Skip to main content

With a ‘Kentucky Affogato,’ Derby Day Has Never Been So Sweet

Woodford Reserve

The Kentucky Derby may be known as the most exciting two minutes in sports, but for attendees it’s a never-ending party measured in mint julep highball glasses. The drink, comprised of mint, bourbon, and simple syrup, is so ubiquitous at the event that it’s almost a cliché, which leaves the field wide-open for creative alternatives to an old standard. So on Saturday, let us suggest a sweeter alternative: the Kentucky Affogato.

Related Guides

Recommended Videos

For this one, Woodford Reserve Brand Ambassador and Brooklyn resident Michael Toscano harks back to his days as the head bartender for the West Village’s Dante, an Italian aperitif restaurant, for which he concocted an early iteration. “It’s starting to get warm, everybody’s outside, and who doesn’t like a good ice cream float?” he tells The Manual.

To call the Kentucky Affogato a “cocktail” can only cause division, as its components could arguably classify it as a boozy dessert. Bourbon whiskey floats a scoop or two of vanilla ice cream, and over top, a warmed, mint-infused simple syrup melts the whole thing down into sweet, milky goodness. Garnished with more fresh mint, it’s as pleasant on the stomach as it is to the nose and eye.

The jury may still be out on how exactly to classify this drink, but the concoction is another delicious way to enjoy bourbon come Kentucky Derby. Like the race itself, it’s all about the horses, and when it comes to a seasonal drink, one can’t go wrong with bourbon whiskey.

The Kentucky Affogato

By Michael Toscano, Woodford Reserve Brand Ambassador

Ingredients:

  • 1.5 oz. bourbon whiskey
  • .5 oz. mint-infused simple syrup (see below)
  • 1 to 2 scoops vanilla bean ice cream
  • Fresh mint
  • Grated dark chocolate or nutmeg (optional)

Method: 

  1. Over a stovetop and with low heat, simmer simple syrup with fresh mint leaves to taste (Toscano recommends 10 stemless leaves for 10 minutes as a baseline)
  2. In a dessert bowl or special coupe glass, pour in bourbon
  3. Spoon out one or two healthy scoops of ice cream into the dish
  4. Drizzle mint-infused syrup over the ice cream, allowing partial melting
  5. Garnish with a sprig of mint, and grate nutmeg or dark chocolate if desired

What You Need to Know

Most people know the traditional affogato as an espresso drink and may be thrown for a loop when this recipe doesn’t include it. “Affogato means ‘drown’ in Italian,” says Toscano. “In the sense of this cocktail, the hot syrup is melting the ice cream into the whiskey.” The bite of the bourbon pairs well with the rich, milky sweetness of a quality vanilla bean ice cream. For those really looking to lean in to the traditional mint julep theme, simply simmer the syrup longer and with more mint. “The longer it simmers, the more flavor you’re going to pull out of it,” he says. Finally, when considering ways to punch up the drink/dish, consider toppings that offer bold scents, or aromatics. These include nutmeg: “It’s going to add; it doesn’t distract from the flavor,” he says.

Read more: History of The Mint Julep

Jon Gugala
Features Writer
Jon Gugala is a freelance writer and photographer based in Nashville, Tenn. A former gear editor for Outside Magazine, his…
Topics
Fresh hop beer season is upon us
IPA heads rejoice
Hops gardening

With September just around the corner, that can only mean one thing for craft beer enthusiasts. Fresh hop season is officially here and west coast breweries up and down Interstate 5 are releasing beers featuring the aromatic ingredient. Most often, they come in the form of vibrant IPAs, but just-picked hops figure into a number of beer styles, not to mention the work of regional cider houses as well.

For fans of IPAs and a pleasant kick of bitterness in their beers, there's hardly a better time of year. From now through September, brewers will usher in hops from the most recent harvest and turn out beers that spotlight their unique qualities. Award-winning Breakside Brewery is Portland has kicked things off with a fresh hop version of its Wanderjack IPA.

Read more
From George Washington to modern distilleries: Bourbon’s all-American journey
The surprising history of bourbon and why it’s more American than apple pie
Whiskey barrels

If you didn’t know it already, September is Bourbon Heritage Month. It was officially declared in 2007 by the U.S. Senate after being sponsored by Kentucky Senator Jim Bunning. Each fall, it’s celebrated to pay homage to America’s “native spirit” and its historical value, and the importance of the bourbon industry.

In my alcohol writing career, I’ve enjoyed countless glasses of bourbon. And while I’ll definitely sip my fair share of bourbon in September, to truly get the most out of this important month, it’s a good idea to learn a little about the history of this truly American form of whiskey, along with the stories and legends surrounding it.
An American legacy of Bourbon

Read more
Even organic coffee isn’t always clean — what you need to know (and how to shop smarter)
Is organic coffee as clean as you think?
Cup of coffee

The Clean Label Project, an organization committed to exposing hidden risks that don't appear on labels, just released a new study on caffeinated coffee, which may surprise many coffee drinkers. The newly published study tested 57 coffee products from 45 of the industry's top-selling brands and found industrial and environmental contaminants in many coffee products that were labeled as organic.

Researchers detected traces of AMPA, a glyphosate byproduct, in 100% of organic samples, despite its use being prohibited in organic farming (yes, you heard that right). To learn more about the impact of this alarming organic coffee study, I got the scoop from Molly Hamilton, Executive Director of Clean Label Project. Here's what she thinks consumers should know about the impact of this study and how to adopt a smarter way of shopping for coffee.

Read more