Skip to main content

A Guide to Sicilian Wines, the Best-Kept Secret of Italy

While frequently overshadowed by other regions of Italian wine, the island of Sicily actually produces some of the finest wine in the world. Home to several native grape varieties, Sicilian wine is delicious, with complex flavors that rival any wine-making region. In previous decades, Sicilian wines weren’t held in high regard, overshadowed by Italian or French wines. At that time, Sicilian wine had a poor reputation, viewed by many wine drinkers as beverages produced with an emphasis on quantity rather than quality.

According to Rob Walsh, Sicilian wine expert and Director of Fine Wine at Disaronno International, a New Jersey-based wine importer, this perception is rapidly changing.

Recommended Videos

“Now that you have people focused on quality over quantity, it makes all the difference in the world,” said Walsh. “Its hard to find a bad bottle of Sicilian wine anymore. Twenty years ago, there was a lot of bad Sicilian wine out there.”

What Makes Sicilian Wines Different?

Aerial shot of Cefalù, Sicily.
Jacek Dylag / Unsplash

The first big difference for Sicilian wines is the climate the grapes are grown in. Sicily is hot and it’s precisely this scorching weather that makes Sicilian wines unique. Typically, Sicilian wines are lighter, fruit-forward, and lower in alcohol compared to regions like Napa Valley or France. This is a direct result of the hot weather. Grapes that sit too long on the vine under these scalding conditions will literally burn up, becoming unsuitable for wine production. This means that Sicilian reds are generally not as heavy when compared to Cabernets and other dark red wines. As a climate, Sicily is also uniquely convenient for sustainable winemaking. According to Walsh, this is due to the strong winds, which remove the need for most pesticides. However, because of the heat, farming wine grapes on the island requires the use of canopies to protect the fruit from the intense sun.

Second, the island of Sicily has historically been a crossroads of the Mediterranean, influenced by a myriad of cultures and nations. Not only is Sicily influenced by the Italian peninsula, the island has also been ruled by the Greeks, Phoenicians, and Arabs, each leaving behind elements of their culture and cuisine.

Currently, the most well-known Sicilian wine is marsala. For most people, this fortified wine usually shows up in mushroom-laced sauces laced with chicken or veal. But Sicily is also home to several varieties of native grapes, including reds like Nero d’Avola, Frappato, and Nerello Mascalese and whites like Catarratto, Grillo, and Inzolia.

The Recent Changes to Sicilian Wines

Hands holding wine grapes.
Andrea Cairone / Unsplash

In recent years, there’s been a revolution within the Sicilian wine industry. Wine on the island is quickly becoming more sophisticated, with a flair for innovative techniques and technology. Spearheading these changes is a new wave of young people, many of them second- or third-generation Sicilian winemakers. These young winemakers are bringing new techniques from other regions and embracing methods like biodynamic wine and experimenting with grape varietals. For a curious wine expert like Walsh, this experimentation is a logical step.

“You go to a wine shop and pop over to the Italian section, you’re going to see grapes you’ve never heard of — Perricone, all these grape you’ve never heard of,” said Walsh. “It just took one or two wine makers to go, ‘hey, here’s something different.’ Its one of those things that I found as a seller is that your always looking for something that’s going to keep you stimulated because after a while, you get bored with Chardonnay.”

Sicilian Wine Food Pairings

People eating food with wine on a wooden table outside.
Lee Myungseong / Unsplash

Historically, Sicily has been one of the poorest areas in Italy and this level of historical poverty is central to the cuisine. Meat like beef, an expensive animal to raise, is not common on the island. Instead, traditional Sicilian cuisine is heavily based on seafood and game meat like wildfowl, boar, and rabbits. Another unique element of Sicilian cuisine is the strong culinary influences from Africa and the Middle East, the result of proximity, trade, and conquest. The Arab influence is particularly strong as Sicily was under Arab rule for two and half centuries. Several prominent Sicilian dishes like cassata cake, arancini rice balls, and Sicilian couscous are just some of the few examples of this Arab culinary influence.

The result of these culinary influences is that Sicilian wines are highly drinkable and pair well with seafood and game meats. Unlike the dark reds of France, Sicilian wines generally don’t pair naturally with a fatty steak. Instead, try it with stews and other spiced dishes. As for Sicilian white wines, they possess a great salinity. Grown mostly on the western part of the island, an area that is home to salt farms and marshes. When strong winds arrive from Northern Africa, they blow over these salt farms and into the vineyards, giving Sicilian whites their patented salinity. As a result, Sicilian whites are excellent with grilled fish and even dishes like tempura.

Sicilian Wine Recommendations

Bottle of Sicilian Corvo Irmana Frappato with a grey background.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The great part about Sicilian wines is the diversity of flavors. If you’re looking for a crisp white, try Duca di Salaparuta Colomba Platino Insolia. This wine, with notes of apples, lemon, and peaches, has great notes of soft salinity, the hallmark of coastal Sicilian white wine. For a classic Sicilian red, try the Corvo Irmana Frappato. A lightly floral red with the aromas of red berries, this wine is great with pasta and pork. For a great Sicilian marsala, try Terre Arse. This complex marsala is great as an aperitif served alongside cheese and smoked fish.

Finally, these wines recommendations are just the beginning. For Walsh, this exploration is part of the appeal for Sicilian wine.

“I always recommend to folks to experiment, to try — pick up something that you don’t know,” said Walsh. “I as a consumer will do that if I see something interesting. Are you always going to like it? No, but that’s the fun part about wine — you can try something different and enjoy the whole discovery phase.”

Hunter Lu
Hunter Lu is a New York-based food and features writer, editor, and NYU graduate. His fiction has appeared in The Line…
A quick guide to wine bottle sizes, shapes, and names
Did you know that there are different names for all of the different wine bottle sizes?
Standard wine bottle with a glass of red wine

There are more than just a few kinds of wine bottles out there. Sometimes, it’s just a matter of shape and the same amount of liquid. Other times, it’s a broad spectrum of volume sizes, from the petite and personal split to the ridiculously large Nebuchadnezzar, which holds roughly twenty regular bottles. If you really want to be a wine expert, you must know the unique names of each of the wine bottle sizes and shapes as well as how much wine each holds.

Below, check out the names for the various bottle sizes, as well as an explanation for why some look the way they do.
A guide to wine bottles

Read more
The best red wine substitutes for cooking
Can't find the corkscrew? No problem.
man cooking with wine

Whether you're sober, pregnant, or simply drank all the red wine and are too tipsy to drive to the store for more, there are plenty of great substitutions if your recipe calls for red wine and you don't have a bottle.

Why cook with wine?

Read more
A guide to Gewurztraminer, an intensely aromatic wine
It's okay. The waiter probably doesn't know how to pronounce it, either.
Glass of white wine

When ordering wine, whether or not we speak the language of its origin, most of us have gotten pretty good at perfecting certain pronunciations. Names like Sauvignon Blanc, Sangiovese, and Beaujolais just mindlessly roll off the tongue as we peruse our wine lists. Every so often, though, there comes a wine name that raises an eyebrow and ties our tongue into knots. Gewürztraminer is one of those wines. But despite its mouthful of consonants, Gewürztraminer is an absolute delight...once you figure out how to order it.

What is Gewürztraminer?

Read more