it’s open to submissions.

Read more