Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

Throw it Back with These Old School Grooming Products

old school grooming products
While it seems like manLY upkeep is always on the upswing, there was a time when gentlemen would wax and twirl their mustaches into distinctive shapes, carefully comb their hair back with pomade, and give themselves a once over with cologne (even if it was just to cover up a lack of personal hygiene). In the spirit of the throwback, why not eschew modern wares in favor of vintage finds like the potions whipped up in the legacy apothecaries and barbershops of yore? If these old school grooming products were good enough for your grandfather, they’re good enough for you. These heritage brands are the real deal. Make your bathroom shelves over in the dream of the 1890s with these time-tested wonders.

Caswell-Massey Heritage Jockey Club Cologne Spray – $75

Caswell-Massey Heritage Jockey Club Cologne Spray

This cologne, launched in 1840, is thought to be the first “sport” fragrance as it wafted through the air of the American Thoroughbred racing clubs back in the nineteenth century. This new heritage formulation reflects the original with notes of citrus, thyme and basil with a just a touch of honey and rose. This classic, clean scent with said to have been a favorite of JFK.

See it

Kent Shaving Brushes – Prices vary

kent shaving brush

Back in the day — 1777 to be exact — William Kent founded Kent Brushes. Centuries of hand craftsmanship and excellence in all kinds of brush-making is why this British Company continues to thrive today. Try this king size pure silver tipped badger shaving brush that has been lifting whiskers for generations.

See it

Taylor of Old Bond Street Aftershave Lotion – $35

Taylor of Old Bond Street Sandalwood Aftershave

Back in the day, barbershops were called shaving salons and were frequented by very rich dudes indeed. Jeremiah Taylor opened up just one of these establishments in 1854, calling it Taylor of Bond Street. Later, when his son took over the shop, Taylor introduced a line of very fancy shaving products by that very same name.


Penhaligon’s Bayolea Eau de Toilette – $92

Penhaligons Bayolea Eau de Toilette

In 1870, William Penhaligon opened a London barbershop next to Jermyn Street’s finest tailors. He received the royal warrant and trimmed the Shah of Persia’s beard. The rest was history. Bayolea, an original “Bay Rum” scent, has been recreated from the archives and turned into soaps, pomades, scrubs waxes, and oils. It’s a spicy, energetic scent with black pepper, cardamom, mandarin, tangerine, lemongrass, and musk-patchouli.

See it

J. R. Watkins Pain Relieving Liniment – $9

JR Watkins Pain Relieving Liniment

Founder Joseph Ray Watkin’s product line began as a humble, homemade (literally, he was blending ingredients in his Minnesota kitchen) pain-relieving liniment in 1868. His cure-for-all-that-ails-ya was a huge hit then, and judging by the fact that it’s continued run, still is now.


Kiehl’s Musk Essence Oil – $35

Kiehls Musk Essence Oil

The Kiehl’s shop on 3rd Avenue in the East Village has stood there since 1851. Though no longer a pharmacy dispensing homespun elixirs, there is still at least one current product that has been around since the beginning. The musk oil is a humane take (read: synthetic, not animal-derived) on the original sexy scent, which was hidden away in the basement after perhaps being deemed too sexy for the times. We promise it smells better than it sounds.

See it

C.O. Bigelow Lemon Body Cream – $20

CO Bigelow Lemon Body Cream

In 1838, Village Apothecary opened its doors in lower Manhattan, where owner Dr. Galen Hunter conjuring up homemade remedies. After employee Clarence Otis Bigelow took over the pharmacy, he renamed it C.O. Bigelow and continued the tradition of creating products by hand. Much of their current catalogue is a nod to those original recipes, such as this refreshingly scented body cream.


Article originally published July 15, 2016. Last updated by Jennifer Jones on January 5, 2017.

Editors' Recommendations

Katie Dickens
Katie Dickens is a Manhattan-based beauty and grooming writer. She has held staff positions at Glamour, In Style, People…
The Best Charcoal Grooming Products for Better Hair and Skin
Best Charcoal Hair & Skin Products

Charcoal. The substance that turns your teeth black while brushing and your steak medium-well by grilling. Pretty crazy, right? Actually, those two charcoals are slightly different. Activated charcoal — the charcoal used for health purposes — is the type we want to focus on. Aside from leaving your teeth pearly white, activated charcoal also is great at stripping away dirt from your skin and hair.

Whether you've been exposed to charcoal grooming products or not, there are picks out there for every kind of use. Shampoos, conditioners, face washes, face masks, body washes, the list goes on. Fortunately, we rolled up our sleeves and sifted through the vast selection of choices out there to give you a better idea of how to add activated charcoal to your grooming routine. Enjoy!
Best Body Wash: Every Man Jack Activated Charcoal Body Wash

Read more
The Best Latinx-Owned Grooming Brands to Shop Now and Forever
Jessica Alba Honest Beauty

Jessica Alba, Founder and Chief Creative Officer of The Honest Company, attends the Honest Beauty Launch on September 9, 2015 in New York City. Paul Zimmerman/Getty Images

For centuries, Latinx culture has had a strong connection to beauty. It has given birth to some of the best skin and grooming experts and the consumer makes up a huge part of the profit margin of the beauty industry in general. But it isn’t every day you see Latinx-owned brands properly represented. So in the spirit of waking up in 2020, it is our civic duty (as editors at The Manual) and your duty as the consumer to diversify your spending and brand knowledge. All cultures should be represented, all the time.

Read more
The Absolute Best Grooming Products To Buy September 2021
Man using skincare.

Great grooming takes work. That’s why The Manual team tests and vets countless soaps, moisturizers, colognes, and more to find the best personal care products for men, so you don’t have to. Every month, our writers highlight some of their favorites. Read on to learn more.
Baxter of California Deep Clean Shampoo

"A new sulfate-free shampoo that does what it says, and leaves my scalp and hair feeling squeaky clean for days." — Christian Gollayan

Read more