Skip to main content

Spice Up Valentine’s Day With This Deliciously Angry Arrabbiata Pizza

arrabbiata pizza
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Sappy professions of love, the exchange of hearts full of chocolate, and champagne-glass engagements aren’t for everyone. For those who don’t enjoy making starry-eyed confessions of love and affection, Valentine’s Day can be kind of a drag. But it doesn’t have to be.


After all, food is still a thing. A delicious, delicious thing that you can either share with the one you love or enjoy solo. And there are plenty of proprietors who don’t participate in the whole prix fixe thing. Take, for instance, Chef Jeff Pond, partner and chef at Area Four, a wood-fired pizzeria, bar and café in Cambridge, Massachusetts. Every year, he throws a Haters Valentine’s Day party. 

“I know people like to go out and feel special on Valentine’s Day,” he says. “I just wanted to have some fun with it.”

During Haters Valentine’s Day, Area Four offers up dishes like pizza with arrabbiata—Italian for “angry”—sauce and “slapped” pork cheeks, plays emo music and sad movies, and gives guests cheeky chalk hearts with their checks at the end of the night. This year, he says, the arrabbiata sauce pizza is particularly exciting, because he’s using locally-grown chilis for the sauce. “It’s going to add a little something extra, I think.”

Area Four, according to Pond, really tries to go all out for the event.

“We try to do a special experience but with a little twist,” he says.

Eating delicious food while making fun of Cupid’s favorite day? Sounds like a ton of fun—whether or not you’re attached. If you’re in the Boston area, you’re lucky enough that you can go check out the event. But if you’re somewhere else this holiday—well, you’re still lucky, because Chef Pond let us in on the secret to making angry pizza so you can throw your own Haters Valentine’s Day for you and all your friends.

Oh, and hey, just a heads up: the dough takes two days to prepare, so make sure you plan ahead! Pond’s dough is some of the best you’ll ever taste. The time and effort will be worth it—trust us.

arrabbiata pizza
Image used with permission by copyright holder


Sourdough Pizza Dough

1 ½ cups sourdough starter

4 cups unbleached baking flour (preferably one containing malted barley)

3 ½ teaspoons kosher salt

1-1 ½ cups 70° water

  • In a stainless steel bowl add your water and starter. Mix by hand until combined.
  • Have a separate bowl of room temperature water next to you for you dipping your hands.
  • Add your flour to the starter mixture.
  • Dip your hands in the bowl of water periodically to keep the flour from sticking.
  • Fold the loose flour mixture from the center of the bowl in on itself.
  • Continue mixing the dough for 10-15 minutes to develop some of the gluten. This process can also be done in stand mixer equipped with a dough hook.
  • The dough will be loose by the end of 10-15 minutes. Cover the bowl and allow it to proof in the refrigerator for 24 hours.
  • The next day, remove from the fridge, wet your hands, and put on a lightly floured surface.
  • Cut into four 10 ounce balls. Work the dough into balls and place in a baking pan with sides.
  • Cover with plastic and put back in the refrigerator for 12-24 more hours.

Sauce Arrabbiata

24 grams garlic, minced

5 grams fresh oregano, chopped

3-4 fresh red jalapeños, seeded and sliced thin

1-2 green jalapeños, seeded and sliced thin

1 ½ tablespoons salt

1 ¼ cups extra virgin olive oil

1  can Alta Cucina San Marzano tomatoes, drained, excess liquid squeezed out of tomatoes, juice reserved

  • Very lightly toast garlic, red and green jalapeños in  ½ cup of extra virgin olive oil over low heat in heavy-bottom pot.
  • Add oregano and let cool.
  • In the meantime, chop the tomatoes.
  • Add salt and remaining olive oil to reserved liquid.
  • Combine ingredients.


1 red, green and yellow bell pepper each

2 shallots, peeled and sliced into ¼ inch rings

4-5 oz. of shredded provolone picante

2 large farm eggs

chopped parsley, for garnish

  • Seed and julienne all three bell peppers in ½ inch strips.
  • Toss the bell peppers and shallots with 2 tablespoons extra virgin olive oil.
  • Roast peppers and shallots for 4-5 minutes in oven (about 450-500 degrees) then let cool.
arrabbiata pizza
Image used with permission by copyright holder


The Dough

  • Preheat your wood oven to 600-650 degrees. (If you don’t have a wood oven, no worries! You can still use a conventional oven. Fire that puppy up to 500 degrees, and make sure you have a pizza stone. It’ll mimic the bubbly crust of a wood-fired pizza, and the porous surface will draw out moisture, so you’ll get a nice crispy effect.)
  • Temper your pizza dough for 30 minutes prior to use. (This just means to let it get to room temperature before you throw it into the oven.)
  • Once ready, use a bench knife to lift 1 dough ball out of your pan and into a generous pile of flour. Flip the dough over to coat the entire thing in the flour.
  • Using floured hands, press the air from the center of the dough ball out towards the edge leaving a ½ inch around the perimeter untouched.  Continue pressing out the center of the dough, until you have achieved a 12” circle.
  • Lift the dough onto a pizza peel (or pizza stone, if you’re using a conventional oven) and brush off any excess flour.

The Toppings

  • Ladle 3 oz. of sauce onto the center of the pizza, and work around the interior diameter of the dough until it is evenly spread, with enough room for crust.
  • Sprinkle your provolone onto the sauce.  Strategically lay your bell pepper and shallot mix on top of your provolone. A little goes a long way, and too much will not allow you to cook the pizza properly.

The Heat

  • Shimmy your pizza into your preheated hearth (or oven!) and allow to rise and begin to color before you attempt to move it.
  • Once it starts to rise, slide the pie toward you and crack the eggs onto opposite sides of your pizza.
  • Slide back toward your fire (or other heat source), spinning periodically to create even toasting and blistering.
  • As your pizza starts to look close to done, pull the pie toward the mouth of the oven and cook away from the fire to set the ingredients a little more.  Your eggs should be set but the yolks should be runny.


Pull that baby out of the oven onto a cooling rack, to allow the steam to dissipate. You don’t want the crust you just worked so hard on getting soggy. Break your yolks and season with some salt and pepper. Sprinkle with dried chilis, parsley and grated pecorino romano if you prefer.

Slice and enjoy! Emo music and sad movies optional.

Lisa Dunn
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Lisa Dunn is a writer with a background in investigative journalism and a love of tailored suits. Born and raised in New…
The 10 best sweet treats for your Valentine’s Day celebration
These desserts are perfect for sharing with your Valentine
Inside Out Red Velvet Cookies

Some folks love Valentine's Day, spending the day with your special someone, fully embracing the hearts and flowers of it all. Others take great pride in declaring it a commercial greeting card holiday, and rebelling against the societal pressures set upon them. But no matter how you look at the day, it has one benefit for all: it's an excuse to make really good desserts. These 10 Valentine's Day dessert recipes range from entry-level to expert offering sugary bliss to cooks and bakers of any level. They also vary in prep and cook time, so no matter how busy you are you'll be able to whip one of these up no problem.

These Valentine's Day desserts would be great after a delicious Valentine's Day dinner or while watching a Valentine's Day movie.
Related Guides

Read more
Valentine’s Day calls for the very best Champagnes: Our top picks
Valentine's Day calls for real, true blue Champagne. Here are some great options to crack with those you love.
Champagne in glasses

Champagne and Valentine's Day go together like Daniel Day Lewis and Oscar nominations. And while there's great sparkling wine to be enjoyed, increasingly so here in the states, a holiday as romantic as this probably deserves the most iconic options within the effervescent category. Yep, real Champagne — you know, the prized and celebratory stuff from the famed and eponymous region in France.

The pop of a bottle of Champagne alone means there's an occasion at hand. Couple that with the wine's lovely texture and food-friendliness (ready the oysters and caviar), and you have a romantic evening in the making. Valentine's Day is steeped in tradition, passion, and the joy of bring together. Much the same can be said about a great bottle of Champagne.

Read more
Plan a great Valentine’s Day dinner (we’ve got recipes for every skill level)
Valentine's Day dinner: No matter who you're celebrating with this year, these recipes have got you covered
Chicken Parmesan

Another Valentine's Day is upon us, and you're probably thinking about what to put on the dinner table. Whether you're flying solo this year, trying to impress that special someone, or hosting a dinner party, we've got you covered. Valentine's Day dinner and dessert are known for being a bit indulgent. Steak and lobster are frequently on the menu, often at the same time. That said, making a delicious Valentine's Day meal doesn't have to cost a bunch or take a ton of time. We've included recipes for all skill levels and hope that however you celebrate Valentine's Day, this year is a good one.

Related Articles: 

Read more