Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

What Does it Take to Make an Award-Winning Cocktail? A Conversation with Tiger Mama’s Schulyer Hunton

Breakfast in Bombay
Image used with permission by copyright holder
To be an elite, award-winning bartender today, it takes a bit more than being able to pour some rum in a glass and topping it with cola. Hell, you need to be able to know more than your basic Old Fashioned and Manhattan recipes as well.

What you need, it’s becoming ever clearer as the move toward craft cocktails becomes less of a trend and more a way of life, is artistry. You need to be able to embrace both the art and the craft of bartending. Don’t believe us? Well, then listen to Schulyer Hunton of Tiger Mama in Boston, who won the Most Imaginative Bartender Competition 2016, sponsored by Bombay Sapphire for his cocktail “Breakfast in Bombay.”

Recommended Videos

So, it’s one thing to be an award-winner, but how do you get there? To Hunton, being aware of the myriad ways inspiration can strike was the key to starting.

Breakfast in Bombay Cocktail by Schulyer Hunton
Image used with permission by copyright holder

“Inspiration comes from many different outlets, be it new ingredients, flavor combinations, visual inspiration like art, and as cheesy as it sounds I’ve even dreamed of a cocktail before and had to make it,” he said.

From there, practice and repetition with refinement were key to building what would become an award-winning cocktail. It wasn’t just “one and done.” It was almost completely the exact opposite of that. For the syrup alone, Hunton said he made between ten and fifteen different iterations before trying three or four different builds of the cocktail per syrup. He wanted it, he said, to be “the best, most honed cocktail I could make.”

Making it the best he could translates to a lot of practice cocktails, mainly in the form of trial drinks for him, for his friends, and for the people that wouldn’t bullshit him when it came to what they really thought.

“No one has ever gotten better at what they do by always being told they are perfect, so I like to know when something’s not right cause then I can try to fix it,” Hunton said.

Finally, after countless trials, Hunton reached an iteration of the drink he was proud of. With the ingredients in check, the next part, the presentation (the hardest part, according to Hunton), loomed.

Schuyler-Hunton-Bombay-Sapphire-Cocktail-FB
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Most Imaginative Bartender is a completely different animal compared to other competitions. The presentation and creative side of the cocktail is miles above and beyond other competitions’ requirements.”

Hunton credits his girlfriend Michelle with helping him hone the presentation of his cocktail and prepare the verbal portion as well.

“She must have heard that presentation a couple dozen times from front to back,” he said.

With those two parts in check and ready, Hunton did his best before multiple panels of judges, finally being crowned the tenth winner of the Most Imaginative Bartender competition.

Check out Hunton’s award-winning cocktail below, and stay tuned to see who will be crowned this year’s Most Imaginative Bartender.

Breakfast in Bombay

Breakfast in Bombay
Image used with permission by copyright holder
  • 2 oz Bombay Sapphire Gin
  • .75 oz Compound Grapefruit Earl Grey Oleo *
  • .5 oz Lemon Juice
  • .5 oz Egg White

Method: Garnish with a spritz of Adam Elmegirab Teapot Bitters in the center of the cocktail. Combine all ingredients in a shaker, hard shake and double strain into a coupe glass.

*Earl Grey Oleo: Weigh the peels of 8 grapefruits, then use the same weight of white sugar and muddle these ingredients together. When the sugar has turned to syrup, add another of the same measurement of sugar and add 4 ounces of grapefruit juice. Muddle this again and once the sugar has dissolved strain out the peels. Take one cup of syrup and add 3 tablespoons of earl grey tea. Heat the syrup and tea and let steep for 10 minutes, strain out the tea syrup and then stir it back into the remaining syrup.

Sam Slaughter
Sam Slaughter was the Food and Drink Editor for The Manual. Born and raised in New Jersey, he’s called the South home for…
Holiday drinks that will get your guests talking, recommended by a sommelier
Drink picks from a seasoned Denver-based sommelier
Barolo Grill bar.

Conversation is so often sparked by good company. But an even better prompt can come in the form of remarkable wines, ones that tell the narrative of where they're made. And with the holidays just around the bend, we figured it's the perfect time to speak to some of the very best wines—ones that not only enhance great meals but speak eloquently for themselves.

Ryan Fletter is the owner and sommelier at Denver's Barolo Grill. The longstanding northern Italian restaurant features one of the most impressive wine lists you're likely to come across. Best, Fletter is genuinely fascinated with the craft, glowing like a kid on Christmas at the thought of cool Old World varietals or turning customers on to something they've never tried.

Read more
Taste the flavors of the season with these apple and cinnamon cocktails
Tasty seasonal flavors are highlighted in these cozy cocktails
California Cornucopia by Gray Whale Gin

As far as I'm concerned, it's never a bad time to enjoy a crispy apple pastry covered in baked brown sugar, cinnamon, nutmeg, and all the other bakery spices that go so well together. But it is undeniably a flavor combination that's particularly well suited to the colder months, as it invokes warm and comforting feelings when the days are dark and the weather is bleak.

So for cocktails at this time of year, you can look to the trending ingredients of apple and cinnamon for inspiration when crafting your creations. While gin might not be the first ingredient you think of with these flavors, you can add a hint of spice in your garnishes, like this recipe using Gray Whale Gin which features a cinnamon powder and star anise garnish atop a fluffy egg white foam. Or make use of bitters, like the Baked Apple Bitters found in this recipe for a Bourbon Apple delight.
California Cornucopia

Read more
Just in time for the holidays, Old Forester released Warehouse I Expression
Old Forester is celebrating the end of Prohibition with a new whiskey release
Whiskey glass

If you didn’t know it already, December 5 is the anniversary of Repeal Day, the day we celebrate the end of Prohibition. To celebrate this monumental day, Old Forester is releasing a limited-edition whiskey called Old Forester Warehouse 1.
Old Forester Warehouse I

In celebration of the 91st anniversary of the end of Prohibition, iconic Kentucky-based distillery Old Forester is adding to its popular 117 series with this timeless 11-year-old bourbon that was matured in the brand’s Warehouse I. The casks selected for this whiskey were heat-cycled for over a decade and hand-picked from the hottest floors by Old Forester Assistant Master Distiller Caleb Trigo.

Read more