Skip to main content

Rider Brooklyn modernized the dinner & a show experience

Feasting is our column dedicated to cooking, grilling, eating and discovering what’s on the menu across America and the world.

There’s something ultimately special about a night out at dinner and a show. Maybe it has to do with nostalgia. Before people went clubbing or made a night of sharing a pizza and hitting a dive bar (which we love, for the record), going out was a true occasion planned down to the shine on your shoes. Whether the entertainment was a movie, concert, musical, play or what have you, the night wouldn’t be complete without sitting down to a nice dinner before, after or if you were lucky, both. Nestled inside Brooklyn’s new non-profit music venue National Sawdust, Rider is revitalizing pre- and post-theater dining in its own unique way.

Cheeseburger
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Inspired by the idea of a hospitality rider, a set of requests a performer submits to a venue before arrival, the new American bistro and bar reinvents classic dishes with contemporary presentations and thoughtful ingredients. The kitchen is helmed by James Beard Award-winning chef Patrick Connolly who returned to NYC to open Rider after stints at Radius in Boston and Basso in St. Louis. He created a menu that’s meant for sharing with standout dishes like the soft egg with foie croutons, sweet sherry yogurt and caviar and an inventive take on the French dip with roasted marrow bone, prepared horseradish and black garlic jus.

Recommended Videos

Is your mouth watering yet? After checking out the restaurant a few weeks ago, we caught up with Chef Connolly to learn a bit more about his inspiration and what’s next for the Rider menu.

Fregola+Turnips
Image used with permission by copyright holder

You’ve been working all over America in cities like Boston, NYC, your native St. Louis, Philly and now at Rider in Brooklyn. How has cooking in these different locations affected the way you look at food and ingredients?

There’s always a common thread of taste from city to city. Maybe call it 60 percent of food that’s commonly enjoyed throughout America. Then there’s the 40 percent that varies from town to town in terms of cooking styles and, of course, ingredients readily available. For example, I was doing pizza for the past three years, both in St. Louis and Philly. Same dough basically. Slightly different ovens. In St. Louis, they have a style of pizza with a cheese called provel and a sweeter sauce. In Philly, they do what’s called a tomato pie. I did variations of both in each respective city. You always have to adjust for your audience.

Duck BreastRelated: This is how to pair food with cocktails

Rider is attached to National Sawdust, Brooklyn’s newest music venue with a lineup that’s as diverse as your menu. Are you ever inspired by other arts like music when creating a new dish?

I’m a music lover. I listen to music all day. Both music and cooking have rhythm, and cooking just feels more natural to music. I wouldn’t say music inspires any particular dish, but they both do combine a craft and an art to some degree. I’m inspired to just work by anyone who displays creativity and workmanship at the same time. I like to think my cooking has some elements of comfort and other elements of experimentation. Not coincidentally, I like my music, art and fashion the same way.

Many items on Rider’s menu are new takes on the classics – like the deconstructed French dip. Are there any nostalgic dishes you really want to play with next?

I wouldn’t mind messing around with a new interpretation of a fish stick with tartar sauce.

If you could cook for any musician, living or dead, who would it be? What would you serve?

I’ve never thought about it. For some reason, I think I’d like to cook for Elliot Smith – maybe a lasagna.

Photos by Adrienne Grunwald

Amanda Gabriele
Amanda Gabriele is a food and travel writer at The Manual and the former senior editor at Supercall. She can’t live without…
Pineapple cocktails are this summer’s hottest trend — these recipes are must-try
Tropical is the way to go for summer cocktails
A glass of pineapple Tiki style cocktail.

Over the last few years, the cocktail world has seen a number of massive trends. From espresso Martini recipes galore to the return of fun flavors like banana, there's been a lot of action behind the bar. After chatting with some industry folks, we're convinced one of the big cocktail flavors of summer 2025 is going to be pineapple.

Call it escapism or that long-standing love for all things tropical, whatever it may be, pineapple seems to be coming back yet again. Recently, it's shown up not just in the form of intriguing cocktail recipes but infused into liqueurs and even injected into beer. Looks like pineapple might just find a way into your favorite glass this summer.

Read more
Flashy Independence Day cocktails from Deep Eddy Vodka
Red, white, blue, and refreshing
Festive Deep Eddy shot.

The Fourth of July is tomorrow and if you don't have a signature cocktail in order yet, fear not. We've got two festive recipes from a vodka brand worth trying out at home. They're cold, colorful, and refreshing, meaning they're more than welcome on a long summer weekend.

Deep Eddy set us up with pair of cocktails befitting of the weekend, each with a trio of colors and flavors. In the end, you're set up with a beverage that can handle even the hottest afternoon as you try out some easy grilling recipes. And you can dress them up any way you like, adding cool straws or garnishes.
Declaration on Ice

Read more
The ultimate holiday weekend drink: Good Guys’ Frozen Fernet & Coke
Bitter, sweet, cold, and cola-driven
Amaro

Fernet is amazing stuff. The iconic Italian amaro adds a smack of bitterness and herbaceous goodness to your favorite cocktails, balancing out the drink at large and making it oh so tasty. And the liquid goes especially well with Coke, preferably frozen.

In the spirit of summer, we reached out to Good Guys in NYC for an optimal hot-weather cocktail. You know, the one that's the equivalent of playing in front of a gushing fire hydrant in New York City on a sweltering day. And I believe we have the drink.

Read more