Skip to main content

Are you overtraining?The fitness trap that anyone can fall into

Doing too much is a common workout problem

young man doing cardio workout at the gym
Samuel Borges Photography / Canva Pro

If you’re athletically-oriented, your approach to fitness and workouts is structured. You have goals. Plans. A solid routine. You make room for changes and unexpected bad days, but what happens when you hit your goals and it doesn’t feel fulfilling?

This happened to me recently. I’m a lifelong runner, and my latest goal was to go from five miles a day to six, then duplicate that distance six days a week. It took weeks of hard work, but I when I finally got over the hump, I felt nothing, just a strange, unfamiliar combination of flatness and fatigue. It was a vexing problem, and it took me a while to understand that I’d succumbed to one of the most common problems in fitness — overtraining.

Recommended Videos

A common story

Man getting ready to run on running track
Olly / Pexels

Having overtrained before, I had a history to tap into, which gave me a solid starting point. But getting good advice to deal with overtraining is much harder than it looks, and Kristina Centenari, a trainer for Tonal, usually starts with a basic approach to the problem.

“I look at patterns,” she says. “[What’s] the training load? The volume? How about frequency?”

But those basic patterns often aren’t enough. Sometimes Centenari has to go deeper into the problem and ask questions she hopes will be more revealing.

“What role is lifestyle stress playing?” Centenari adds. “Are there holes in [your] nutrition?”

The sum total of these questions is often psychological. Taken together, they can expose a mindset that sets up a situation where overtraining is all but inevitable.

“You won’t feel motivated every day, but when you feel sluggish, really lacking enthusiasm, or even heightened stress or anxiety, that’s when we should take a look at the bigger picture,” she explains. “You need to track your recovery like you track your training, and don’t wait until your performance drops to do it.”

Overtraining adjustments you can make

Man doing plank with pre-workout supplement
Andrea Piacquadio / Pexels

This kind of analysis and thought process can lead to a viable plan. Centenari has a laundry list of steps that can help with overtraining, and there’s no room for a “one size fits all” approach in her process.

  • More “deload” weeks
  • Reduce overall volume
  • Implement lighter intensity days where you incorporate walking, working on mobility, etc.
  • Set protein goals
  • Set sleep goals
  • Encourage some form of breath work or meditation

How I solved my overtraining problem

Man running on the beach at sunset
Samsilitongajr / Pexels

So how did I solve my own overtraining problem? The solution definitely incorporated analyzing my own patterns, but beyond that my solution was very individual.

In making the jump from five miles to six, I’d been focusing on long, slow distance. It took me a while to figure it out, but finally I realized that my pace was a real problem.

Simply put, I was running too slowly. This produced a lot of flat, uninspiring runs where I was simply going through the motions in any ways.

As a result, I began increasing my pace — slowly, a little bit at a time. When this proved easier than I thought I would be, I realized I was on to something. My runs became more lively and enjoyable, and I also made some minor nutritional adjustments while adding extra naps to my routine.

Given my tendency to set goals, I know I’ll probably overtrain again at some point in the future. But having a list of possible adjustments is comforting, and anyone can incorporate them into their routine. Overtraining doesn’t have to be a debilitating problem, especially if you recognize the signs early on and take steps to alter your routine.

Bob McCullough
Bob McCullough is a freelance author and journalist who has published dozens of novellas and novels, and his journalism has…
Topics
Why Peloton’s Kirsten Ferguson takes an hour for herself — and you should too
Kirsten Ferguson on using movement to heal
Kirsten Ferguson

In the hustle of daily life, it’s easy to think of fitness only in terms of physical results — chasing muscle tone, weight loss, or personal records. But for Peloton instructor Kirsten Ferguson, working out is just as much about mental strength as it is about physical gains. I had a conversation with Kirsten to talk about how movement, even in its simplest form, can be a lifeline for emotional well-being.

Through her Peloton classes, Kirsten encourages people to carve out time just for themselves, something she practices daily. In our conversation, she opened up about why she dedicates one hour every day to herself, how to reframe exercise as self-care, and how parents can work through the guilt of taking that time. Whether it’s a full workout or just a few mindful moments of movement, showing up for yourself can have a profound impact on your mental health.

Read more
What can five minutes of brisk walking do for your brain? Researchers find out
Does exercising for just five minutes boost your brain power? Is more intense exercise even better?
man walking in meadows in grass

Recently, a study of over 17,000 healthy American and Australian older adults revealed that those with the slowest walking speed had the highest risk of dementia, and brisk walking could have a protective effect on the brain. Additional research has revealed that individuals who engage in healthier behaviors, such as regular physical activity and a nutritious diet, have the lowest risk of developing dementia. 

We know exercise and walking are good news for our brain health, and another study adds to the growing research.

Read more
These 5 fitness myths are hurting your daily workouts
These fitness adages aren't really true
fit man lat pulldown shirtless

Fitness tips are everywhere. They’re on our screens, regardless of which devices we’re using. They’re at the gym, too, even if some are unsolicited. And devices. They even turn up in health and wellness information, which makes them virtually impossible to avoid.
This is a good thing to some extent, but it also comes with a major downside. It spawns a lot of fitness myths, and many of them don’t look like fiction when you first see them. There’s a lot that goes into recognizing these myths, so here’s some help with some of the most common ones, which can easily creep into your workouts and mess up your training plan.

Fitness myth #1: Calories in, calories out is the best way to lose weight

Read more