Skip to main content

Out of brown sugar? Here’s how to make your own

Here's how to reverse-engineer brown sugar to create the ultimate version

A jar of brown sugar.
Gabi Sandra/Pixabay

In all its forms, sugar plays a fundamental role in baking, but none more prominent than as brown sugar. Brown sugar often stands out with its distinctly warm caramel notes, perfect for your favorite cookies. But what if you’re out of it? While it’s readily available in stores, you can easily make your own brown sugar at home using a combination of white sugar and molasses.

Read on as we reverse-engineer this amazing ingredient to create the ultimate brown sugar at home. Here’s what you should do.

How to make brown sugar

Gather the ingredients

To make brown sugar, you’ll need two primary ingredients: White granulated sugar and molasses. White sugar is refined and devoid of molasses, which is responsible for the distinct color and taste of brown sugar. Molasses, a thick syrup obtained from sugar cane or sugar beet processing, is the key to achieving the desired result. By adding the molasses back into the white sugar, you can create the ultimate brown sugar.

Determine the ratio

The ratio of white sugar to molasses will determine the darkness and flavor intensity of your brown sugar, so it’s highly customizable.

  • For light brown sugar, mix 1 cup of white sugar with 1 tablespoon of molasses.
  • If you prefer a darker brown sugar, increase the molasses to 2 tablespoons per cup of white sugar.
  • Adjust the ratio according to your taste preference.

Combine the ingredients

  • Place the white sugar in a mixing bowl.
  • Slowly pour the molasses over the sugar. Using a fork or a whisk, blend the sugar and molasses together until well combined.
  • Keep mixing until the molasses is evenly distributed throughout the sugar, resulting in a uniform texture and color.

Adjust consistency

The moisture content of molasses can vary, affecting the texture of your homemade brown sugar. If the mixture seems too dry or clumpy, add a teaspoon of water and continue blending until the desired consistency is achieved. If the mixture appears too moist, sprinkle a small amount of additional sugar and mix well.

Store and use

Transfer the freshly made brown sugar to an airtight container to prevent it from hardening. Label the container with the date of preparation. Homemade brown sugar can be stored at room temperature for several months.

By following these simple steps, you can create your own brown sugar at home using white sugar and molasses. This convenient method allows you to customize the darkness and flavor of your brown sugar to suit your preferences.

Whether you’re whipping up a batch of cookies, glazing a ham, or sweetening your morning coffee, homemade brown sugar adds a delightful touch to your culinary creations — and now you know how to make your own if you ever run out!

Editors' Recommendations

Sarah Joseph
Contributor
Sarah is a lover of all things outdoors. With a bright sense of adventure and a heart for the mountains, she is always…
Foraging gets tipsy: How to make an old fashioned and 5 more cocktails with easily foraged items
Forage, mix, drink, repeat
old fashioned recipe with foraged items tincup spring 8

 

You might be surprised to learn this, but you don’t necessarily need to visit the produce department at your local grocery store or invest in a whole garden of herbs to make delicious, fresh cocktails. If you live near (or within driving distance) of a wooded area, you can forage for cocktail ingredients. Yes, you read that right: Foraging to make an old fashioned, julep, and other whiskey cocktails.

Read more
MLB star Mookie Betts travels with his own portable kitchen so he can eat healthy no matter where he goes
All-Star MVP candidates gotta eat right, too
Mookie Betts playing baseball

 

Even a short road trip poses challenges to eating well, with tempting drive-through windows and enticing gas station snacks at every turn. Even the most disciplined can be lured by the alluring aroma of fast food. For MLB superstar Mookie Betts, veering off the healthy eating path while traveling isn’t an option.

Read more
10 smoky scotch whisky options to make those fall campfires magical
Our favorite smoky scotch whisky brands for late-summer drinking
Campfire whisky

The end of summer is barreling toward us like a pumpkin spice-fueled locomotive. Depending on where you live, you’re likely already seeing some signs of fall. The leaves are beginning to change color, the days are getting shorter, and Halloween candy is already on grocery store shelves. Fear not, even with the eventuality that is the end of summer, we still have until September 23 to enjoy all that the season has to offer. For us, it means as many backyard campfires as possible before the weather grows colder. It also means we only have weeks left to pair our fires with a glass of warming Scotch whisky.

Nobody will blame you for complimenting the smoky fire by drinking a complex, non-peated single malt Scotch whisky. For those confused about the spelling, most of the world omits the 'e' when referring to whisky. You also might be wondering the difference between Scotch and whiskey. Well, in the simplest terms, Scotch is a kind of whisky (Americans and the Irish still use the 'e'). So that should put an end to the Scotch vs. whiskey debate once and for all.

Read more