Skip to main content

Steak and a Manhattan: A Match Made in Heaven

Alone, a steak—cooked just right (that is, nothing over medium rare) with just a little salt and pepper—is the perfect meal. You don’t need the salad bar for an extra $3.99 or the sides. Those are just frivolous distractions from the centerpiece. Alone, too, you can’t get much better than a Manhattan when it comes to cocktails. It’s a classic. Booze-forward, yet round, it’s a sipper that is as great as the city its named after. This is why, together, these two items make the perfect pairing.

In order to explain the steak and a Manhattan pairing some more, we asked Beverage Director Brad Nugent and Michael Lomonaco, Chef and Partner of Porter House Bar and Grill in New York for their thoughts on the matter.

Photo Courtesy of Porter House Bar and Grill

First, let’s start with the drink.

The Classic Manhattan

  • 2 oz rye whiskey
  • .75 oz sweet vermouth
  • 3-4 dashes angostura bitters

Method: Add ingredients to a mixing glass with ice. Stir and strain into a chilled cocktail glass. Garnish with a cherry. 

This drink, Lomonaco says, is “rich and brawny, with a shade of sweetness and a bite of quality bitters. This is the American Classic.” When it comes to which rye, Lomonaco says he usually goes with Michter’s. Nugent takes a little different approach to the Manhattan, favoring a two-to-one ratio (whiskey to vermouth), and he favors using Crown Royal (and Carpano Antica Formula for vermouth).

Either way, the important thing to remember is that you stir the drink, you do not shake it. This keeps the alcohol from becoming too diluted, leaving you with the full flavors you need (such as the spicy notes you’ll get from the rye) to stand up to the steak that is to come.

Speaking of the steak, you can go a number of different ways when it comes to the type of cut you are looking for. For Lomonaco, a dry-aged New York Strip steak can’t be beat when pairing it with a Manhattan. You’re going to get full beef flavor, he says, and that will complement the sweetness of the drink.

Porter House
Photo Courtesy of Porter House Bar and Grill

Nugent, on the other hand, favors a Cowboy Ribeye, as they have at Porter House Bar & Grill. The rye, he says, “helps cut the fattiness of the ribeye and leaves the palate clean and ready for another bite.”

Why wouldn’t you want a drink that goes down easy (too easy, sometimes) and also helps you get ready for the next bite of a delicious steak?

Editors' Recommendations

Sam Slaughter
Sam Slaughter was the Food and Drink Editor for The Manual. Born and raised in New Jersey, he’s called the South home for…
We found a really clever use for sous vide nobody talks about
One clever Reddit user figured out a surprising use for the versatile sous vide machine
Honey dipper and honeycomb on a table

You've probably heard of the hottest "new" cooking method, sous vide — though it isn't actually new at all. It turns out that many restaurant chefs have been using this technique for ages to achieve the most consistently delicious, perfect-every-time cooking for their dishes.
Only recently have home cooks been able to take advantage of this rather modern cooking method, and it seems the recipe world has caught fire with new sous vide tips and tricks on every cooking website and blog in town. But if you're still unfamiliar with the trendy cooking method, you're not alone.

What is sous vide cooking?
Though the process may seem rather complicated and scientific, it's really quite simple to understand. The term sous vide is French, which translates to "under vacuum." In other words, food is vacuum sealed in a pouch, and then cooked in a temperature-controlled water bath.
Why is sous vide cooking useful?
Chefs and home cooks alike love to sous vide for a few reasons. One reason is for the consistency it offers. With traditional cooking methods, exact temperatures are nearly impossible to set; let alone duplicate each time you cook a particular dish. With sous vide cooking, you can set a precise temperature and that's how your dish will cook every time -- giving you the consistency you're after. The water bath and vacuum seal also allow your food to cook in its own juices, and this creates a much more tender and flavorful dish each time.
Using a sous video device to decrystallize honey
by u/cruftbox in Beekeeping
What can I cook in a sous vide machine?
The versatility of foods you can prepare in a sous vide machine is arguably unparalleled by any other kitchen appliance. You can use this machine to make vegetables, meat, chicken, pork, fish, eggs, and even desserts.

Read more
Star Wars drinking game rules you can use for all the movies
These drinking game rules will ensure that the Force of intoxication is with you, whether it's May the Fourth or not.
star wars drinking game rules cocktails death feature image

May the Fourth may come just once a year, but celebrating everything that Star Wars has given us shouldn't be confined to a single day. You should feel free to rewatch your favorite Star Wars films whenever you want, especially since they're so conveniently located on Disney Plus.

As fun as lounging and binge-watching is in and of itself, you might find that adding alcohol to the equation really spices things up. This is why movie drinking games are a great way to take any film you've already seen and add a whole new level of entertainment on top of it. With 11 different movies to choose from, we thought it best to create one list of Star Wars drinking game rules to rule them all. So whether you're starting with the original trilogy or jumping ahead to The Force Awakens, here are some drinking guidelines to try to stick to throughout.

Read more
The very best airport watering holes, from LAX to JFK
Flying this travel season? We suggest a good drink at one of these outstanding airport bars
A beer pint at the airport.

Travel season is upon us, which means moseying through an airport en route to a special trip or vacation. That process is made all the better with a quality drink.

Fortunately, today's airports are pretty generous when it comes to quality food and drink options. Yet, with so many terminals and slim windows in between flights, it pays to know exactly where you are going. So we rounded up the best watering holes in some of the busiest airports in the country.

Read more