Skip to main content

Study exposes one major drawback to wearing fitness trackers

We always hear about the benefits of wearing fitness trackers, but it turns out there are possible drawbacks, too

Close-up of a man wearing an Apple Watch on his arm, health and fitness app
Tim Foster / Unsplash

Around one in five adults in the United States regularly wears a smartwatch or fitness tracker according to the Pew Research Center. We’re always hearing about the benefits of wearable health and fitness trackers, from tracking your steps and monitoring your sleep quality to helping you stay accountable and encouraging you to increase your physical activity. Wearable devices are the modern way that many people believe have digitally revolutionized the health and fitness world. Is it all as rosy as it seems or are there possible drawbacks to consider? A recent study dives in.

The study

close up of mans arm with watch checking heart rate heart health pulse
Nik / Unsplash

A study published in the Journal of the American Heart Association revealed that wearing fitness trackers to monitor heart conditions, such as an irregular heartbeat or atrial fibrillation, can induce anxiety. The researchers merged survey and electronic health record data of over 172 patients over a 9-month period to compare wearable users and non-users. 

Recommended Videos

The study results

tired man sleepy
Maskot / Getty Images

The researchers concluded that wearable users reported more atrial fibrillation treatment concerns and higher rates of symptom monitoring and preoccupation compared to non-users. 20% of wearable users experienced anxiety and always contacted their doctors when they received irregular rhythm notifications.

Too much of a good thing

Man stressed sitting down on couch
Nik Shuliahin / Unsplash

Many anxiety and OCD specialists believe that the more you attend to something, the more you train your brain to worry about it. Checking your fitness tracker on your phone can become compulsive behavior and lead to data overload, particularly if you’re not exactly sure how to interpret or manage the information. Another interesting study from the University of Copenhagen also showed that people who use fitness tracker data as if it’s a medical device often have elevated unnecessary fear and anxiety. Training for a 5K is one thing, but if constantly tracking your heart fluctuations is making you feel anxious and fearful, it’s time to consider some solutions.

Concluding thoughts and solutions

fitness tracker smart watch black on table close up
Indra Projects / Unsplash

The consistent stream of numbers and data can feel overwhelming. Take notice if you start compulsively checking your smartwatch or device. Being aware of how you’re using your fitness tracker is the first step. The next step is taking regular tech-free breaks to separate yourself from the technology. It’s always best to talk to your doctor or healthcare provider if you have any concerns or questions about your health.

From health-tracking rings to smartwatches, tracking specific data can help you achieve your goals. Still, on the other hand, these studies highlight how it can also lead to an unhealthy fixation that heightens anxiety. Perhaps what we can take from this study is that in moderation, fitness trackers can provide benefits, but if you use them too much to monitor a specific health condition like an irregular heartbeat, there are possible detrimental effects to be aware of. Digital detox, anyone?

Topics
Steph Green
Steph Green is a content writer specializing in healthcare, wellness, and nutrition. With over ten years of experience, she…
Can you trust the data your fitness tracker is giving you? An expert weighs in
Here are the answers to your questions about fitness tracker data
Man wearing EMS (electrical muscle stimulation) suit while working out

When it comes to fitness trackers, few people have more expertise than Tim Rosa. As the former CMO of Fitbit, he researched the reliability of the data they provide constantly, both individually and in larger studies.
Given his expertise, Rosa felt like the right person to approach to learn more about the reliability of fitness tracker data. He’s also deeply involved in sleep research in his current role as CEO of Somnee, so we asked him a wide range of questions about fitness tracker reliability, how sleep-related wearables are becoming part of the information equation, and the evolving role of AI in this technology. The following is everything that Rosa shared with us.

The lowdown on fitness trackers

Read more
The dangers of quick-fix fitness: What you should know about programs like V Shred
What will cause more harm than good?
Person measuring waist

​In recent years, the fitness industry has seen a surge in programs promising rapid weight loss and transformative results. An example of a program that has garnered significant attention is the V Shred diet.

I'm a personal trainer and nutritionist, and despite V Shred’s widespread popularity, I would advise caution when considering it and other such programs that are not grounded in science and sustainability. Understanding the factors that contribute to the success of programs like the V Shred diet can help you spot them and avoid them where necessary. Below, I’ve outlined everything you need to look out for!
The evolution of fitness programs

Read more
Can mental training and mindfulness improve your running performance? New study
Is sharpening your mental faculties beneficial for your overall fitness?
mindfulness man happy breathing calm relax

Is training your mind just as important as training your body? Many of us have a warmup routine that helps us get ready for exercise or a game. Before I go running, I like to do some yoga poses as well as a short dynamic warmup with moves like jumping jacks and high knees.

Recently, researchers explored whether mental training and mindfulness can improve running performance. Let’s delve into the new research.

Read more