Skip to main content

8 Deserted Islands in America to Visit Before They’re Overrun With Tourists

Best Deserted Islands in America to Visit
Image used with permission by copyright holder

For suburbanites and city-dwelling Americans, it’s difficult to imagine anywhere in the country that’s not jam-packed with people, strip malls, gas stations, and Starbucks. But the United States is indeed the third-largest country in the world by landmass. No matter where you live, it’s not too hard to escape the maddening crowds. You just have to know where to look. The best place to start? One of the many fantastic islands that dot the country’s coastlines. These are the best deserted islands in America to visit in 2022.

Related Guides

San Miguel Island

Channel Islands, California

California's Channel Islands
Image used with permission by copyright holder

California’s Channel Islands are a literal national treasure. San Miguel Island, the westernmost in the chain, feels and is worlds away from anywhere. Reaching the shore requires a four-hour boat ride one-way. But, hearty explorers will appreciate the island’s solitude and pristine landscape. It’s 9,500 acres of stunning natural beauty, home to more than tens of thousands of animals, including peregrine falcons and foxes, plus marine mammals like dolphins, seals, and blue whales. Whether day-tripping or overnighting, just be sure to pack everything you’ll need.

Garden Key

Dry Tortugas National Park, The Florida Keys

Image used with permission by copyright holder

For sheer solitude, it’s hard to beat the U.S. National Parks. But to truly escape the crowds, look to the smallest, most off-the-beaten-path parks in the USNP system — parks like Dry Tortugas. Garden Key, the main island in the archipelago, is a former island prison and is the actual southernmost point in the continental United States. At 70 miles beyond Key West, it’s closer to Cuba than it is to Florida. Most visitors are daytrippers; however, overnight camping is allowed. For those looking to truly get away, we recommend it. Be warned that there are zero services on the island, so you’ll need to carry in all of your own supplies, including food, shelter, and clean drinking water.

Portsmouth Island

The Outer Banks, North Carolina

Portsmouth Island in The Outer Banks, North Carolina
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Most visitors to The Outer Banks have never heard of Portsmouth Island. The small tidal island off the southwest coast of Ocracoke is only accessible by private boat, tour, or charter, which means it sees very few visitors each year. The island’s claim to fame is its well-preserved ghost town with a handful of historical buildings, including a one-room schoolhouse and a combination post office/general store. Beyond that, the 13-mile-long island boasts some of the most beautiful, untouched beaches in the U.S., even by Outer Banks standards.

Mokoli’i Island

Oahu, Hawaii

Mokoli’i Island in Oahu, Hawaii
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Mokoli’i — known locally and somewhat unfortunately as “Chinaman’s Hat” — is a speck of an island off the eastern coast of Oahu. At just 12.5 acres, there isn’t much to do on the island beyond a 20-minute hike to its peak. But it’s popular among visitors for two main reasons. One, it’s become something of a meme as a cheeky backdrop for tourist photos. But the fact that it can only be reached by kayaking, surfing, or swimming has also made it a bucket-list-worthy challenge for many Oahu visitors. If that’s a little too adventurous for your liking, it’s also accessible at low tide by wading across the channel. Time your visit during the week, and there’s a good chance you’ll have it all to yourself.

South Manitou Island

Lake Michigan, Michigan

South Manitou Island on Lake Michigan
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Finding the perfect desert island doesn’t always require a trip to the coast. South Manitou Island, a small, eight-square-mile patch of land off the shores of Lake Michigan, is a hidden gem for solitude seekers. It’s only accessible via infrequent ferry, meaning visitors are unlikely to see too many other people. This is a place where time slows down, where days consist of beachcombing the island’s 10 miles of pristine pebble-dotted sands and exploring groves of old-growth cedar that date back more than five centuries. South Manitou Island’s long history has inspired plenty of modern-day ghost stories, and the waters surrounding the island are home to more than fifty known shipwrecks.

Yellow Island

San Juan Islands, Washington

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Washington’s San Juan Islands are a popular destination for nature- and outdoor-loving travelers. But, no island in the chain delivers the peace and untouched beauty of Yellow Island. The 11-acre Natural Conservancy Preserve remains largely today as it has for centuries — covered in wildflowers and home to dozens of wildlife species. It’s only reachable via private boat or kayak (for experienced kayakers out of Deer Harbor on Orcas Island), which ensures that visitors have no trouble finding an acre or two all to themselves.

Buck Island

St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands

Buck Island in St. Croix
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Even among the Virgin Islands, Buck Island stands out. The 176-acre island, less than two miles off “mainland” St. Croix, is part of the larger Buck Island Reef National Monument. The monument includes more than 19,000 acres in total, the majority of which are underwater, making this an ideal destination for snorkelers and scuba divers. On-island, visitors can while away the day along Turtle Beach to the west or hike the heart of the island through turpentine and pigeon-berry trees. Like most islands on this list, Buck Island is only accessible by tour or private boat, so it only sees around 30,000 visitors each year.

Wild Horse Island

Flathead Lake, Montana

Wild Horse Island on Flathead Lake, Montana

Montana is known for many thanks, but “world-class deserted islands” isn’t one of them. That makes Wild Horse Island all the more worth a visit. It’s the largest spot of rock in the middle of massive Flathead Lake, home to no one — well, no one except mule deer, bald eagles, bighorn sheep, and (obviously) wild horses. It’s all the beauty, peace, and quiet of a traditional desert island, but with a distinct Big Sky Country vibe. Don’t miss a hike to the top of the caldera, the perfect picnic spot with stunning panoramic views from nearly 4,000 feet above sea level.

Editors' Recommendations

Mike Richard
Mike Richard has traveled the world since 2008. He's kayaked in Antarctica, tracked endangered African wild dogs in South…
For an authentic California surfer experience, visit this underappreciated gem
Hidden in South Orange County, Dana Point offers good vibes, great waves, gnarly adventures, and so much more
A view of the Dana Point Headlands from Salt Creek Beach in Dana Point, California.

Dana Point, California, lies near the southernmost tip of Orange County, so it’s understandable how this scenic coastal city feels far removed from OC’s more central — and more famous — tourist attractions. But if you’ve ever wanted to try out OC’s favorite sport, you have to head down here. (And no, we’re not talking about shopping!)

Surfing may not be native to California, but it’s definitely part of Dana Point’s lifeblood. Whether you’re an aspiring pro surfer looking for a new spot to ride some epic waves or you’re a hodad who’s never climbed onto a surfboard before, you have plenty of good reasons to hit the beach at Dana Point. From Dana Point’s remarkable range of waves to the city’s prominent place in surfing history, it's always a good idea to suit up and bring your board down here for an awesome beach vacation. 
Here's some historical background on Dana Point

Read more
The best places to visit in Mexico: 6 amazing gems (that aren’t Cancun)
Here are the cities in Mexico you should visit to get off the beaten path
The calavera is a popular symbol in Mexico.

From its great weather and its delicious food to its inviting culture and a whole lot more, there has never been any shortage of reasons for visiting Mexico. During the pandemic, however, the country’s popularity surged among American and Canadian travelers seeking a continental destination they could reach with relatively little difficulty. The thing is, while many are familiar with hotspot tourist magnets like Mexico City, Cancun, Tulum, or Puerto Vallarta, few visitors know where to best wander off the beaten path. With this in mind, we’ve decided to take a look at a few of Mexico’s smaller cities that get less attention but offer plenty of solid reasons to visit. If you're looking for the best places to visit in Mexico, consider these incredible locales.

Book your plans with confidence, knowing that these are well-proven recommendations. I’ve spent a total of roughly five years living and traveling in Mexico, including the vast majority of the past three years. I’ve road-tripped throughout some two-thirds of the country and know each of these cities firsthand, and I can attest that these places are exceptional.

Read more
Up your ski game with these lesser known ski resorts in North America
Undiscovered ski towns: Avoid lift queues and busy groomers and discover a whole new ski area
Alyeska Resort

I remember when I took up snowboarding in a hectic French Alpine resort. Everywhere I turned, there were lines of skiers coming down the mountain, and if you stopped for a break — I was a beginner, cut me some slack — you had to merge into traffic like you were entering a busy highway. What's more, once I started cruising runs, I realized I was spending more time standing in lift lines than I was riding. Then I moved to Canada. On the suggestion of a friend, I shirked the better-known resorts and headed to a small town with a small mountain, which boasted a ridiculous amount of skiable acres per person. I no longer had to wait for lifts, I could ride fresh powder all day, and ski accidents were few and far between.

Sure, if you love a big aprés ski scene or long for the buzz of a busy holiday destination, there might be a benefit to going to a better-known or all-inclusive ski resort. But if your idea of the perfect ski holiday is a quieter destination with great snow, shorter lift queues, and good vibes, then check out one of our lesser-known ski resorts.

Read more