Skip to main content

Hillrock Estate Distillery Is Making Some of the Best Whiskey in America

Hillrock Estate Distillery

Before Prohibition, upstate New York was home to dozens of estate distilleries where spirits producers harvested grain grown on their own land to make celebrated whiskies and gins. After Prohibition, not only was the region left devoid of such operations, but in fact the nation was without any estate-based distillery until Hillrock Estate Distillery opened its doors in 2011.

Nestled into the rolling hills of Ancram, New York, just over a hundred miles north of New York City, Hillrock Estate Distillery sits on 100 acres of land, many of which are devoted to raising barley, wheat, and rye. (And in fact they own or lease 850 acres of tillable land in total, so watch out for expansion.) The restored Georgian house holding court over the estate was built in 1806 by a grain merchant who had served as a captain in the Revolutionary War. Today within the home you’ll find Jeffrey Baker and Cathy Franklin, the husband and wife who established and own Hillrock and who, with the help of the late Master Distiller Dave Pickerell — top of his class chemical engineer, 14 years with Maker’s Mark, the list goes on — and experienced distiller and winemaker Tim Welly, produce three whiskies that are ranked as world class spirits by leading experts on the field.

Related Videos

We’ll get to the booze in a moment. First, a few more words about what makes this place special.

Jeff Baker, who is a partner in an investment banking firm, which one suspects helped with the establishment of the distillery, had operated Hillrock as a cattle farm for years. He was committed to the local food movement as early as the 1980s. Closer to the turn of the millennium, now a married father and with even more land acquired and added to the estate, Jeff felt himself ready for “another farm-based business, and this time I wanted it to be making a real world-class product.”

He went on to explain how that product ended up being whiskey. “We did a tremendous amount of research about things one could do in our area and during that process I uncovered the fact that New York was producing something like two thirds of the country’s barley in the early 1800s. There was a real tradition of growing grain there, and there were a thousand-plus farm-based distilleries before prohibition. But no one had been doing it since. We saw the whole craft spirits movement taking off, but we saw something missing there. Estate wineries have been around growing all their own grapes to make wine, and we decided we could do the same with grains we grew.”

To make the most of the unique terroir of the Hudson Valley, Jeff and Cathy decided to make their whiskies entirely in situ. And here is where Hillrock truly stands out in the world of American spirits. They grow their grains on the acres around the distillery itself. They harvest the grain, floor malt it, smoke it, distill the spirit, and then age their whiskies all on location. Then they bottle it. By hand. The level of control the Hillrock distillers have over their product is almost peerless, and the results come through in every sip. Which is why those hand-filled bottles have a hundred-dollar price point.

Unlike with a 25-year-old Scotch where, let’s be honest, often you’re paying as much for prestige as you are for flavor, with a Hillrock bourbon, single malt, or rye, you are paying for a liquor you will love. And the pros love it, too: Hillrock’s single malt has been called the best American single malt ever and currently enjoys a 97-point rating with Wine Enthusiast.

But their multi-award-winning Solera Aged Bourbon is the distillery’s flagship, so let’s focus on it in a bit more detail. After the meticulous process covered above, this bourbon is poured into 20-year-old Sherry and Oloroso casks for aging. It doesn’t just sit there, though. The word “solera” in the name refers to a traditional yet rare form of aging wherein the barrels are positioned in a pyramid, with whiskey bottled from a portion drawn from the lowest barrels which are then replenished with younger whiskey from the barrels a tier above. The step-by-step process sees older, mature bourbon mingling with younger whiskey, resulting in a rich and complex blend that’s well worth the spend.

You can find Hillrock’s liquors at various locations throughout the Northeast, the Midwest, and in California, but the best place to enjoy a glass or two is at the distillery itself, looking out over, as Cathy Franklin describes, “the Berkshires, the Connecticuts, the Catskill … it’s truly an amazing, beautiful place.” The views are even better with a bourbon in your hand.

Editors' Recommendations

How you can help “Protect the West” with High West Campfire Whiskey
Conservation efforts help wildlands and wildland firefighters
A wildland firefighter works on putting out flames.

The National Interagency Fire Center cites 41 large fires and complexes that have burned 289,515 acres across seven states in the U.S. West so far in 2022. More than 10,100 wildland firefighters and support personnel are assigned to these incidents. While the federal Office of Wildland Fire budgeted $1.5 billion to prevent and suppress fires, and state agencies contribute millions more, it’s the nearby towns and cities that are most affected by these infernos. That’s why the Park City, Utah-based High West Whiskey is one of many local firms that contributes to preserving and uplifting its Western home.

The brand just released its seasonal, nationally acclaimed Campfire not only to satisfy loyal imbibers, but to help preserve the place where it was born through the Protect the West initiative. With Campfire’s 2022 release, High West is elevating its devotion to the people and organizations keeping the Western environment healthy and its protectors safe. Over the next three years, the spirits maker will fortify this commitment with a pledge to give over $1 million in whiskey revenue to fighting wildfires, wildland preservation, and protecting winters from climate change.

Read more
This Kentucky Distillery Will Soon Offer Pot Still Bourbon (And We Can’t Wait)
The Finished Juice Will Add to an Impressive Small Batch Collection
Preservation Distillery in Bardstown, Kentucky.

If you’re clued into the bourbon world at all, you’ll likely know that Pappy Van Winkle sits at its apex. Bottles of Pappy's whiskey often run into the hundreds and thousands of dollars. What you likely don’t know (unless you’re a hardcore fan) is that a single exporter, Marci Palatella, helped Pappy to flourish overseas as bourbon popularity ebbed in the United States in the 1980s.

In the book, Pappyland, Julian Van Winkle III recalls how in 1986, Palatella, representing her International Beverage firm, reached out to the brand to inquire about exporting the American spirit to Japan. And now Palatella is at it again, making her mark with pot still bourbon.

Read more
Going Estate in the Name of Farm Spirits
The Spirits World Is Embracing an Estate Approach to Production
A bottle of Frey Ranch Rye Whiskey in front of some grains

There's a growing estate movement underway, bringing producers closer to their ingredients. It's an approach that wine has made famous, but is gaining (or regaining) steam in other areas of agriculture, too, like the growing of grains and making of spirits. With craftspeople looking to work with what's right in their domain, the resulting work is not only tastier and more authentic, but it's also a real reflection of terroir and the flavor associated with a specific place.

Estate is something the wine industry has long celebrated. The idea is that the vines and resulting fruit on your property express something unique to that place. It could be the climate, soil, elevation, or some other factor, but because it's singular to that area, you get something singular in the glass. It's much deeper than that, of course, as estate involves more control over your farming practices and perhaps a greater familiarity with the land, but in a nutshell, this is the idea.

Read more