Skip to main content

Dewar’s Scratched Cask: Bridging the Gap Between Bourbon and Scotch

dewars scratched cask bridging the gap between bourbon and scotch whiskey header
Dewar’s White Label Scotch Whisky is, in a word, iconic. Around since 1899, generations of scotch drinkers have sipped and shared the beverage, making it the most awarded blended Scotch whisky in the world. Over time they’ve slowly added other whiskies to their portfolio (the particularly delicious Dewar’s 15 Year Old and 18 Year Old come to mind), but in their latest effort, Dewar’s is taking on a brand new market: bourbon drinkers.

Dewar’s Scratched Cask is a blended Scotch whisky that borrows from bourbon tradition of scratching the inside of the cask to enhance the flavor or the liquid. We sat down with Dewar’s Brand Ambassador Gabe Cardarella to find out more about Scratched Cask and why the scotch giant has chosen to borrow from their bourbon brethren.

Related Videos

Dewar’s has been around for quite a long time, but this is the first time in their history that they’re borrowing from bourbon. Why?

The whisky category is such an exciting one right now. What you’re seeing a lot of brands doing is innovating to add new characteristics to already great liquids. [One of the ways] we’ve chosen to do that is with Scratched Cask.

How is it different than other Scotch whiskies out there?

GC: The word ‘scotch’ evokes certain things for people. When most people think of scotch they think of old men sitting by the fireplace with their buddies. You’re not allowed to smile when you drink it, and you can add a tiny dash of water if you like, but that’s it. And it’s true that there are other whiskies out there that epitomize what people think of scotch—they’re peated and they’re a bit aggressive. Some of those whiskies do scare people off. We wanted to make a whisky that was a bit more accessible to [bourbon drinker’s] palates.


Take me through the process that produces Scratched Cask.

We take Dewar’s White Label, which is comprised of up to 40 different whiskies from around Scotland, and we put it in first fill bourbon casks. While it’s true that most whisky in Scotland is aged in bourbon casks because they’re inexpensive, they’re second and third fill casks. They’re not drawing out the big vanilla flavors. We use American oak that has only had bourbon in it for two years. It’s the first time the barrel has ever seen scotch in it. The finishing, which for all intents and purposes is what we’re doing with White Label, doesn’t stop there. We put it in these casks for around three months—it’s up to our master blender Stephanie Macleod (who is only the seventh master blender since John Dewar started the company) to decide when it’s done.

What we found is because it was American oak and because it was a first fill bourbon cask, that it was really, really oaky and but it also brought in the peated characteristics of White Label.

Related: The Best Whiskies Under $20

So you’ve taken White Label and let it sit in the first fill bourbon casks. Where does the scratched part of Scratched Cask come in?

The char layer on every other stave of wood in these casks was scratched. Not a lot—we’re talking a one millimeter long scratch—and what we found was that it allowed much more vanilla character to be drawn out in those three months.

It’s really unique for us. The scratch technique isn’t proprietary to us, but we’ve never done this with one of our blends before in terms of a finishing. You really only see single malt whiskies playing in the finishing game. For us to do it is a great approach to bridge that gap between bourbon and scotch.

What’s the best way, would you say, to drink Scratched Cask?

The best approach for this is as a bourbon drink. Drink this whisky however you’d drink your bourbon, or any whiskey for that matter. There truly are no rules to how to drink it. For me, I think it’s amazing on the rocks. This whiskey makes a killer Old Fashioned, too.

Editors' Recommendations

12 Best Whiskey Glasses to Elevate Your Drinking Experience
Uncommon Green Maps Glass featuring map of Anchorage, Alaska.

Whiskey is the sophisticated man's drink of choice. Especially in the colder months of winter and early spring, a glass of whiskey neat warms the spirit. The complex aromas, the wide-ranging flavor profiles, the varying origins, and the rich traditions are all reasons why it's a spirit that deserves special accessories. In a nutshell, if you're drinking any type of whiskey out of standard bar glassware, you could be doing yourself and your high-priced booze a disservice.

Whether you're a whiskey snob or only occasionally indulge in a nightcap of bourbon or scotch, it's essential to know how to drink whiskey properly. It's also good to know your options regarding the different vessels available to elevate your whiskey drinking experience. There's a staggering amount out there to choose from. Some are aesthetically pleasing, some are designed based on the science behind the spirit — giving you the best experience, and some are a little of both. We'll get into how to choose the perfect glass for your specific needs a little later. But first, let's go over some of the best whiskey glasses we found out there.

Read more
Cheers to Bourbonism and How It Shapes Louisville Culture
Louisville Mayor Greg Fischer toasts a glass of bourbon to Louisville's 'Bourbonism' growth.

As the mint julep is the drink of choice at the upcoming Kentucky Derby, its main ingredient, bourbon, is Louisville’s characteristic cultural libation. As the home of the Derby, the city even instituted Bourbonism, an economic development plan to drive downtown tourism and business growth.

Upon arrival at the Muhammad Ali International Airport, visitors can partake in the bourbon experience with options in the terminal. Downtown, an 11-foot barrel art installation marks the entrance to the Bourbon District. Beyond, Louisville serves up 10 distillery experiences, many included on the Urban Bourbon Experience, a city trail stuffed with award-winning micro-distilleries, exhibits, and craft cocktail destinations. On a revitalized Main Street, restaurants serve up delicious enough edibles to find themselves ranked among Southern Living’s Top 10 Food Cities in the South. The drinks, of course, are world-class as bartenders compete to develop the most imaginative, entrancing bourbon cocktails.

Read more
The 9 Best Whiskeys for Making a Bar-Worthy Old-Fashioned at Home
An Old Fashioned whiskey cocktail at a bar.

There are two schools of thought when it comes to the iconic Old-Fashioned cocktail. The first believes the drink requires the best whiskey you can find, as with few additional ingredients, there's not much in the way of masking the spirit. The second believes the addition of sugar, bitters, and citrus and can make even the most basic or foul whiskey drinkable.

We fall somewhere in between: Thirsty for quality, but well aware that the finest whiskeys should probably be enjoyed neat. A standup Old-Fashioned is informed by your whiskey selection but not fully dependent on it stealing the show. The drink, after all, was developed in the late 19th century during mixology's simpler era. It is what its name suggests.

Read more