Skip to main content

Even organic coffee isn’t always clean — what you need to know (and how to shop smarter)

Is organic coffee as clean as you think?

cinnamon coffee
Olga Miltsova / Shutterstock

The Clean Label Project, an organization committed to exposing hidden risks that don’t appear on labels, just released a new study on caffeinated coffee, which may surprise many coffee drinkers. The newly published study tested 57 coffee products from 45 of the industry’s top-selling brands and found industrial and environmental contaminants in many coffee products that were labeled as organic.

Researchers detected traces of AMPA, a glyphosate byproduct, in 100% of organic samples, despite its use being prohibited in organic farming (yes, you heard that right). To learn more about the impact of this alarming organic coffee study, I got the scoop from Molly Hamilton, Executive Director of Clean Label Project. Here’s what she thinks consumers should know about the impact of this study and how to adopt a smarter way of shopping for coffee.

Why the study’s findings matter

“Coffee is one of the most popular beverages in the U.S., generating USD $269.27 billion in 2024,” says Hamilton. “Over 1 billion people, worldwide, drink coffee every day – that’s about 12.6% of the world’s population.” Knowing this, the Clean Label Project launched this study to assess the overall contaminant load of the category.

Recommended Videos

The study identified traces of Aminomethylphosphonic acid, commonly referred to as “AMPA”. This chemical residue is created from the degradation or breakdown of glyphosate. Given the rising health concerns surrounding glyphosate, the Clean Label Project has been testing products for AMPA. Although the use of glyphosate is banned from use in organic certified products, the study found AMPA in every organic sample in the study, causing great concern for the accuracy behind coffee labeled as organic.

“The detection of AMPA in 100 percent of organic samples is a wake-up call, Hamilton says. “Whether from environmental runoff or legacy contamination, this finding highlights the need for stronger safeguards and greater transparency in our food system.”

This study also poses a major question to be addressed on a larger scale: If glyphosate is prohibited in organic farming, how can chemicals like AMPA still end up in organic coffee? Hamilton says there are still some sneaky ways AMPA could make its way into coffee.

  • Some coffee growers may use AMPA to manage weeds around coffee bushes to make harvesting easier, a common practice in conventional farming.
  • Glyphosate could contaminate the water supply and, in turn, contaminate nearby organic farms.
  • Wind can also lead to cross-contamination from a conventional farm spraying glyphosate to an adjacent organic farm.

Shopping smarter for coffee

Though the study’s findings are alarming, Clean Label Project is also useful in helping consumers make informed decisions on how to reduce contaminant exposure while enjoying coffee. The purpose of these studies is not to worry consumers, but rather to help them shop smarter. To shop smarter for coffee, Hamilton recommends looking for CLP-certified brands, like Love Grown Coffee, and referencing findings on the website.

Emily Caldwell
Emily is a freelance journalist with a focus on food, travel, health, and fitness content. She loves to travel to new…
How Café Grumpy crafts festive coffee blends — and how you can do it at home
Brew cafe-style festive coffees in the comfort of your kitchen
Cafe Grumpy Peppermint Mocha

Café Grumpy is a Brooklyn staple. It was co-founded in 2005 by Caroline Bell, an office worker tired of struggling to find a decent cup of coffee nearby. The brand opened its first shop in the Greenpoint neighborhood of Brooklyn in 2005 and has quickly grown to 11 locations throughout NYC. The brand also sells its expertly sourced coffee online, allowing coffee lovers not local to a location still to enjoy a delicious Café Grumpy cup of coffee.

In the spirit of the holiday season, we've gathered some insight into what goes into making a delicious cup of coffee brewed at one of Café Grumpy's 11 locations. Bell has provided expert insight to help you elevate your at-home coffee brew for the holiday season. We've learned that brewing festive coffee flavors at home starts with understanding what makes a good cup of coffee: quality sourcing and expert brewing.
Using quality coffee

Read more
Director of Nutrition weighs in on Atkins’ latest protein coffee drinks — what to know
Should you combine protein and caffeine?
Atkins Pumpkin Spice Latte

New protein drinks are always hitting the market -- but what if you could combine protein with iced coffee? Turns out you can, with Atkins's latest protein coffee drinks. Called "Iced Coffee Shakes", the brand offers protein shakes that are made with real coffee. But should you consume coffee that has added protein to it? Are there benefits to combining your caffeine intake with your protein intake?
To get the scoop, we interview Dr. Jonathan Clinthorne, PhD – Director of Nutrition & Education at Simply Good. Simply Good is the parent brand for Atkins's low-carb products. Simply Good is focused on empowering and educating its customers on how to eat right and snack smarter by offering low-sugar, health-conscious products that make life easy.
Here's what he had to say when asked to provide more information about Atkins's new iced protein coffees.

What do people need to know about consuming protein coffee?

Read more
What is black eye coffee? What to know about this simple, yet strong drink
It's even stronger than red eye coffee
black eye coffee

If you like your coffee as strong as strong gets, you'll want to pay attention to an important menu item seen at coffee shops: the black eye coffee. The black eye coffee is even stronger than its cousin, the red eye coffee -- offering a solid choice when you need the strongest coffee on the menu. Whether you've had a late night or simply love the strong taste of espresso, you can't go wrong with the black eye coffee. This coffee is about as strong as it gets! Here's what you need to know about the black eye coffee before this simple yet strong drink.
What is black eye coffee?

A black eye coffee is made with only two simple ingredients: freshly brewed regular coffee and shots of espresso. Different than a red eye coffee which consists of one cup of coffee and one shot of espresso, the black eye coffee contains two shots of espresso mixed into a cup of coffee. To make this strong coffee/espresso drink, you simply pour two shots of espresso into a cup of coffee. This drink usually comes as a hot drink, however, it can be ordered over ice, if preferred.
Caffeine content
A typical cup of coffee is about 80 mg, on average (although it varies depending on brewing and the size of the cup). Plus, one shot of espresso is generally around 64 mg of caffeine. It only takes some simple math for you to realize this means the black eye coffee packs in a sizable amount of caffeine for just one coffee beverage. There's a wide variation of caffeine content that could be found in the black eye, so we recommend checking with a coffee shop before you order. After all, you don't want to end up consuming too much caffeine only to find yourself crashing at the 3 p.m. afternoon slump.

Read more