Skip to main content

Study: People are giving up popular cars (like the Toyota Tacoma and Honda Civic) for EVs like the Tesla Model 3

This shows Toyota is really behind on selling EVs

FernandoV/Shutterstock / Shutterstock

While many people of a certain age were led to believe that the future is made up of flying DeLoreans, it turns out that we might not need a flux capacitor after all. As it turns out, the future is here, and it is powered by electricity. Unfortunately for many companies like Toyota, this new age wave of the future capsizes many of their gas-powered sales, making many executives exclaim, “Great Scott!”

Tesla group photo with Model S, Model 3, Model X, Model Y parked in front of charger during sunset.

Tesla owns four of the top ten spots for used EVs

According to a new study by CarMax, from February 2022 to February 2023, search volume for terms containing “electric” increased twofold. Beyond that, a survey conducted by the Pew Research Center in May 2022 found that 42% of Americans say they would be very or somewhat likely to seriously consider an electric vehicle for their next car. Unsurprisingly, the spike in interest in electric cars coincided with the jump in gas prices from $3.54 to $4.20 from February to March of 2022. Despite whatever changes the future has in store, it seems people still want to hold on to their hard-earned money.

Also, not groundbreaking news is that four out of the top ten most popular used EVs on CarMax come from Tesla. The Tesla Model 3 and Tesla Model Y come in first and second, while the Model X and Model S rank seventh and eighth, respectively. However, it is surprising that the Model X is the most expensive used EV, with an average sales price of over $72,000, surpassing its Model S sibling by almost ten grand.

2024 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro
2024 Toyota Tacoma TRD Pro White Rear View Toyota / Toyota

Goodbye Toyota Tacoma, hello future

When it comes to what type of vehicle gets traded in the most, SUVs take the gold with a staggering 40% share of the pie, while sedans and coupes combine to take up another 29%, followed by luxury vehicles, pickup trucks, sports cars, and finally mini- and regular vans. Toyota, BMW, and Ford were the top three most traded-in brands. Toyota takes the lead with a 12% share, while Bimmer and the Blue Oval tie at 8% each.

Upon examining the numbers more in-depth, CarMax found that the two vehicles most traded in for the top-selling Tesla Model 3 were the Honda Civic and the Toyota Tacoma. The most common model traded in when customers were buying a Tesla Model S and Model Y was its cheaper sibling, the Model 3. It shows not only the brand loyalty Elon Musk’s company commands but also that current customers value more expensive models with their willingness to upgrade.

ev charging in sunny weather
Blue Planet Studio / Shutterstock

Although the extinction of gasoline-powered vehicles is unlikely to be something that happens in our lifetime, the trend is clearly headed in that direction. Although the dreaded ‘range anxiety’ continues to loom large over the electric world like a dark storm cloud, the silver lining may ironically be the ability to harness the power of lightning itself in battery form. And while we may not have a flying DeLorean just yet, we’re willing to bet that a Tesla Model S Plaid is a lot more fun getting up to 88 mph.

Editors' Recommendations

Lou Ruggieri
A lifelong lover of cars, Lou contributes to Motor Trend, Hot Cars, Auto & Truck Connection, and the PowerAutoMedia Group.
Toyota chairman boldly claims electric cars will never dominate, says hybrids are the better option
Hybrids are better than EVs says Toyota Chairman
ChargePoint Home Flex EV charging station charging a white Tesla in a garage.


It's not breaking news that EVs have been all the rage over the last decade. Elon Musk and Tesla dominate news wires, while companies like Kia and Hyundai are tripping over themselves trying to get newer and better electric options to showroom floors. Beyond that, we've seen plenty of reports that the electric revolution is better for our health, as well as the planet, and is an inevitable change we simply have to learn to embrace... or is it? But, with EV sales beginning to stagnate at the end of 2023, suddenly, we are seeing something many didn't expect, and according to Akio Toyoda, chairman of Toyota, consumers are "finally seeing reality."

Read more
Chicago, Tesla show how climate change is beating EVs
Charging EVS at home may be the best cold weather practice.

Tesla Cybertruck snow performance isn't the only climate-related EV problem. Frigid Arctic temperatures caused havoc among Chicago-area EV owners in mid-January. During extended hours of sub-zero temperatures, EV batteries couldn't hold their charge, and charging took much longer than usual. Charging times grew, and waiting times multiplied at charger locations overwhelmed by the weather.

TV news pieces showed Tesla supercharger stations with long lines of cars waiting to charge and people pushing Teslas with depleted batteries to parking spaces. Tesla is an easy target, but the very low temperatures affect all EVs with Lithium-ion batteries.

Read more
Porsche unveils its latest EV, the Macan, with 380-mile range – and Porsche fans may not like it
Porsche debuts its second-ever EV, the new Porsche Macan
Electric Porsche Macan

Porsche has finally revealed key details on its upcoming electric Macan. The SUV, which is to be the second all-electric vehicle in the German manufacturer’s lineup, aims to match “Sports-car-like performance figures” with “high-performance fast charging.” It comes in two flavors, the basic Macan 4 and the high-performance Macan Turbo. As you may expect, performance is balanced out against range and price. The company has also revealed that customers will begin receiving the electric Macan in late 2024 -- with prices starting at $80,450.

Get your foot down, and the Macan Turbo certainly seems like it will have that Porsche feeling -- accelerating from 0-60 in just 3.3 seconds. The Macan 4 is a little tamer, taking 5.2 seconds to reach the 60 mph milestone. It’s still impressive for an SUV, but faces lots of stiff competition in the EV world. Top speed caps out at 162 mph for the Turbo, and 124 on the Macan 4. Other notable features include air suspension and optional rear-wheel steering.

Read more