Skip to main content

A registered dietitian reveals the ingredient swaps that will keep your favorite Christmas cookies from ruining your weight loss goals

How to eat your sugar cookies without the guilt

baked sugar cookies for the holidays
Jonathan Meyer / Pexels

‘Tis the season to be jolly. However, the holidays can be challenging for people mentally and physically, especially people trying to maintain weight loss (or continue a journey).

The holidays can be a tricky time when trying to maintain one’s weight,” said Vanessa Rissetto, RD, a registered dietitian and the CEO of Culina Health. “First, there is an emotional component. Families and gathering with them can be triggering for some people and can cause emotional eating. Also, the lack of family, partners, and children can also take a mental toll.

Then, there’s the relentless social calendar.

“[The holidays bring] the endless cookie swaps, lunches, dinners, and cocktails that seem to be happening daily,” Rissetto said.

Still, the idea of skipping out on Christmas cookies because of weight can feel sad. Do healthy dessert recipes exist? Experts share that the answer is yes and that ingredient swaps like sugar substitutes can make your favorite holiday cookies healthier. Nutrition pros dished on the sweet details.

holiday cookies in a bowl
Jill Wellington / Pexels

The best ingredient swaps to make a healthy cookie this holiday season

Baking holiday cookies is a time-honored tradition, and the treats genuinely offer something for every sweet tooth: Crispy sugar cookies with holiday-themed icing, chocolate-peppermint treats, and the secret Christmas cookie recipe you wait to enjoy every year. Skipping the holiday cookies in the name of healthy eating may leave you saying, “Bah humbug.” However, simple ingredient swaps can allow you to have your cookie and keep weight off.

“Swapping healthier ingredients reduces calories, which is beneficial for those who are losing weight,” said Catherine Gervacio, BHSc, RND, a registered nutritionist-dietitian and certified exercise nutrition coach. “Most healthier swaps are the high-fiber options, which can help increase the feeling of fullness, which potentially decreases the chances of overindulging, especially in refined foods.”

From under-the-radar butter substitutes to swaps for chocolate goodies, these are experts’ top tips for developing a healthy cookie recipe this holiday season.

Butter substitutes

Butter adds richness, texture, and fat to a cookie. Experts share ways to get a similar taste and texture with an improved nutrient profile.

Avocado can be used to substitute for butter – still giving the same texture but more fiber and protein,” Rissetto said.

Another butter substitute may also be in your fridge: Applesauce.

“Applesauce has a lower saturated fat content and does not contain cholesterol,” Gervacio said. “Also, its natural sweetness can add flavor to a recipe.”

Flour substitutes

Traditionally, most people use white flour when baking Christmas cookies. However, white flour is a refined carb with little fiber.

“You can use whole grain/whole wheat flour in place of regular white flour at a 1-to-1 ratio without any major adjustments to taste or texture, all the while adding more fiber and protein to the disk,” Rissetto said.

Are you feeling more adventurous?

Black beans can be used instead of flour – adding extra fiber to your dessert,” Rissetto said.

Cream and egg swaps

Cream and eggs can increase the calories and cholesterol in Christmas cookies.

One pro suggests opting for Greek Yogurt over cream.

“The combination of Greek yogurt and water reduces it to make it a bit more of a creamy consistency,” said Blanca Garcia, RDN, a nutrition specialist with Healthcanal. “It includes higher amounts of protein and good nutrients which can help with blood sugar control and possibly reduced fat content.”

Garcia suggested using 3/4 cup of plain, full-fat Greek yogurt and 1/4 cup of water in a Christmas cookie recipe that calls for one cup of cream.

Chia seeds can serve as a surprising egg substitute.

“You need to put the chia seeds in white vinegar as chia seeds need liquid to work, but this is a great vegan substitute and again adds a fair amount of fiber to the dessert, making it less likely to spike your blood sugar,” Rissetto said.

Chocolate swaps

Rissetto said baking with Cacao Nibs instead of chocolate gems or chips can lower the sugar content. People can also opt for dark chocolate over milk chocolate.

“Swapping out milk chocolate can significantly reduce sugar in a baked good,” Garcia said.

This swap isn’t a straight one, though.

“Dark chocolate gives off a slightly bitter taste, which can work to balance out the sweetness of treats,” Gervacio said. “Also, dark chocolates have a less smooth texture.”

Just have the cookie as is

You can also opt out of healthy cookie recipes and have the tried-and-true treats you wait for 11 months of the year.

Sometimes, there just aren’t substitutes for a good-old traditional cookie, and that is OK,” Garcia said. “Not everything has to always be perfectly healthy. Having the cookie can be just what you need.”

Pavel Danilyuk / Pexels

Other tips for a healthier holiday season

Holiday cookie ingredient swaps are one way to indulge while practicing healthy eating, but experts shared some others.

Eat mindfully

Gervacio said mindful eating involves tuning into your body and hunger cues. She explains that the practice reduces the risk of eating more than you want or need.

Mindful eating also encourages enjoying holiday foods but with portion control and awareness of what healthier options are better to eat,” Gervacio said. “ One good practice of mindful eating is to stop when 80% full. Also, have 3-4 hour intervals in between meals.”

Try veggies

Vegetables are an underrated part of holiday meals and appetizers.

Don’t forget to have a hefty amount of dishes that include a variety of fall or winter-type vegetables like squashes, which can greatly help balance meals,” Garcia said. “Vegetables can be steamed, grilled, made into soups, or just classic salads with creative toppings.”

Protect your mental health

“Peace” isn’t just a buzzword for holiday cards.

“I always remind clients, first, to make sure that they are also seeing a mental health professional at this time because it can help navigate the murky waters,” Rissetto said.

From there, prioritize what matters.

Next, we go through their calendars week by week and decide what events are a must-go and which ones are a nice-to-have and then strategize around that,” Rissetto said. “When we take it one step at a time, people find that it’s less taxing on them mentally, and they can keep in alignment with their goals.”

This alignment can include weight loss goals.

Editors' Recommendations

BethAnn Mayer
Beth Ann's work has appeared on healthline.com and parents.com. In her spare time, you can find her running (either marathons…
From Bob’s Red Mill to McCann’s, these are the best healthy cereals for men, according to a registered dietician
Stick with these choices to start your day right
A bowl of cereal and a spoon

Cereal is arguably one of the first foods that comes to mind for most people when they think about breakfast, and the food industry has capitalized on our love for breakfast cereals with enough options to span an entire aisle at most grocery stores. While we all know there are plenty of sugar-laden choices these days (some even have the word “cookie” in them!), there are also ones that masquerade as nutritious choices but are actually little more than empty calories, refined grains, and added sugars. This doesn’t mean you need to steer clear of the entire cereal aisle and become an eggs-only type of guy, but if you’re in the market for a healthy cereal, it’s a good idea to turn the box and scan the nutritional facts and ingredients list before adding it to your cart.
“Breakfast cereals are healthy when they are made from whole grains, are low sugar with no added sugar, and have a moderate amount of fiber and protein,” said Janette Marsac, a registered dietitian in New York City, who added that cereal can be a great source of whole grains, which have been linked to a lower risk of heart disease and diabetes. The key is choosing minimally processed, whole-grain cereals with at least 3-5 grams of protein and fiber per serving, and no more than 5 grams of sugar unless it contains only sugar in the form of dried fruit.
The list of ingredients should include grains, nuts, and seeds, such as whole wheat, whole oats, brown rice, amaranth, flax, almonds, chia, walnuts, and quinoa, and should not contain high-fructose corn syrup, date syrup, fruit juice, honey, agave, or any added sugars or sugar alcohols (look for words ending in -ose or -ol).
In recent years, there have been an increasing number of cereals marketed as "keto-friendly," "high protein, or "high fiber." Perhaps surprisingly, these aren’t always as healthy as they may sound. The “high-protein” cereals are usually made with soy protein, which has poor bioavailability and is usually highly processed. It’s typically better to consume cereal for its intended purpose — a good source of whole grains — and consume other naturally high-protein foods like eggs, lean meats, poultry, fish, and cottage cheese. Similarly, the “high-fiber” cereals usually contain chicory root or inulin; both are poorly absorbed and may leave you bloated and gassy. To prevent digestive distress, opt for cereals with natural sources of fiber like whole grains, nuts, flax seeds, and chia seeds.

Healthy breakfast cereal to start your day
Now, it's time to find out what the healthiest breakfast cereals are for men that will help you begin your day on a healthy note. Below, we share our recommendations.

Read more
Here’s how to lower your blood pressure without using medication
Is your blood pressure a bit high? Here are some straightforward ways to reduce it
Blood pressure monitor.

High blood pressure can be deceptive, as it doesn't always show obvious symptoms. We do know, however, that it's a big deal in the country, with an estimated 50% of men and 44% of women in the U.S. impacted, according to the CDC. And the prevalence is even more so among men.
What does that mean? Well, there's a decent chance you're running a little high. Stressful work or home environments can certainly be the culprit, as can other dramatic forms of intake, like dealing with the news, navigating a pandemic, or trying to make ends meet in a wobbly economy. We get why the numbers are so staggering, but we can take care of ourselves a bit better and lower our collective blood pressure level.
We aren't going to rip away your favorite cocktails from your hands or say you can't have burgers anymore. But we are going to issue some measures you can take to chip away at your raised blood pressure.

Quit smoking
High blood pressure is one of the many risks of smoking. Cutting out all nicotine and tobacco is one of the best things you can do for your hypertension and health overall, and has been shown to reduce your risk of hypertension, myocardial infarction (heart attack), and respiratory diseases.

Read more
These 14 foods will add essential vitamin K to your diet
Vitamin K is an important nutrient you could probably eat more of
Salad greens high in vitamin K

It's perhaps not the most talked-about or sexiest vitamin out there (we see you, vitamin C), but vitamin K is important nonetheless. You're probably already getting some through your regular diet but there's a good chance you could use a pinch more. But how? And why?

Because vitamin K serves the body well. The nutrient helps with coagulation when you're wounded, bone metabolism, and the vital functions of your heart and vessels. When you're not taking in enough of the stuff, bad things can happen, like bleeding disorders or cardiovascular issues.

Read more