Skip to main content

One Kentucky Bar Bar is Selling Pappy Van Winkle at Cost for ‘Pappy Thanksgiving’

Pappy Van Winkle, the line of whiskeys that has bourbon drinkers and collectors getting as riled up as a teenager going on his first date, is about to be released for 2018 and this time, one bar in Lexington, Kentucky is doing something a little special: They’re selling the stuff at cost.

Now, if you’ve spent any amount of time around anyone who drinks bourbon, you would know that hardly anywhere sells Pappy Van Winkle at cost. You’d be lucky to get a bottle of it at a secondary market pricing in a liquor store. (It’s also why our chosen April Fool’s Day joke this year was to “give away” a bottle of Pappy 23. Sorry not sorry.)

pappy van winkle bourbon
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The bar in question is the 85-year-old Chevy Chase Inn, the oldest bar in Lexington, Kentucky. This one-day-only Pap-stravaganza, otherwise known as the First Annual Pappy Thanksgiving, will take place on Sunday, November 18. On that wonderful day, the bar will sell its entire allotment of the whiskeys. Quick, figure out how to get to Lexington.

Recommended Videos

“The prices being charged for Pappy Van Winkle has gotten out of control. So many people right here in the heart of bourbon country can’t afford to try this delicious bourbon.”

The reasoning behind the move, according to Kevin Heathcoat, one of the owners of the Chevy Chase Inn, is simple.

“We feel that bourbon this special should be enjoyed, not looked at. The prices being charged for Pappy Van Winkle has gotten out of control. So many people right here in the heart of bourbon country can’t afford to try this delicious bourbon,” Heathcoat said in a statement. “Pappy is actually one of the most reasonably priced ultra-premium bourbons when it leaves the warehouse. Our industry and the secondary market is ruining it for working-class bourbon lovers everywhere.”

Heathcoat added, “My partners and I had been enjoying some great Kentucky bourbon when our Pappy was delivered. One of us said, ‘Wouldn’t it be nice if everyone could afford to try these bourbons?’ That is when we got the idea to host our First Annual Pappy Thanksgiving. We sobered up and still thought it was a great idea, so here we are.”

chevy chase inn lexington kentucky
Chevy Chase Inn/Facebook

The bar will open its doors at 2 p.m. and give everyone in line a wristband and a number. Starting at 4:30 p.m., the first 75 people in line will be guaranteed one pour of Pappy. Once they are gone, they’re gone. The Chevy Chase Inn will, however, have a good variety of other bourbons on hand for people to drink in addition to a raffle featuring Buffalo Trace distillery swag.

The bar has not said what “at cost” is, but does that really matter? It’s going to be cheaper than anywhere else around.

Sam Slaughter
Sam Slaughter was the Food and Drink Editor for The Manual. Born and raised in New Jersey, he’s called the South home for…
Penelope Bourbon releases new American Light Whiskey
Penelope Bourbon is launching a 17-year-old whiskey
Whiskey in a glass

Penelope Bourbon was founded in 2018 and has quickly gained a loyal following while it continues to grow. Its newest release, Penelope American Light Whiskey, is part of the brand’s annual limited releases. These expressions consist of the rarest and longest-aged barrels Penelope has at its disposal.
Penelope American Light Whiskey

Penelope American Light Whiskey begins with a mash bill of 99% corn and 1% malted barley. It was distilled at the historic Seagram’s site in Lawrenceburg, Indiana, which is now known as Ross & Squib Distillery. It was matured for seventeen years in second-fill oak barrels before being bottled at a robust 138.8-proof.

Read more
Jim Beam and Keegan-Michael Key are teaming up on a limited-edition football care package
Jim Beam and Keegan-Michael Key are launching 7 stages of defeat care package
Jim Beam

Being a die-hard NFL fan isn't easy. You paint your face, put on your lucky jersey, and set yourself up in the most comfortable seat in front of your flat-screen TV. Your favorite quarterback might still throw a pick-six, the reliable kicker might miss an easy kick, and the referees might wipe out a long run with a phantom holding call. All of these things might turn your magical day of watching playoff football into a nightmare. Luckily, the folks at Jim Beam are here to help.
"7 Stages of Defeat" care package
Jim Beam '7 Stages of Defeat' Care Package Jim Beam

Jim Beam wants you to know that regardless of the outcome on the field, you should still be able to gather with friends and toast to a great NFL season. They partnered with comedic actor, producer, and football fan Keegan-Michael Key to release the "7 Stages of Defeat" care package.

Read more
Angel’s Envy is partnering with East Olivia on a Valentine’s Day gift set
Angel's Envy is collaborating with a floral brand to create a unique Valentine's gift
Angel’s Envy

Nothing says “I love you” like a well-made bourbon whiskey. The folks at Angel’s Envy know this more than most. That’s because the makers of some of the most beloved finished whiskeys are teaming up with floral brand East Olivia to launch a limited-edition Valentine’s gift set.
Angel’s Envy Valentine's Day Floral Gift Set

The limited-edition Valentine’s Day Floral Gift Set comes with everything you need to delight your whiskey-loving other half (or just keep it for yourself). The gift set includes a hand-crafted greeting card (adorned with edible flowers) that’s also a handmade floral garnish that can be used in a cocktail featuring Angel’s Envy aptly called the Amore Manhattan.

Read more