Skip to main content

Tesla self-driving video? All staged, says company engineer

Fake? The 2016 video was used by Tesla to showcase how its EVs can drive on their own

While most cars on the road today offer some kind of advanced driver-assist system that lets them handle some aspects of driving, the technology was relatively new in 2016. That’s what made Tesla’s video depicting a Model X driving itself so remarkable. The video showed a Model X driving from a house in Menlo Park, California, to Palo Alto without any input from a driver (the video is at the bottom of this article if you haven’t seen it in a while).  The video was used to promote Tesla’s self-driving technology and Tesla CEO Musk quickly took to Twitter to state that the video was evidence that a “Tesla drives itself.”

Well, it turns out that the video was faked. Who would’ve guessed it? According to a new report from Reuters, the video that clearly shows a Model X driving by itself is actually a video of a Model X that’s driving by itself with technology that Tesla wasn’t offering in its production vehicles. The news comes from a transcript of a July deposition that the outlet received, which was originally taken as evidence in a lawsuit against Tesla for a 2018 fatal accident involving a former Apple engineer.

Overhead shot of Tesla Model X in a Tesla parking lot in California in 2016 video.
Tesla

The testimony comes from Ashok Elluswamy, director of Autopilot software at Tesla. “The intent of the video was not to accurately portray what was available for customers in 2016. It was to portray what was possible to build into the system,” said Elluswamy in his testimony.

Recommended Videos

To create the video, Tesla reportedly used 3D mapping on a predetermined route. Elluswamy claims that drivers behind the wheel of the Model X had to intervene to take control of the car, and when Tesla was trying to show off just how well the vehicle could park on its own, the Model X crashed into a fence in Tesla’s parking lot. When asked if the video portrayed abilities, like stopping at a red light and acceleration at a green light, that Tesla was offering on vehicles that customers could purchase in 2016, Elluswamy said, “It does not.”

This isn’t the first we’re hearing that the video is staged, but this is the first time an existing Tesla employee has gone on the record to definitively state that the video is fake. In 2021, The New York Times carried out an investigation that involved speaking with several of Tesla’s former employees who stated the video was fake.

Full Self-Driving Hardware on All Teslas

Tesla has been under fire because of its Autopilot driver-assist system. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) has reportedly looking into roughly 41 crashes involving a Tesla and its advanced driver-assist systems. The U.S. Department of Justice started a criminal investigation into Tesla’s claims that one of its EVs can drive itself in 2021 after a number of fatal accidents involving Tesla’s Autopilot system, claims Reuters. Someone has created a website called Tesla Deaths, which keeps track of all of the fatal accidents that have occurred in a Tesla. As of today, the website claims that there have been 348 deaths involving a Tesla.

Musk promised that Tesla would have a completely self-driving vehicle on sale by the end of 2017. It’s now 2023 and Tesla still doesn’t have a fully autonomous vehicle on sale – no automaker does, regardless of what they’re claiming – despite selling a package that’s called “Full Self-Driving Capability.”

Joel Patel
Former Freelance Writer
Joel Patel is a former contributor for The Manual. His work has also been featured on Autoweek, Digital Trends, Autoblog…
BMW’s 2026 iX is refreshed and better than ever — what it’s like to drive all 3 versions
More power, more range, what's the catch?
2026 BMW iX Lineup

The 2026 variant of the BMW iX has received a pretty heavy refresh, with a new look, a range boost, and performance boost across the entire lineup. The premium electric SUVs even have a new entry system, which makes granting access to your friends and family easier than ever.

Recently, I was invited to BMW's headquarters in New Jersey to try out the iX XDrive45, iX XDrive60, and iX M70 XDrive on an ambitious route that covered city driving, highways, and winding mountain roads. There was also an unintended bonus section, as a pretty severe navigational error on my part resulted in my co-driver doubling back on himself. So this may be the most thorough iX first drive out there. Possibly. Either way, I spent a couple of hours in each variant, and here's what I discovered.

Read more
GM recalls nearly 600K SUVs due to engine failure
GM engine failure recall
2023 Cadillac Escalade on a dirt mountain with the sun setting in the back.

While Tesla recalls tend to grab headlines, other big auto manufacturers aren't immune to occasional production woes. According to the NHTSA GM has just issued a recall of a Chevrolet, GMC, and Cadillac trucks and SUVs, totalling a whopping 597,571 vechiles in all.

GM is initiating a recall for specific models from 2021 to 2024, including the Cadillac Escalade and Escalade ESV, Chevrolet Silverado 1500, Suburban, and Tahoe, as well as the GMC Sierra 1500, Yukon, and Yukon XL. These vehicles are powered by a 6.2L V8 gasoline engine, which has been identified to potentially contain manufacturing defects in its connecting rod and/or crankshaft components. Such defects may result in severe engine damage or even complete engine failure, posing a significant safety and reliability risk to owners.

Read more
New survey reveals what Tesla owners really think about EV ownership
Tesla owners second guessing their purchase
Tesla group photo with Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y parked in front of charger during sunset.

Electric cars might be seen as the future, but many Tesla owners have been surprised by some of the challenges that come with the ride. From dealing with slashed tires to rising insurance premiums, the experience hasn’t been as smooth as they’d hoped. A recent survey by Guardian Service examined how issues such as vandalism, rising insurance costs, and public perception are affecting the ownership experience of Teslas, particularly for younger drivers and residents in specific regions of the U.S.

Nearly half of the Tesla owners surveyed (44%) reported that their cars have been vandalized, which includes being keyed or having tires slashed. The average repair bill is around $1,900. In the South, the problem seems to be even worse, with 46% of owners saying their vehicles were intentionally damaged—way more than the 11% in the Midwest and higher than the 21% in the West and 22% in the Northeast.

Read more