Skip to main content

Ford F-150, Ram 1500, and Chevy Silverado 1500 pickup trucks get poor ratings on IIHS backseat safety test

How do large pickup trucks measure up on safety?

Ford F-150 gets poor rating on IIHS backseat safety test test.
Courtesy IIHS / IIHS

The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) recently reported distressing news about large pickup trucks. The Ford F-150, Chevy Silverado 1500, RAM 1500, and Toyota Tundra crew cab pickups had good results overall in crash tests, but the trucks did not do as well on a test that focuses on backseat passenger protection.

How did the pickup trucks fare?

When the IIHS crash tested 2023 crew cab versions of the Ford F-150, Chevrolet Silverado, Ram 1500, and Toyota Tundra, the trucks earned acceptable to good ratings in side crash tests but didn’t do well on a moderate overlap front crash test. The latter test assesses injury risk to adults and children in the back seat.

The institute’s research showed the risk of fatal injury with newer vehicles was greater for passengers wearing seat belts in the back seats than for people belted and seated in the front seats. As a result of that finding, the IIHS developed the new moderate overlap test in 2022.

The IIHS stated that the difference was due not to downgraded backseat safety but to safety improvements for front seat passengers. Enhanced airbag technology and advanced seat belts found more commonly in front seats than the back lowered the risk for the driver and front seat passengers. The upgraded seatbelts and airbags are seldom available for backseat passengers.

In the IIHS testing, backseat passenger safety was rated based on the risk of injury to a test dummy placed upright behind the driver. The test dummy in the driver’s seat was the size of an average adult man, and the dummy in the second row was the size of a 12-year-old child or a small woman.

The crash test assessed the risk of injury to the dummy’s head, neck, chest, or thigh. During a crash, the dummy should not “submarine” or slide beneath the safety belt. For greatest protection, the shoulder belt shouldn’t move out of position, and the backseat dummy’s head shouldn’t get within a dangerous distance from the front seat’s back.

In the updated moderate overlap front crash test, the dummy in the front seat was well protected. All four crew cab trucks had issues with backseat passengers submarining. Also, the Ford F-150, Ram 1500, and Chevy Silverado 1500 had seatbelt forces that were too high. The Toyota Tundra did not put excessive pressure on the belts.

Measurements from the rear passenger dummy in the Ford F-150 and the Ram 1500 showed the most likely chance of chest, neck, and head injuries. The Silverado 1500’s test results were also excessive but not as high as the Ford or Ram. The Tundra’s risk of head or neck injury was minimally higher, but the risk of chest injury due to poor belt position was excessive. As a result of the testing, the Ford F-150, Chevrolet Silverado 1500, and Ram 1500 were rated Poor, and the Toyota Tundra was rated Moderate on the updated Moderate overlap front test for large pickup trucks.

In a related side crash test, the Ford F-150, RAM 1500, and Toyota Tundra received a Good overall rating for drive and rear passenger protection, but the Silverado 1500 was rated Acceptable, a lower rating due to an elevated risk of rear passenger chest injury.

The IIHS also stated that because of the risks from front seat airbag inflation, children are still safer in the back seat than in the front seat.

Editors' Recommendations

Bruce Brown
Digital Trends Contributing Editor Bruce Brown is a member of the Smart Homes and Cars teams. He also writes technology news…
Get this Milwaukee tire inflator while it’s 59% off for Black Friday
Someone using a Milwaukee M18 Inflator on Van

Black Friday deals are underway, and there are a lot of great savings you can land on life-saving equipment you might not have bought otherwise. One of those deals is on the Milwaukee M18 tire inflator, which you can currently get on the cheap at Amazon. It’s one of the best Milwaukee Black Friday deals you’ll find, in fact, as it’s marked down from its regular price of $310 to a Black Friday sale price of just $139. That’s a savings of $171, which is pretty substantial even for Black Friday. Free shipping is included with a purchase.

Why You Should Buy the Milwaukee M18 Tire Inflator
Whether you are working on mastering the trail or simply want to keep your vehicles ship-shape throughout the year, a tire inflator makes a worthy investment. Milwaukee has been making electric tools for nearly 100 years, and all of that experience can be found in the Milwaukee M18 tire inflator. It delivers fast, accurate inflation and it has the portability to go anywhere with you. The high efficiency motor is rated to deliver max PSI of 150, which allows it to top-off 33-inch light truck tires in under one minute. The Milwaukee M18 tire inflator is optimized for passenger, light truck, and other medium-duty tires.

Read more
Get a Lamborghini Countach for $17 (with one big catch)
A Lego Lamborghini Countach with associated driver in front of its box.

You may have laughed at us when we asserted that Lego is worth more than gold, but now we're the ones driving Lamborghinis. Lego Lamborghinis, that is. As we combed through the nearly 300 Lego Black Friday deals, we knew we had to emphasize this one a bit more. Right now, you can get the Lego Lamborghini Countach for 15% off, bringing it down to $17. It'll make a great stocking stuffer, gift to your nephews or cousins, or a great addition to your own adult Lego collection. Just tap the button below and you'll find yourself at the page to buy it.

Why you should buy the Lego Lamborghini Countach
There are two reason why you might want to get this product. The first is the highly-renowned brand. This is a Lamborghini after all. And not just any Lamborghini, but a Lamborghini Countach, famed for being 1989's fastest car. If you know someone that's about 34 right now, this can be an awesome memento of how much you care for them or a bit of well-wishing for their speedy route to success. Sports car enthusiasts that always wanted a chance to drive the one that got away are equally good recipients.

Read more
Hyundai and Amazon team up for online car sales (and no, you can’t get your car via Prime)
Hyundai and Amazon just made it super easy to buy a new car
2024 Hyundai Ioniq 6 parked outside.

If you shop on Amazon for guitar strings, luggage, and electronics, how do you feel about buying your next car on the mega e-commerce platform? At the 2023 Los Angeles Auto Show, Amazon and Hyundai Motor Company jointly announced an online sales collaboration beginning in 2024. Other car brands come later, but Hyundai will be the first brand you can buy on Amazon.

The new strategic partnership has three facets: online vehicle sales, cloud services, and integrating Alexa in future Hyundais. Amazon will begin online sales of Hyundai models on Amazon Web Services (AWS) will be Hyundai's preferred provider of cloud services for the vehicle manufacturer's digital transformation. The two companies will work together to integrate Alexa voice response into Hyundai's driver infotainment and vehicle management system.
Find my car
Amazon's new partnership with Hyundai doesn't cut out auto dealerships. Dealers will be able to list on Amazon vehicles currently available for purchase.

Read more