Top 10 Cigars of 2018 According to ‘Cigar Aficionado’

By Chase McPeak Updated December 12, 2019

Since 1992, Cigar Aficionado has been the go-to guide for all things tobacco, which is why we pay attention when the magazine releases its picks for the top 10 cigars of the year.

“Each and every cigar that made it to the top 25 is truly outstanding — with an impressive level of artistry, build quality and craftsmanship — and their producers should be proud,” said Marvin R. Shanken, editor and publisher of Cigar Aficionado in 2018. “We are thrilled to present these cigars, which we are sure our readers will thoroughly enjoy.”

Recommended Videos

To reach the top 25 list, Cigar Aficionado‘s tasting panel took the highest rated cigars from the publication throughout the year and subjected them to another round of blind taste testing. From there, they continued to whittle down the list of only the best cigars, round after blind round, until they arrived at the top 25 cigars.

Below are Cigar Aficionado‘s picks for the top 10 cigars of 2018. Click the links to see tasting notes, scores, and a video of the taste tests.

If you’re unsure of how exactly you should be smoking a cigar, we’ve got a whole guide for that. We can also tell you how to get rid of the stink after you’ve figured out how to light up. Unfamiliar with different cigar varietals? Learn more about those here.

Now, on to the cigars!

10 Best Cigars of 2018

10. Montecristo Nicaragua Series Robusto

Image used with permission by copyright holder

9. Alec Bradley Black Market Estelí Torpedo

Image used with permission by copyright holder

8. Oliva Serie V Melani0 Churchill

Image used with permission by copyright holder

7. JFR Lunatic Habano Short Robusto

Image used with permission by copyright holder

6. Arturo Fuente Hemingway Work of Art

Image used with permission by copyright holder

5. H. Upmann Sir Winston

Image used with permission by copyright holder

4. Padrón Family Reserve No. 44 (Natural)

Image used with permission by copyright holder

3. The Wise Man Maduro Robusto

Image used with permission by copyright holder

2. My Father La Opulencia Toro

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Winner Cigar of the Year: E.P. Carrillo Encore Majestic

Image used with permission by copyright holder

According to Cigar Aficionado, E.P. Carrillo Encore Majestic’s tobaccos are “…from Nicaragua’s three primary growing regions — Estelí, Condega and Jalapa — and all of it comes together in the Majestic, a robusto of immaculately detailed flavor that ranges from oak and tea to caramel sweetness with tangy citrus pops of candied orange peel. It’s elegant, refined and nuanced from first puff to last …”

Check out Cigar Aficionado‘s full Top 25 list is available online here.

All images courtesy of Cigar Aficionado.

Former Former Digital Trends Contributor, The Manual

Chase McPeak is the former Lifestyle Editor. Chase regularly appeared on Beards, Booze, and Bacon: The Manual Podcast where…

Topics

Cigars

Culture

Broncano’s Classic Toro cigars bring bold flavors to premium retailers

Looking for your next great smoke? Try the Classic Toro

Silver Toro from Broncano Cigar Co

Who doesn't love relaxing with a good cigar? There are cigars for beginners, cigars for specific events like golf outings, and cigars that you turn to when you want a specific flavor profile. Broncano Cigar Co, founded in 2022 by U.S. Marine Corps veteran Martin Smith, just announced the official expansion of their Classic Toro line into more premium cigar shops and lounges following their debut in January. This builds on the growing momentum of the Broncano Vintage Toro, which is 20-year aged and was released in February of 2024.

The New Classic Toro offerings include the Broncano Classic Royal Blue Toro (6x52), which comes in an Ecuadorian Habano wrapper and Dominican Monteplata binder. Inside, the filler contains Dominican Criollo 98 Seco, USA Broadleaf Ligero, BVS Seco African Tobacco, and Dominican Corojo. This cigar has a bold, earthy flavor profile with a bit of spice and subtle sweetness.

Culture

Here’s why you probably shouldn’t buy a box of cigars as a gift

Plus, some cigar gift ideas that would work much better for the cigar lover you know.

La Gloria Cubana boxes from JR Cigars

As we're nearing the holidays and getting closer and closer to gift-giving season, I thought it would be a good idea to chat about cigars particularly, why you should probably avoid buying a box of cigars as a gift. Now, before we get into it, I should add that this will not apply to everyone. There are instances where giving your favorite cigar person a box of cigars would be a fantastic idea. If you decide to go through with it, good on you. It's always going to work best when you know the recipient well -- which is one of the reasons why I say avoid buying a box of cigars as a gift.

Nevertheless, it's a better option to buy a cigar sampler, pick out a few single cigars that you know the recipient likes, or just opt for cigar accessories to gift instead. Let's get into it.
Why you should probably avoid buying a box of cigars as a gift

Culture

The Boneshaker Lunatic is here — An Aganorsa-made Boneshaker cigar

The ultimate team up boneheads: Boneshaker X Aganorsa.

Boneshaker Lunatic cigar box of ten for hero

I've been waiting a while to share this news because when I first heard it, from my super secret source, I was over the moon. Aganorsa and Boneshaker have teamed up to produce the Boneshaker Lunatic.

Aganorsa is one of my favorite brands, which you probably know already if you follow my cigar coverage. But every once in a while, a brand like Aganorsa will work with another to create a unique blend. You see it often with AJ Fernandez blends -- the guy is always working with new brands. I digress. This Aganorsa and Boneshaker team-up is super exciting. Why is that special? Boneshaker is well known for making delicious, accessible smokes that don't break the bank.