Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

How to ferment your own pickles (it’s not gross, we promise)

Pickling and fermenting are processes as old as time that have recently regained popularity. It seems like there are new pickle recipes and methods for at-home pickles popping up everywhere, and it can be tough to sift through them all. Fermented pickles may sound gross to you, but they are precisely the opposite. If you like kimchi or kombucha, you’ll love fermented pickles. If you’re new to the fermented foods game and want pickles, they are a great way to get into fermented foods. Pickle fermenting at home is easy — the process is simple, and perfecting the recipe is a matter of trial and error for your specific tastes. Learn how to ferment your own pickles at home below.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

The difference between pickling and fermenting

Fermenting and pickling are both ancient food preservation techniques that are often confused because the categories overlap each other a bit. That is, some fermented foods are pickles, and some pickled foods are fermented. By definition, a pickle is a food that has been preserved in a brine (salt or salty water) or an acid like lemon juice or vinegar.

Recommended Videos

Fermented food is preserved and transformed by benign bacteria, which usually means that the natural sugars and carbohydrates in the food have been eaten by the good bacteria present in the food. The bacteria then turn the sugar into acids, carbon dioxide, and alcohol, preserving the food and adding to its flavor. So when you eat something like kimchi, you also consume the good bacteria that has preserved the cabbage.

The overlap

Pickles have been preserved with brines, as we’ve established. Many fermented foods also start with brine, so they are also pickles — fermented pickles. Sauerkraut is an example of a fermented pickle since it’s made by packing cabbage with salt and letting it ferment. Traditionally, dill pickles are fermented cucumbers in salty water. On the other hand, beer and yogurt are fermented, but you would never put them in the same category as a pickle.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

How to ferment your own pickles

Now that you know the differences and similarities between fermented foods and pickles, why not learn to ferment your own pickles at home? You can use almost any vegetables you have on hand to ferment pickles, even though most people think of cucumbers when they hear the word “pickle.” In fact, pickling is a fantastic way to preserve all of the vegetables your garden produces. There are two popular methods of fermenting pickles — read more about each below. 

Sous vide

To cook sous vide, you need an immersion circulator, which is a tool that sounds way fancier than it really is. It sets the water temperature you immerse it into, and, in turn, any food in the water gets cooked to that same exact internal temperature. So, to pickle something sous vide, you would complete all of your usual canning steps, submerge your jars into the water, and sous vide them until they reach the desired internal temperature (140 degrees Fahrenheit). The cooking process takes about two and a half hours if you are using quart-sized jars. If you are using smaller or larger jars, you will have to adjust the sous vide time accordingly, which may take a bit of experimenting.

Buy Now

Lacto-fermentation

Lacto-fermentation is the process that produces traditional dill pickles and works because harmful bacteria cannot tolerate salt. And pickles are made with lots of salt or brine, as mentioned previously. There is no canning, no submerging, no heating, etc., involved in lacto-fermentation, which means that it is not used for long-term preservation. Most fermented foods are edible for two months or more, and their flavors develop and become more acidic over time. So, to prepare fermented pickles, you proceed as you usually would with the steps for canning until you get to the point where you would start to cook your jars. Once the lids are on, store the jars in a cool and dry place for up to two months.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

The choice is yours

Now that you know the difference between pickling with the sous vide (or canning) method and lacto-fermentation, the decision is yours. We think that the sous vide method yields crisper pickles, so texturally, they’re way better, but it depends on what you like and what you are preserving. Don’t worry; you don’t have to choose one method. Try them both out and see which produces the foods you like best.

Kelly Kaliszewski
Former Contributor
Kelly's work has appeared in blogs and on websites. When she's not writing, she is playing with her two dogs, cooking, or…
How to cook steak: Your guide to the 6 best methods
Which is your favorite? Maybe more than one way
Steak on a cutting board

If you love a good steak (who doesn't?), you probably have a tried-and-true method of preparing your favorite cut. Perhaps you're a grill master who swears by the charred and blackened grill marks that can only come from fiery, open flames. Or maybe you're committed to your cast iron, devotedly basting your beautiful steak in garlic-infused butter as it sizzles on the stovetop.

I personally am a huge fan of pan searing and then finishing in the oven, but no matter what your favorite steak-cooking method, there's something for everyone and more than a few ways to get absolutely delicious results every time. These are the best methods on how to cook steak. Try them all!
Grilling

Read more
An expert’s advice on how to upgrade your Old Fashioned
From which spirit to use to making the most of your fruits and bitters
Old Fashioned

The Old Fashioned is one of the world's most iconic and popular cocktails, and with such a simple construction you might not think there would be many ways to make this drink better. But according to Daniel Lagestee, beverage supervisor behind the bar and cocktail programs at Journeyman Distillery’s two distilleries in Three Oaks, Michigan, and Valparaiso, Indiana, the Old Fashioned is the perfect base for experimenting and upgrading. He and his team create the Old Fashioned section of their menu, using ingredients as diverse as bacon-washed whiskey and fig-infused rye.

He shared his tips on making the most of this classy, delicious drink:
Give rye a try
Lagestee notes that while bourbons were everywhere for the past decade, recent years have seen an interested in rye whiskeys like Journeyman’s Last Feather Rye or Bulleit Rye. These can add a different dimension to the familiar drink: “These whiskeys provide a softer and subtly sweeter base spirit that tends to play well in the Old Fashioned format.”
Switch up your base spirits
While the classic backbone of an Old Fashioned is always going to be whiskey -- whether that's bourbon, rye, or perhaps even Scotch -- the drink can also be made with other spirits like rum or tequila.

Read more
Dirty Sue is launching premium pickle juice to help you up your cocktail game
Dirty Sue is finally launching a pickle juice
Dirty Sue

Have you ever had a Pickleback? If not, you’re really missing out on a boozy, tangy treat. In the simplest terms, a Pickleback is a shot of liquor (usually a bourbon, rye, or other whiskey) directly followed by a shot of pickle juice or brine. The tangy, salty, spicy pickle juice perfectly offsets the warmth of the alcohol.

It’s a surprisingly great combination. And while you can dump out some juice from your favorite Kosher dills or sweet gherkins, wouldn’t you buy a bottle made specifically for a Pickleback instead?
Dirty Sue Premium Pickle Juice

Read more