Skip to main content

For Sale: The Stunning Bahamian Island Where Fyre Festival Didn’t Happen

Fyre Festival will go down in history as one of, if not the, greatest disasters in music festival history. For those who (almost) attended, it was a debacle of near-epic proportions. For the rest of us, it became fodder for the social media zeitgeist. Now, the private Caribbean island widely and fraudulently touted as the postcard-worthy home of the festival is up for sale.

Saddleback Cay
Christie's International Real Estate / Christie's International Real Estate

Over “two transformative weekends” in 2017, the Fyre Festival promised to “exceed all expectations” with “the best in food, art, music, and adventure.” From the marketing to the ticket sales to the non-event itself, it was a whirlwind of misinformation about the location, the “gourmet” catering, the five-star accommodations, and even the artists. There’s a reason both Hulu and Netflix dedicated full-blown, American Greed-worthy documentaries to the debacle (As if you needed another great Netflix documentary to add to the growing queue you’ll never have time to watch). When the smoke cleared in 2018, the event organizer was ordered to forfeit more than $26 million and sentenced to six years in prison.

Saddleback Cay
Christie's International Real Estate

Somehow, at the center of the festival’s marketing material, was the remote Bahamian island of Saddleback Cay. Promoters used aerial footage of the island to bolster an image of the festival on an impossibly beautiful stretch of private white sand beach. News of the island’s former life as home to the infamous Pablo Escobar only added to its mystique. To the best of anyone’s knowledge, however, the Colombian drug lord never set foot on the island, and the festival was actually slated to take place nearly 200 miles away on Great Exuma. Nevertheless, the non-home of the world’s greatest non-festival is up for sale.

Saddleback Cay
Christie's International Real Estate

The official real estate listing for Saddleback Cay sidesteps any mention of Fyre Festival, as well it should. Notwithstanding its unintentional connection to the festival, it’s a stunning, picture-perfect stretch of Caribbean sand that most of us would kill to retire to. It covers 35 pristine acres with seven ultra-private beaches. On one of those beaches lies a modest, 500-square-foot main house with one bedroom and two bathrooms, plus a few satellite cottages to accommodate staff or guests. The island’s 90-foot elevation towers, relatively speaking, over the Caribbean Sea in every direction, providing commanding views.

Saddleback Cay
Christie's International Real Estate

Naturally, the surrounding landscape and its proximity to Exuma National Sea & Land Park make it an ideal base for all manner of watersports and activities including sailing, deep-sea fishing, and scuba diving. The island’s location in the northern Exuma Cays provides exceptional seclusion. However, neighboring Normans’ Cay has a working airstrip guaranteeing a quick, 30-minute private flight to Miami.

Saddleback Cay
Christie's International Real Estate

If you’re the sort of hotshot who’s looking to add to his portfolio of high-end Caribbean real estate, Christie’s International Real Estate is entertaining serious offers for Saddleback Cay Private Island. Starting bids are just short of $12 million. If that seems too rich for your blood, imagine the cocktail party stories you could spin about possibly sleeping in Pablo Escobar’s former bedroom.

If renting an island stay is better suited to your budget, check out these surprisingly affordable semi-private island resorts worth splurging on.

Mike Richard
Mike Richard has traveled the world since 2008. He's kayaked in Antarctica, tracked endangered African wild dogs in South…
Would you sail on a Titanic replica? Everything we know about the Titanic II
We're pretty sure this one will have enough lifeboats
The Titanic ocean liner

The Titanic meunierd via Shutterstock

The Titanic was an engineering marvel that met a tragic end. It set new standards for ocean liners, with enormous dimensions, luxury accommodations, and intricate engineering. But on April 10, 1912, an iceberg ruined the ship's maiden voyage from Southampton, England, to New York City. Today, it rests at the bottom of the Atlantic Ocean.

Read more
Round up your golf buddies — these are the best golf trips in the U.S.
Head to these great locales with your golf buddies
Ocean hole at Pebble Beach Golf Links

Pebble Beach Golf Links Noah Rosenfield via Unsplash

Golf lends itself to a fun, relaxing vacation. In the morning, hit the links with your buddies, try and break par, and take in stunning landscapes. When your round’s over, relax at the clubhouse or try world-class eateries, where you can savor and recharge. Then, do it again the next day.

Read more
These are the hottest summer travel spots in the U.S., according to Airbnb
2024 airbnb summer travel destinations packing mans suitcase for

As the weather heats up, so do travel plans for many people! Airbnb just released a list of the hottest summer travel spots in the U.S., and it has something for everyone. Airbnb based these top U.S. summer destinations on where people were searching to book rentals for the summer months of June through August 2024.
Top U.S. summer travel spots
Ouray, Colorado

If you’re an adventure seeker, Ouray, Colorado, might just be your perfect match. Nicknamed the "Outdoor Recreation Capital of Colorado," this mountain town offers hiking, rock climbing, and off-roading adventures with stunning views. Heads up -- you might see more bighorn sheep than people!
Eugene, Oregon

Read more