Skip to main content

Want serious stamina? Study reveals whether rowing or running wins for VO2 max

It’s the VO2 max face-off: Are we lacing up our running shoes or strapping into the rowing machine?

Man sitting in gym doing seated cable row on cable machine
MAD Production / Shutterstock

When I recently tested out the Speediance Gym Monster 2 home gym machine, I began to enjoy rowing more. Not only does it feel like an excellent workout, but it also feels like this motion is stretching my back and shoulders while getting some cardio in. The rowing machine requires the activation of your legs, core, hips, back, and arms all at the same time.

Pro Olympic rowers who’ve played on the national team, like Jack Nunn, have always used the rowing machine to help with their endurance sports and with transitioning from excelling on the machine to the watertop. 

Rowing or running for your VO2 max

Your VO2 max is a measure of the maximum rate of oxygen your body can absorb and consume during exercise. This number is often used to assess your general and cardiorespiratory fitness, as well as how your lungs, muscles, and circulatory system work together to handle exercise. One of the most common ways to test VO2 max is with the 2,000-meter rowing test.

Recommended Videos

In an interesting study published in the Journal of Sports and Science Medicine, the study authors explored whether the elliptical trainer, the treadmill, or the rowing machine was more effective when it comes to VO2 max. The participants worked to exhaustion on a treadmill, an elliptical trainer, and a Concept 2 Row Erg.

Both take the crown in this study

The researchers concluded that the rowing machine was equally effective as the treadmill for peak oxygen uptake (VO2 max). The rowing machine also beat the elliptical. In that case, if you’re looking to improve your VO2 max, you could simply decide which you like best, or consider if you have access to a rowing machine.

Most gyms have a rowing machine somewhere, often lonely in a corner, unless it’s a Hyrox gym, which is helping the humble rower make a comeback.

Rowing and V02 max

The research is promising when it comes to rowing and V02 max. For example, one study revealed that people who rowed three times a week for just eight weeks boosted their VO2 max by 10%. The three weekly rowing sessions consisted of two 30-minute sessions and one more vigorous, high-intensity workout.

Another study showed that athletes achieved the same peak VO2 on both the bike and the rowing machine, highlighting the rowing machine’s benefits for the heart, lungs, and cardiovascular system.

Concluding thoughts

Many fitness enthusiasts think rowing is even more effective than running for VO2 max because it’s even more of a whole-body workout as you heavily engage your arms. People are also drawn to the lower impact on the joints. When it comes to VO2 max, it seems that both the rowing machine and running on the treadmill are effective with comparable benefits for your cardiorespiratory fitness.

Steph Green
Steph Green is a content writer specializing in healthcare, wellness, and nutrition. With over ten years of experience, she…
Topics
Incline walking or running, which is better for burning fat? Surprising study
If your goal is fat-burning, you might want to check out the latest research.
man running on treadmill

Walking is easier than running, but it still comes along with plenty of benefits. Studies show just two minutes of walking around the block helps blood sugar levels rise and fall more gradually and stabilize insulin levels. A brief 10-minute walk could lower blood pressure, and my mood always perks up when I walk my two little fluffy dogs around the block and see their wagging tails and smiling faces.

When it comes to achieving weight loss, researchers found that walking can help promote weight loss, so it’s worth setting off on foot, even if you’re short on time. Recently, researchers wanted to explore whether incline walking or running is better for burning fat. Incline walking is harder than it looks, and you’ll definitely feel your muscles working, especially those larger leg muscles.

Read more
Running or rebounding, which is better for your joints and heart? New study
Which is more efficient when it comes to the rate of oxygen consumption?
rebounder trampoline people jumping outside

There’s something childlike and fun about simply jumping up and down on a trampoline or a rebounder, which is essentially just a smaller trampoline suitable for one person. For me, jumping around on any trampoline reminds me of my childhood when we’d have a big trampoline out in the garden. My brother and I'd jump around for what felt like ages before finally wearing ourselves out.

Previously, researchers revealed that mini trampoline exercises boost blood circulation, oxygen delivery, bone health, balance, motor performance, and more. So there’s a lot more to it than just having fun and feeling a bit more like a kid again. One fascinating study concluded that vigorous exercise, such as jumping on a therapeutic mini-trampoline (rebounding), can increase lymph flow by 15 to 30 times, as well as strengthen bones. 

Read more
How many marathons can you run in six days? The Boston 2 Big Sur Challenge
A single marathon is an accomplishment, and the Boston 2 Big Sur Official Event is ramping up the challenge.
man runner marathon

Avid runners often look for ways to level up their performance and cross that finish line faster. We’ve heard a buzz about zero-drop running shoes, carbon-plated running shoes, and even sandals, special diets, protein shakes, and other tips and methods. It’s difficult to know what truly works and what’s just rapidly dwindling hype.

Tackling a marathon is a major accomplishment, but some runners are taking the challenge to a new level by participating in the Boston 2 Big Sur Challenge. So, what is this challenge, and what does it involve?

Read more