Skip to main content

From Deadwood to Yellowstone: 8 movies and shows like American Primeval to binge next

These movies and shows will quench your thirst for more of the Wild West

deadwood hbo show
HBO / HBO

When you think about Utah, what comes to your mind first? Karl Malone and John Stockton leading the Jazz to the NBA Finals during 1997 and 1998 might be the cornerstone Utah moment for basketball nerds. Others might like to visit Utah for hiking and skiing during the cold season. You most likely think about the relevance of the Mormon religion, though. According to a 2023 study, 42% of the state’s residents are Mormon.

American Primeval is the latest big Netflix series and it gives great insights into the ways the Mormon religion gained footing in Utah during the Mormon War throughout 1857 and 1858. Starring Taylor Kitsch, American Primeval is a massive spectacle with great acting, set design, and an acute knowledge of what makes a great Western. If you’re finished binging the series, these are the movies and shows like American Primeval to watch next.

Recommended Videos

Deadwood (2004)

Deadwood
tv-ma
3 Seasons
Genre
Western, Crime, Drama
Stars
Timothy Olyphant, Ian McShane, Molly Parker
Created by
David Milch
Watch on max
Deadwood is one of HBO’s gold-standard shows from the mid-2000s but it hardly ever gets the attention of The Sopranos or The Wire. This Western isn’t going to satisfy a thirst for shootouts or cowboys in saloons, but it definitely resembles the settlement parts of American Primeval and elevates them beyond what any other show in this genre has done in the 21st century. The costume design and acting allow the characters of Deadwood to shine as they fight for survival and respect in South Dakota before it officially became a United States state. Ian McShane is one of the best anti-heroes of his era as Al Swearengen. Timothy Olyphant gets warmed up as a Western staple before heading over to Justified on FX several years later.

Yellowstone (2018)

Yellowstone
tv-ma
5 Seasons
Genre
Western, Drama
Stars
Luke Grimes, Kelly Reilly, Wes Bentley
Created by
John Linson, Taylor Sheridan
Watch on Peacock
Yellowstone has paved the way for almost every Western show on TV since its inception. With several spinoffs and a world crafted with immense attention to detail, Taylor Sheridan has set a standard for the genre that American Primeval and others on this list have followed. Kevin Costner gave the Dutton’s patriarch his distinctive personality that spearheaded the series’ great character work. The Duttons must defend their home from the everchanging American landscape as more people come West and threats come from all corners of the country. It’s a great story with even better side plots that make the series feel so vast.

Wind River (2017)

Wind River
107m
Genre
Crime, Mystery, Thriller, Western
Stars
Jeremy Renner, Elizabeth Olsen, Gil Birmingham
Directed by
Taylor Sheridan
Watch on Amazon

Another Taylor Sheridan effort, Wind River is a drama following the murder investigation of an Indigenous woman on the Wind River Indian Reservation. The discussion of rape and murder isn’t for the faint of heart, but it brings awareness to real-life issues in the Native American community related to these topics. Jeremy Renner and Jon Bernthal are excellent here. Wind River is a great example of Western storytelling that is set in the present instead of historical fiction, which will help the genre in the long run as so many filmmakers like to focus on the past i.e. Deadwood.

The Revenant (2015)

The Revenant
157m
Genre
Western, Drama, Adventure
Stars
Leonardo DiCaprio, Tom Hardy, Domhnall Gleeson
Directed by
Alejandro González Iñárritu
Watch on max

The movie that won Leonardo DiCaprio his first and only Academy Award pits man against nature as Hugh Glass tries to escape the wilderness and the grasp of a human rival played by Tom Hardy. The special effects and DiCaprio’s convincing performance immerse the viewer into the world of The Revenant in a way other Westerns can’t, although the plot is not exactly anything to write home about. This is truly a film for those who appreciate the art of visual storytelling and dedication to acting.

Bone Tomahawk (2015)

Bone Tomahawk
133m
Genre
Western, Horror, Drama
Stars
Kurt Russell, Patrick Wilson, Richard Jenkins
Directed by
S. Craig Zahler
Watch on Netflix
If you want something that is Western but with a very violent, morbid twist, Bone Tomahawk might be the movie that you need to check out next. This Kurt Russell film follows a sheriff who has to battle cannibals and other dangers to save kidnapped individuals from imminent danger. Richard Jenkins and Patrick Wilson are two underrated actors who support Russell in the movie.

1883 (2021)

1883
tv-ma
1 Season
Genre
Drama, Western
Stars
Sam Elliott, Tim McGraw, Faith Hill
Created by
Taylor Sheridan
Watch on Paramount+
1883 can be enjoyed equally whether you loved Yellowstone first or just want a great Western TV show to watch. This spinoff follows the Dutton family long before the events of Yellowstone as their conquest to capture land in Montana takes shape. American Primeval fans will love the depiction of the Western journey tropes used in this series.

Under the Banner of Heaven (2022)

Under the Banner of Heaven
tv-ma
1 Season
Genre
Crime, Drama, Mystery
Stars
Andrew Garfield, Sam Worthington, Daisy Edgar-Jones
Created by
Dustin Lance Black
Watch on Hulu
Under the Banner of Heaven is set in Utah just like American Primeval. It examines the influence of the Mormon religion on a pair of murderers who take out a mother and her daughter in the name of the Church. While not a traditional Western, this miniseries is a thorough interpretation of what the people who go to the LDS Church are capable of when they use religion for evil instead of good.   

Killers of the Flower Moon (2023)

Killers of the Flower Moon
206m
Genre
Crime, History, Drama
Stars
Leonardo DiCaprio, Robert De Niro, Lily Gladstone
Directed by
Martin Scorsese
Watch on Apple TV+

Killers of the Flower Moon is a great example of the anti-Western or the Revisionist Western in which the characters have a lot more of a gray area in defining their morality. This Martin Scorsese film looks at the oil industry conflict between Osage Native Americans and the settlers who wanted to use their resources. Robert De Niro and Leonardo DiCaprio are good, but newcomer Lily Gladstone is the star here.

Movie images and data from:
Shawn Laib
Shawn Laib is a freelance writer with publications such as Den of Geek, Quote.com, Edge Media Network, diaTribe, SUPERJUMP…
8 shows like Better Call Saul that will keep you hooked
These crime shows resemble the best parts of famous spinoff
Giancarlo Esposito in Better Call Saul

Better Call Saul started out as Breaking Bad's little brother, the prequel series that was supposed to be a nice companion piece to the best crime drama of the 21st century. After six seasons and a vivid vision executed by showrunner Peter Gould, the spinoff starring Bob Odenkirk became an equal to its predecessor and even surpassed it in some aspects of storytelling, acting, and direction.

The series follows the life of Jimmy McGill, a sleazy lawyer who slowly loses his morality as he evolves into the broken shell of a man we see in Breaking Bad. The complexity of the other characters and the way the show creates a grander universe that ties both shows together is something to behold. Somehow, Better Call Saul never won a single Emmy for its greatness despite being nominated 54 times throughout the 2010s. It often lost to shinier competitors like Succession and Game of Thrones.

Read more
7 incredible shows like 1923 that every fan should binge
These westerns are dramatic and just like 1923
Harrison Ford in 1923

1923 may be a prequel to Yellowstone, but this Western drama that takes place in the 1920s is one of the best shows in its genre all on its own. The series uses the star power of Harrison Ford and Helen Mirren to craft an immersive drama about a family trying to survive one of the most tumultuous times in American history. Themes such as loyalty, expansionism, and manifest destiny are examined with incredible precision, and it probably makes fans of the series want to find other shows that have similar qualities.

It's easy just to cop out and say you should watch Yellowstone and 1883 if you love 1923 (and you should watch these other shows that take place in the same universe), but we want to focus more on other Western hits adjacent to the show. The longform creativity allowed by TV has made the Western an in-vogue genre yet again. These are the shows like 1923 you should enjoy during your next binge.

Read more
13 shows like Yellowjackets to watch if you’re obsessed
These series provide the same thrill and horror as Yellowjackets
Lottie talks to the group in 1996

Yellowjackets didn't get a lot of audience recognition when it started on Showtime, but an addition to Netflix's roster introduced the mystery series to a vast number of newbies. The drama runs two parallel timelines next to each other with the same characters. A girls' soccer team crashes in the woods and has to turn to their worst instincts to survive. The atrocities they underwent still affect them 25 years later into their 40s, a storyline the show also gives equal screen time to.

Season 3 of Yellowjackets just wrapped up, and fans (like me) are probably wondering where they can find a similar series while waiting for a potential season 4. For a show to be like Yellowjackets, it should combine coming-of-age characters, some sort of mystery, and maybe dark humor. There are some older classics and modern shows that fulfill some or all of these requirements. These are the best shows like Yellowjackets to watch next!

Read more