Skip to main content

This marshmallow recipe is so simple (and homemade marshmallows are so much better than store-bought)

This is the marshmallow recipe you need

Hot chocolate served in vintage mugs with marshmallows
Istetiana / Getty Images

Hot chocolate season is upon us, and that means marshmallows. Soft and pillowy, bouncy and sweet, tender, chewy marshmallows. Maybe it’s just us, but even with the summertime s’more craze, winter seems to be the true marshmallow season. There’s just something delightfully wintery about a marshmallow’s pure white sweetness, perfectly complimenting so many warm and cozy treats.

Three cups of Aztec hot chocolate with marshmallows and cinnamon sticks on a table.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

And sure, you can always buy a bag of one of the store-bought varieties. They’re cheap and convenient, and these days come in a wide variety of flavors, colors, and shapes. But homemade marshmallows are precisely one million times better than any bagged version you can pick up at the store. And chances are, they’re a whole lot easier to make than you think.

Recommended Videos

So this winter season, why not adopt a new kitchen skill and learn to make your own homemade marshmallows? Not only do they taste better, but they’ll last forever in your pantry, and make for perfect holiday gifts. Make a big batch and hand them out to neighbors, coworkers, teachers, and your favorite barista this holiday season. Keep reading and feast your eyes on the perfect recipe to make marshmallows.

Homemade marshmallows
The Flavor Bender

Homemade marshmallow recipe

(From The Flavor Bender)

This fantastic marshmallow recipe from The Flavor Bender is exquisite. These marshmallows are perfectly balanced, sweet-but-not-too-sweet pillows of pure heaven. Their bouncy consistency somehow defies physics and melts away in your mouth. Furthermore, their ability to take on different flavors with a quick swapping of extract gives you an enormous assortment of flavored marshmallows with just this one simple recipe.

Homemade marshmallows
The Flavor Bender

Homemade marshmallow tips and tricks

  • When cooking your sugar syrup, it’s important that no sugar crystals remain on the sides of your pot. Use a pastry brush to clean the sides of the pot and make sure there are no rogue sugar crystals outside of the mixture.
  • A candy thermometer is pretty crucial in making marshmallows, but be sure to secure it to your pot correctly. If you touch the bottom of the pot, you’ll get an inaccurate temperature read. Be sure that the probe is in the syrup, but not touching the bottom of the pot.
  • Never rush the gelatin blooming process. Gelatin needs enough time to hydrate thoroughly to prevent undissolved pieces of gelatin from bobbing about in what should be a smooth-textured marshmallow.
  • Obviously, the smaller the pan, the thicker your marshmallows will be. This is entirely your preference; just be sure to grease whatever pan you choose properly. It goes without saying that marshmallows are sticky! It’s also a good idea to grease any utensils that will come in contact with your marshmallows- knives, scissors, cookie cutters, etc.
  • This recipe to make marshmallows will give you a perfectly traditional, classic vanilla marshmallow. However, feel free to substitute vanilla extract for any other flavoring you’d like. Peppermint makes for a very festive and delicious holiday treat. But be creative here!
  • Always store your finished marshmallows at room temperature in an air-tight container. If put into the fridge or freezer, they will harden, and their perfectly pillowy texture will be lost forever.
Cinnamon
Angelos / Wirestock / Adobe Stock

Can you make flavored homemade marshmallows?

Yes, you can absolutely get creative and make flavored homemade marshmallows. There are many ways to flavor your DIY marshmallows, but some of the most popular methods include:

  • Adding extract: This is the simplest way to flavor your marshmallows. Add 1/2 teaspoon of your favorite extract to the marshmallow mixture before beating it. Some popular extract flavors include vanilla, almond, peppermint, lemon, and orange.
  • Using fruit puree: For a more intense flavor, you can use fruit puree to flavor your homemade marshmallows. Add in 1/4 cup of your favorite fruit puree to the marshmallow mixture before mixing it. Some fruit puree flavors to try include strawberry, raspberry, blueberry, and mango.
  • Adding spices: You can also use spices to flavor your marshmallows. Some popular spice flavors are cinnamon, nutmeg, ginger, and cloves. To add spices to your marshmallows, add 1/4 teaspoon of your favorite spice to the marshmallow mixture before beating it.
  • Using chocolate: Chocolate is a classic flavor that pairs perfectly well with marshmallows (like s’mores). To make chocolate marshmallows, add 1/4 cup of cocoa powder to the marshmallow mixture. You can also add chocolate chips to the mixture for added flavor and texture.
Topics
Lindsay Parrill
Lindsay is a graduate of California Culinary Academy, Le Cordon Bleu, San Francisco, from where she holds a degree in…
The best fall sangria recipes: Get into the spirit with this boozy autumn drink
How to make the best fall sangria cocktails
Autumn harvest fall sangria

There's something about a festive drink that matches the mood to get you into the spirit of whatever you happen to be celebrating. A frosty margarita just makes you want to throw on a swimsuit and hit the pool. A flute of bubbly champagne often invokes our inner Gatsby as we raise toasts in our finest cocktail wear. A cold beer is appropriate on many occasions, but especially at a baseball game, with a piping hot, mustard-slathered hot dog in the other hand.

And this fall sangria, complete with autumnal fruits and flavors, will put you into the most festive of pumpkin-picking moods. So, as the weather starts to cool and stores are flooded with everything orange, mix yourself a batch of these delicious fall cocktails. You can consider it a reward for all the hard work of raking those leaves.

Read more
How to make seared tuna: Tips, tricks, and a fantastic recipe
This dish is too easy not to be making at home
Sesame tuna

Seared tuna probably isn't the first thing that comes to mind when you're looking for a simple weeknight meal on the couch. There's something about this dish that feels like it just doesn't cross the threshold into our home kitchens. One that is reserved for restaurant dining only. But why? Seared tuna is truly one of the simplest things to make, and is absolutely delicious in all of its mildly meaty, soft and buttery, cool and refreshing, vibrantly beautiful glory.

We say it's time to stop fearing this fish and claim this deliciously simple yet exquisitely impressive dish for our home kitchens.
Best tuna for searing

Read more
How to make pizza: Icon Anthony Mangieri shares the secrets to his pizza recipe
Mangieri is a legend in the pizza world and is sharing some tips
Man using a pizza oven

If you're lucky enough to have tasted one of the more than 700,000 pizzas Chef Anthony Mangieri has made in his lifetime, you'll see why the New York Times called the pizzas he produces at Una Pizza Napoletana the best pizza from a sit-down restaurant in all of New York City. Just think about that for a moment. The best. Pizza. In New York City. You could say that's like finding the best baguette in Paris or the finest Texas ribs, but frankly, it's even higher praise than that.

How does Mangieri manage to make such amazing pizza? He started young. Born and raised in New Jersey, the Italian-American chef was already making pizza when he was a kid, inspired by his regular family trips to Italy. In the early 90s, he opened a bread bakery in his home state.

Read more