Skip to main content

The white oak tree is in danger, and so is bourbon — here’s what the industry is doing about it

We're making more white oak barrels than we can sustain

Bourbon barrels
Katherine Conrad/Unsplash

If you’ve ever looked into the process of making whiskey (specifically bourbon), you know that there are a lot of rules and regulations, but (on top of the ingredients themselves) there are few steps more important than the aging process. Equally invaluable is the actual wood the bourbon is matured in. While some distillers experiment with other woods for extra aging and finishing, white oak is the only acceptable barrel for straight bourbon. This is why it’s so discouraging to learn about a new report that says that whiskey makers are starting to run out of viable trees.

Something must be done quickly, or soon you might either not be able to get your hands on your favorite bourbon — or you’ll have to pay an uncomfortable amount to get it. You still don’t understand? Let’s start with a little refresher about what makes a bourbon.

How bourbon is made

While whiskey (spelled ‘whisky’ everywhere but the United States and Ireland) is made all over the world from Scotland to Taiwan and everywhere in between, you can only make bourbon in the U.S. America’s “native spirit” is also governed by a few unflinching rules and regulations.

To be considered a bourbon, first and foremost, it must be made in the U.S. It doesn’t, however, need to be made in Kentucky, regardless of what you might have heard. That being said, roughly 95% of all bourbon is still made in the Bluegrass State.

It also must be made from a mash bill of at least 51% corn (although many distillers lean much more heavily on the sweet flavor of corn and bring that percentage up). The rest of the grains are up to the distiller, with barley, rye, and wheat being popular choices.

Bourbon must be distilled to a maximum of 160 proof (80% alcohol by volume), barreled at a maximum of 125 proof (62.5% ABV), and bottled at a minimum of 80 proof (40% ABV) and a maximum of 150 proof (75% ABV).

But this brings us back to the problem at hand. Above all else, bourbon must be matured in new, charred American oak barrels. While all the other steps are important, it’s aging in charred oak that gives your favorite bourbon its memorable nose and palate of caramel, vanilla beans, dried fruits, spices, and oak.

It’s not bourbon without the oak. Even if you follow every other rule, you can’t label it as bourbon without maturing it for at least two years in charred oak. It’s as simple as that.

The problem with white oak trees

Sadly, this extremely important step in the bourbon-making process is in serious danger and has been going on for decades. This is because white oak, also known as Queras alba, isn’t doing so well. And while it’s bad for bourbon and other businesses that use white oak, we still don’t even know how bad just yet. You see, you can’t just plant a tree and then have it magically grown overnight, harvest the wood, and make barrels. Just like making whiskey itself, you have to wait for the trees to mature before they’re suitable to be cut down to be made into whiskey barrels and casks.

According to a group of researchers, industry insiders, and government agencies called The White Oak Initiative, while there are more than 100 million acres of white oak throughout the United States, around 75 percent of it is mature. And while that is all well and good for making whiskey barrels right now, it’s bad news for future whiskey makers.

According to the Initiative, competing species — like maple and beech — are primarily responsible for the lack of young white oak trees. Climate change, invasive insects, disease, and behavioral change also play a part.

If the numbers continue to decline, in a decade or so there might be real difficulty getting wood for bourbon barrels.

Luckily, there is hope for the future. Among other initiatives, the University of Kentucky announced in 2021 that it would create the largest repository of American white oak trees in collaboration with famed bourbon brand Maker’s Mark. First, they collected 300 families of white oak and began planting them at Maker’s Mark’s Star Hill Farm. Then they planted 1.700 trees, and then another 2,200 in 2022, before adding another 5,000 this past spring.

And Maker’s Mark isn’t the only one. Old Forester Distillery, Buffalo Trace, and more all have their own conservation plans in place. Here’s hoping they’re successful.

Editors' Recommendations

Christopher Osburn
Christopher Osburn is a food and drinks writer located in the Finger Lakes Region of New York. He's been writing professional
Here are the benefits of taking vitamin D supplements – what you should know
Find out if you're getting enough Vitamin D or if you need help getting more
A close-up of a vitamin D capsule

It’s not always easy or feasible to consume a well-balanced and varied diet. Between juggling a busy schedule with minimal time for healthy food preparation, food allergies and intolerances, dietary preferences, and cultural eating habits, many of us fall short of meeting the nutritional recommendations for several key vitamins and minerals. Even if you cook at home and try to eat a healthy diet, you may be deficient in certain micronutrients because some essential vitamins and minerals are only found in a few food sources or are only present in low concentrations.
Vitamin D is a prime example of a vital nutrient that is not found in many common foods in the standard American diet, nor is it necessarily well absorbed when consumed in food sources. Rather, exposure of the skin to sunlight is the primary means by which the body’s vitamin D levels are increased, as exposure to UVB rays stimulates the production of vitamin D.
However, as the hours of daylight dwindle in the winter and the sun becomes less intense, it becomes increasingly difficult to meet your vitamin D needs. Because vitamin D plays several key physiological roles, it may be advisable to take vitamin D supplements. Keep reading for our helpful primer on the functions and benefits of vitamin D, foods high in vitamin D, and whether vitamin D supplementation may be useful.

What is vitamin D?
Along with vitamins A, E, and K, vitamin D is a fat-soluble vitamin, which means it's stored in the body rather than excreted like vitamins C and B vitamins. However, unlike any other vitamin, vitamin D is actually a steroid hormone produced from cholesterol when skin cells are exposed to UVB rays. In addition to the endogenous production of vitamin D, there are two different dietary forms of the nutrient:

Read more
The differences between bourbon and brandy, explained
Brandy and bourbon are quite different

Like most aged spirits, brandy and bourbon look the same. If you’re a drinking novice and someone puts a glass of bourbon and a glass of brandy side by side, you might even have a little difficulty figuring out which is which. Both are golden to caramel in color depending on the age. The two spirits also carry some of the same aromas and flavors, like oak, caramel, and fruity flavors. That being said, the two spirits couldn’t be more different.

A very different base
Bourbon is often referred to as America’s “native spirit”. If you didn’t already know it, this is a reference to its history and cultural significance in the US. It’s also a reference to the rules of bourbon whiskey. That being that it must be made in the US (not just Kentucky). While there are various other rules and regulations, the other most important rule is that, to be called a bourbon, the whiskey must have a mash bill of at least 51% corn. So, it’s a corn-based spirit.

Read more
What is Cognac? A quick guide to the classic French spirit
Learn all about Cognac in our entry-level guide to the classic Frenc spirit
A glass of cognac served on a wooden table.

Cognac is somewhat simpler than its name suggests. The best way to understand the French spirit is to treat it like its closest cousin: wine. In short, Cognac is a type of brandy made in its namesake commune in western France.

Similar to the best wine, it is tied to a specific place on the map and must be made from a select list of grapes in a particular style. There are aging and blending requirements tied to Cognac, much like a Chianti Italian wine or Bordeaux. Further, Cognac is best enjoyed in a particular kind of Cognac glass (the wine comparisons continue) that allows you to drink Cognac the right way. Get in there and sniff and savor the stuff.

Read more