Skip to main content

5 things you should never do with your top-shelf whiskey

Things not to do if you splurge on whiskey that goes on the top shelf

Whiskey in a glass
itakdalee / Shutterstock

So, you splurged and bought that expensive bottle of whiskey you’ve eyed every time you stopped by your local liquor store to grab a new bottle of Elijah Craig Small Batch or Knob Creek 9 Year. If I’ve learned anything in the almost 20 years I’ve been writing professionally about alcohol, it’s that good things (whiskey) come to those who wait.

You waited and finally forked over the few hundred dollars (or more) that were required to get your hands on that highly sought-after, hard-to-find small batch bourbon — after all, the time was right to treat yourself. Maybe it’s your birthday, or perhaps you’re simply hosting a party and want to look like a baller. For whatever reason, you purchased an expensive bottle of whiskey. What now? Well, I’ll tell you what you never do with that expensive whiskey.

Recommended Videos

What not to do with expensive whiskey

Whiskey in a glass
Haris Calkic / iStock

Now that you’ve actually purchased a bottle of expensive whiskey, what comes next? Sure, you can just crack it open and start drinking it while you stream Black Mirror or the popular streaming show DuJour. But, if you ask me, you shouldn’t just dive right into this bottle as if it’s bottom-shelf swill. You’ll be disappointed if you finish it in a day or two and have to return to your stock of value bourbon bottles.

To help you fully enjoy your drinking experience, we’ve outlined five things that you absolutely should never do with expensive whiskey. Keep scrolling to see them all before you crack open that bottle.

Don’t just guzzle it down

Crate & Barrel The Glencairn 6-oz. Whiskey Glass
Crate & Barrel

If you spent extra cash to buy an expensive bottle, you’ll probably not want to just gulp it down. Instead, pour it into a whiskey glass (the Glencairn is a good choice) and first savor the aroma.

After you’ve taken a moment to breathe in the various scents, slowly take a sip. Let the whiskey cover your tongue as you slowly taste it. You can even smack your tongue using what Jim Beam’s Fred Noe would refer to as the “Kentucky chew.” Once you’ve acquainted yourself with the aromas and flavors of the whiskey, you can sip it slowly at your leisure.

Don’t add too many mixers

Whiskey cocktail
Ash Edmonds / Unsplash

Nobody will stop you from using your expensive whiskey as the base for a cocktail. If that’s what you want to use it for, that’s your prerogative. Just try not to add too many mixers or overpowering flavors. You spent a lot of money on this whiskey, and you wouldn’t want it to get lost in the shuffle, right?

Don’t add too much ice

Whiskey in a glass with an ice cube
timnewman / iStock

While many whiskey enthusiasts will tell you that the best way to drink whiskey is at room temperature, some drinkers prefer their whiskey a little colder. If that’s how you like it, nobody should fault you. Add an ice cube or two to cool it down a bit before taking a sip. Just don’t add too much ice, or you’ll end up diluting the flavor and losing much of its nuances and complexity.

Don’t be afraid to add some water

Whiskey in a glass
Robin Canfield / Unsplash

You might think you’re a whiskey purist because you drink your favorite bourbon at room temperature in a fancy tasting glass with nothing added to it. But if you want to get the most out of your expensive whiskey (especially if it’s cask strength or simply a higher proof expression), you’ll want to add a splash or two of water. It will help open up the whiskey aromas and flavors, even adding new notes you might not have otherwise unlocked.

Don’t drink it alone

Whiskey in a crystal glass sitting on a rock in front of a fire
Thomas Park/Unsplash / Thomas Park/Unsplash

If you spent the money on an expensive bottle of whiskey, are you really going to want to sit alone and drink it? Well-made, rare whiskey deserves to be shared with your whiskey-loving friends and family. Pour a few glasses, sip it with them, and talk about it. There’s no better way to enjoy whiskey than with others who like it as much as you.

Christopher Osburn
Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He's been writing professional
Stellum Spirits and Star Trek Spirits are partnering for an out-of-this world duo of whiskeys
You'll feel like Captain Kirk when you crack open one of these limited-edition Star Trek whiskeys
Star Trek Spirits

'Star Trek' was known "to boldly go where no man has gone before." Apparently, instead of traveling to planets in far-off solar systems, they'll fly the USS Enterprise into the whiskey world instead. That's because Star Trek Spirits, the official spirits brand of the Star Trek franchise, is collaborating with Stellum Spirits to launch two limited-edition whiskeys.

Star Trek Spirits X Stellum Spirits Whiskey Collab 

Read more
Fincasa Whiskey is the rye whiskey for rum drinkers
Fincasa Whiskey is the perfect rye whiskey for rum drinkers
Fincasa Whiskey

We love a good whiskey finished in a unique barrel. Especially when it’s finished in rum barrels. One of our favorite single malt Scotch whiskies of all time is The Balvenie Caribbean Cask 14 Year. That’s why we were so excited when we heard about the third release of Fincasa Whiskey, a rum-cask-finished rye whiskey.
Fincasa Whiskey

Based on owner Mike Martinez’s familial agricultural story in Puerto Rico, Fincasa Whiskey is a melding of whiskey and Latin American culture. Referred to as “Whiskey De La Tierra,” it begins as whiskey sourced from Indiana’s renowned MGP Distillery. The mash bill is 95% rye and 5% malted barley. After the initial maturation, this unique whiskey is finished for six months in ex-rum barrels.

Read more
The newest release of New Riff’s award-winning Single Malt whiskey is hitting shelves
New Riff is dropping its 2025 American Single Malt Whiskey this week
New Riff

New Riff Distilling is known for its award-winning bourbon and rye whiskeys, but if you haven't tried any of its American single malt whiskey, you're missing out. Luckily, the famed brand recently announced the launch of a new batch of this popular whiskey.
New Riff American Single Malt Whiskey

Made with some of the distillery's oldest barrels, the newest iteration of its American Single Malt Whiskey features whiskeys matured between 7 and 10 years. Made with malted barley using Kentucky's sour mash traditions, it featured Maris Otter, Scottish peated barley, and a "beer-inspired mash bill base on classic barleywine."  It's finished in new charred oak, de-charred toasted oak, de-charred and re-charred oak, Madeira casks, Oloroso Sherry, and red wine casks.

Read more