Skip to main content

Does muscle weigh more than fat? Here’s the truth

Everything you need to know about body recomposition

Muscular man with shirt off flexing muscles
Pikx By Panther / Pexels

Does muscle weigh more than fat? If you’re building muscle, will it make you weigh more? Can you build muscle and lose fat at the same time? These are all questions many people have about their workout routine. In this article, we’ll look at muscle building and the differences between muscles and fat in your body. 

What is the difference between muscle and fat?

Abdominal muscles.
charles / Adobe Stock

Fat is the body’s way of storing energy, but it also plays a genuine role in the body as part of the endocrine system (which regulates hormones). Fat can help control your insulin sensitivity and immune system, as well as keep you warm in cold temperatures. You need some amount of fat storage for your body to function properly, but most people have too much.

Recommended Videos

Muscles are, of course, what you use to move your body, from your smallest finger to your back and core. Muscle cells require energy just to sustain them, so having a higher muscle mass means you’ll burn more calories, even when you’re not doing anything. 

Does muscle weigh more than fat?

Man on scale.
Ketut Subiyanto / Pexels

Technically, no — one pound of muscle is equivalent to one pound of fat when it comes to weight. However, muscle takes up less space, as muscle is denser than fat.

This means that a person with 200 pounds of mostly muscle will appear slimmer than a person with 200 pounds of mostly fat. That’s one reason why the BMI, or Body Mass Index, isn’t completely reliable — a bodybuilder with a large amount of muscle gets the same BMI score as an obese person. 

Can muscle and fat look different on people?

Man doing CrossFit outside
SOPA Images / Alamy

Yes, fat and muscle often look different depending on the person. For example, different people usually store more fat in different areas of their body, so one person might have fat appear mostly in their stomach, while another might carry it mostly in their legs. That variation is greater in women than in men. 

The appearance of muscle will vary depending on the person, too. Some people find it easier to gain muscle in their core or arms, and variations in workout habits will also create differences. Full-body workouts are best for a balanced physique, but if you work out each part of the body individually (arm day, leg day, etc.), make sure you keep them balanced and don’t focus too much on any one area. 

What happens if you have too much body fat?

Man holding belly fat
Towfiqu barbhuiya / Unsplash

Too much body fat can cause you to be overweight and obese. Obesity is an epidemic in the United States and in many other parts of the developed world because of the ever-increasing availability of fatty and sugary processed foods. Being overweight or obese, which really means having too much body fat, increases your risk of heart disease, strokes, diabetes, and even complications from COVID-19. 

What are the benefits of having more muscle mass?

Man flexing arms muscles on a dark background in the gym
Mahmood Sufiyan / Pexels

Increased muscle mass reduces your risks of heart disease and diabetes, possibly because higher muscle mass correlates with lower fat levels. As mentioned above, muscle mass also burns more calories than other types of body mass, even at rest. 

Tips for building muscle while losing fat

Man with shirt off in gym lifting one dumbbell
Ronin / Pexels

Watch what you eat

Your diet can make a big difference in your body composition. Eating more protein and less fat can help you gain muscle and lose fat at the same time. This is called body recomposition, which means deliberately changing your body composition. 

Choose the right exercises

Most people choose cardio exercises for weight loss since the activities burn a lot of calories, but strength training is much more effective for building muscle than cardio. You can reduce weight and fat by lifting weights and increase muscle mass while you’re at it. 

Expect slow progress

Trying to gain muscle and lose fat at the same time is harder than trying to do one or the other on its own. You need to consume enough calories so that your muscles can easily grow, but too much will make your body store more fat. The exercises that result in the most weight loss tend not to match the exercises that build the most muscle. It’s possible to do both things at once, but you should expect that your progress will be slower because simultaneously gaining muscle and losing fat is difficult. 

Frequently asked questions

Young strong man posing and flexing his quadriceps legs muscles in a gym blue shorts holding
Chris Graphics / Adobe Stock

Why am I gaining weight but looking thinner?

It is possible to gain weight but appear thinner if you are losing fat and building muscle at the same time. Since muscle is denser than fat, it can produce more weight in less space, causing you to look thinner while weighing more. 

How to tell if you’re gaining muscle or fat when gaining weight?

It can sometimes be hard to tell, but the best way is just to look in a mirror. If it looks like your muscles are gaining definition, you’re probably gaining muscle, but if some areas are starting to look soft or to sag, you might be gaining fat instead. 

Do you weigh more if you are muscular?

Generally speaking, yes. If you take two people who are the same height and the same fat percentage, but one has more muscle, the one with more muscle will weigh more. However, your weight depends on many other factors as well.

Christine VanDoren
Christine is a certified personal trainer and nutritionist with an undergraduate degree from Missouri State University. Her…
Does lack of sleep hold you back on the running track? Here’s the research
Is insufficient sleep stopping you from achieving your true fitness potential? Sleep longer, run faster.
Tired man stopping for break on beach

We all need our sleep. Personally, I feel a lot better after getting a full night’s rest, and I’m not yawning my way through the day. Researchers have found that a lack of sleep increases your risk of a range of conditions, including depression, diabetes, high blood pressure, stroke, and heart attack. All the more reason to prioritize your sleep.

I know I’m not functioning at my best if I haven’t got enough shut eye, so I certainly wouldn’t be trying to run a marathon or anything on those days. Research shows that runners who sleep less hours actually do take longer to cross that finish line, highlighting a connection between running performance and sleep.

Read more
Sustainable dumbbells are for the eco-conscious — here’s what they’re made of
These earthy-looking dumbbells could change the paradigm.
sustainable wooden dumbbells

Many of us try to do our part for the betterment of our environment. Some fitness trends are making a difference, like plogging, where you go jogging while picking up trash. In the fitness world, while focusing on building muscle and power, one personal trainer in Kent decided to also focus on eco-conscious fitness by developing wooden dumbbells. Most weights and dumbbells are made from metal or plastic materials, but these earthy-looking dumbbells could change the paradigm. So, what are they made from, and how did they come to be? This really got me thinking about how we make gym equipment, and if maybe there is a better way when it comes to our planet.

Sustainable dumbbells

Read more
The truth about daily weigh-ins and why they can hinder your weight loss
The scale isn't the only way to measure progress
Weight loss scale black and white doctor office weighing scale

When you’re trying to lose weight, weighing yourself regularly can be stressful. Daily weigh-ins show major up-and-down movements that leave you confused, and you have three different Excel spreadsheets to average your progress over time. We’ve all been there. But what are you supposed to do?

As a trainer and nutritionist, I stress to my clients that there are other ways besides a scale to track their weight loss progress. In fact, I believe some of them are much better than weighing yourself, and others help fill out a fuller picture. Here’s everything you need to know about different ways to track your progress — and how to avoid obsessing too much over any of them.
What are the downsides to only weighing yourself?

Read more