Skip to main content

High West Distillery Makes a Big Change to Double Rye! Whiskey

At the beginning of any distillery, a couple of things have to be established right away. Items like a name and location are obvious, but another important decision is whether or not the products you release in the first few years are going to be made by you. Many distilleries, for various reasons (chiefly among them the fact that whiskey takes time to age so you can’t just release a bourbon on day one) choose to buy product from a place like Midwest Grain Products of Indiana (MGP, for short).

MGP is a factory distillery in Lawrenceburg, Indiana that pumps out whiskey products for what seems like countless distilleries. That product is then blended by the distillery and put out under their label. This allows new distilleries to have aged products while their own spirit is sitting peacefully in barrels.

High West Distillery Double Rye Whiskey
Trevor Hooper Photo

One of the distilleries that bought product was Park City’s High West Distillery, Utah’s first legal distillery since 1870 (in addition to being Whisky Advocate’s 2016 Distiller of the Year). This year, however, they are overhauling one of their core products, Double Rye!, by using rye whiskey that was made by the distillery, at the distillery (which is close to Park City in Wanship, Utah).

This newest release of Double Rye! combines two- to three-year-old high rye whiskey from MGP mingled with pot still rye whiskey made on-site at the High West Distillery. The MGP rye has a mashbill of 95 percent rye and 5 percent barley malt while the High West rye is made of 80 percent rye and 20 percent malted rye. The previous iteration featured 2-year-old MGP rye and 16-year-old rye from Barton 1792 Distillery in Kentucky.

High West Distillery Copper Still
Trevor Hooper Photo

“The addition of our own whiskey to our blends has always been part of our plan.  As some of our sourced whiskeys get used up, we needed to make whiskey to hit the same taste profile; therefore, we have migrated into our own in-house whiskeys, which have the same effect in the overall blend,” said master distiller Brendan Coyle.

Another difference in this iteration of the whiskey compared to the previous one is the use of a pot still to make High West’s rye. This helps create a fuller character in younger whiskey, which ultimately helps maintain consistency of flavor, despite not using a sixteen-year-old product in Double Rye! any longer.

High West Distillery Double Rye Whiskey
High West Distillery

“Since the column still whiskey is aged for a long time to develop the heavier character, we can replace it with our own younger, but very full and heavy-bodied pot still whiskeys to achieve the same effect in the finished product,” Coyle said.

On the nose you’ll find mint, clove, chocolate, and some spice. On the palate, rye spice followed by mint, eucalyptus, all spice, and honey. Cinnamon, a little anise, and more mint come through on the finish.

Double Rye! is 92-proof and is available nationwide for around $35. To find the bottles that contain High West’s own whiskey, look for batch numbers beginning with “18.” You can purchase Double Rye! online here, though there’s no guarantee of which batch it is.

Editors' Recommendations

Sam Slaughter
Sam Slaughter was the Food and Drink Editor for The Manual. Born and raised in New Jersey, he’s called the South home for…
Classic Old Overholt Rye Whiskey Gets an Upgrade
old overholt rye whiskey update

Old Overholt is a classic, inexpensive rye whiskey that has been a favorite of bartenders and home drinkers for years. Originally a Pennsylvania rye that got its start in the early 1800s, the brand was acquired by Jim Beam back in 1987 and for decades has been a young (around three years old) 80 proof barely legal rye, with a mash bill containing around 51% rye, that is distilled in Kentucky. The low ABV has been a sticking point for some, especially when going up against the similarly aged and priced, but 100 proof, Rittenhouse Rye. This might have been a factor leading to the release of Old Overholt Bottled in Bond a few years ago, which upped the proof to 100 as required by the Bottled in Bond Act. But now Old Overholt is changing up a few key features of the whiskey in a way that seems like a positive development for longtime fans of this workhorse rye.

“Old Overholt is an incredibly resilient brand that has stood the test of time for three reasons," said Tim Heuisler, American Whisk(e)y Ambassador for Beam Suntory in a prepared statement. "It’s always been a quality whiskey, it’s embraced its own evolution throughout history, and it’s consistently been affordable. These updates will only better serve the bar community that first adopted Overholt years ago. We’re taking the trusted, quality whiskey that we all know and love and making mindful improvements to help it stand out even more as a cornerstone of American Rye.”

Read more
How to Make Your Own Cinnamon Whiskey at Home
cinnamon whiskey

Getting bored at home? Need something to do? Have some lower quality whiskey on hand and need something to do with it that doesn't involve simply chugging it straight from the bottle? Well, why not try infusing it? Specifically, we mean infusing it with cinnamon. It's easy, only takes a little bit of time, and at the end of the day you're left with a spirit that tastes delicious on it's own or in cocktails.

The thing about cinnamon-flavored spirits, though, is that they are not all great. Chances are you've had a night or two that ended with shots of Fireball, which was then followed by a morning-after from hell (don't worry, we've been there, too). That's because many cinnamon liquors use a variety of additives; it's also because a good many of those cinnamon-infused spirits just plain suck.

Read more
Tincup Releases New Rye Whiskey
Tin Cup Whiskey

As rye whiskey continues to grow in popularity, established whiskey brands and distilleries continue to add it to their portfolios. And many of them continue to source whiskey from the experts at MGP, the Indiana distillery that is responsible for so much of the rye whiskey out there sold under various brand names like Bulleit, Dickel, and Redemption. The latest to release a rye whiskey is Colorado's Tincup, adding it to its lineup of original (a blend of bourbon and single malt) and 10-year-old American whiskey.

The rye is distilled in Indiana from a mash bill of 95% rye and 5% malted barley, aged for three years, and cut with Colorado Rocky Mountain water to proof it down to 90. The whiskey reads as young but flavorful, with balsa wood notes on the nose and a sweet palate full of notes of freshly cut grass, soft spice, and vanilla flavors. In fact, it does not immediately comes across as your typical 95/5 rye, because of the toned-down nature of the baking spice and fruit notes that are often predominant with that mash bill. Overall, this is a good mixing rye that would work well in a variety of cocktails.

Read more