Skip to main content

Will you exercise more if you stick to what you enjoy? New study dives in

Are you more likely to put the effort in if you have more control over the exercise intensity?

Man on treadmill with sleeveless shirt in gym
Olly / Pexels

Maybe you’re a runner who loves feeling the breeze on your cheeks while zooming through the trail or city streets. Maybe pumping iron and feeling your muscles swell is your thing, or practicing yoga, going swimming, or powering through a high-intensity interval training class. We favor different types of exercise at varying intensities, and all of these different types have benefits. Exercising is part of a healthy lifestyle. One question that comes to mind is whether you will exercise more if you stick to what you enjoy. Are you more likely to put the effort in when it’s something you tend to like more or if you have control over the exercise or the intensity? Recently, researchers set out to find some answers.

The study

Man lifting weight
Logan Weaver / Unsplash

In a study published in the International Journal of Behavioural Nutrition and Physical Activity, the researchers wanted to determine if participants trained more frequently when they were allowed to self-regulate their exercise intensity according to their own preferences and tolerance. They wanted to know how to motivate people to exercise more and suggested that educating them on the health benefits of exercise isn’t enough to get people to take action and get moving.

Recommended Videos

The researchers from Lusófona University in Lisbon, Portugal, instead focused on pleasure as a leading motivating factor, and they invited 46 adults who weren’t regular exercisers to join exercise classes. Over eight weeks, study participants could join a workout class at a health club every two or three days if they wanted to. If they didn’t want to, they didn’t have to. 

Man on treadmill walking using machine in gym
Julia Larson / Pexels

The classes involved:

Half of the participants were allowed to choose the intensity of their exercises that felt the most pleasurable and comfortable for them. The other half had to follow standardized instructions for exercise intensity.

The results

People at cycle bar taking a fun fitness class
Katie McCurdy / ClassPass

The adults who could choose their exercise intensity based on pleasure or what they preferred attended 77% more exercise sessions than the participants who had to follow the standardized instructions. The participants who weren’t able to choose the exercise intensity attended classes an average of 8.13 times in eight weeks and reported smaller improvements in mood, whereas those who had the freedom of choice went to the health club 14.35 times and reported much higher improvements in mood. Exercise yielded a more positive emotional response in those who self-regulated their workout intensity.

The takeaway

Man lifting weights by mirror
Andres Ayrton / Pexels

If you prefer lower-intensity sessions, go with that. If you prefer higher intensity intervals that are over quicker, go with that. The takeaway here is that when you have more control over your exercise plan and you’re able to choose the intensity you prefer, you’re more likely to get a better mood and a positive impact from working out. You might also exercise more often, which is good news for your overall health and fitness

This study suggests that sticking with exercise intensities that you find more comfortable or pleasurable could be more motivating, and let’s face it, motivation is what gets you moving. If your main issue is showing up to exercise, it could be time to take the reins and consider the exercise intensity that appeals to you the most.

Steph Green
Steph Green is a content writer specializing in healthcare, wellness, and nutrition. With over ten years of experience, she…
Topics
What are recovery shoes — and do you actually need them?
Should you add these shoes to your self-care routine?
Person holding slides.

Are you frequently active or just spend a lot of time on your feet? No matter how your daily schedule looks, you may have sore and aching feet that need some support. This is where recovery shoes could play a role. So, what are recovery shoes?

Keep reading to learn the many benefits of recovery shoes, how you should utilize them, and tips for picking the best ones for you!

Read more
Sleepless night? This supplement might help your brain bounce back, study finds
Can this popular fitness supplement perk up your brain even if you're sleep deprived?
Man head in hands tired stressed laptop

I’m definitely not functioning at my best and fulfilling my true potential without a good night’s sleep. However, poor sleep doesn’t just hamper your productivity the next day or make your brain feel groggy; researchers have associated chronic insufficient sleep with a heightened risk of heart disease, obesity, cancer, and diabetes. Sleep is natural and protective for your overall wellness.

People try many ways to combat poor sleep, from guzzling cups of coffee to splashing water on their faces and napping during lunch. In an interesting study, researchers investigated whether the popular fitness supplement creatine can enhance cognitive function following sleep deprivation. 

Read more
Active kids, healthier minds? Study explores kids’ fitness and mental health
Does being more physically active boost your child's mood and protect their mental health?
teen playing football

As a child, I ran and jumped around a lot and played with my friends, so I was generally quite active. Even then, I recall how moving my muscles made me feel better, both mentally and physically. Previous research concludes that physical activity is beneficial for improving mental health, anxiety, depression, stress, self-esteem, and social competence in typically developing children and adolescents, which aligns with what I experienced as a kid.

Recently, researchers wanted to explore whether children who took part in physical education classes and sports were less likely to experience anxiety, depression, and addiction as they became adolescents. Let’s look at the research.

Read more