Skip to main content

Bad buys: These 10 cars have the worst resale values

Used car values: Stay away from these 10 models

Side profile of 2023 Cadillac Escalade ESV in front of a mountain range at dawn.
Cadillac

The pandemic caused used car prices to go haywire. Everyone wanted to buy a car, but new ones weren’t available, so they went to the used car markets. High demand resulted in high prices and chaos. While finding a new car at a dealership without a massive markup is still difficult, you’ll want to pay extra close attention to car value and what car you buy while asking yourself — what is my car worth? — because depreciation could be on your side or against you.

An old BMW 7 Series car being driven up a hill.
BMW

These ten cars have the worst resale values

iSeeCars analyzed over three million three-year-old and five-year-old used cars sold in 2022 to find which vehicles hold onto their values and which ones depreciate like rocks. Because of the pandemic, used vehicles retained their resale value more than before. But quite a few used cars had depreciation figures that crossed over 50%, well above the national average of 33%.

So, if you’re looking to avoid a vehicle with a horrible resale value, you’ll want to stay far away from these ten models:

  • BMW 7-Series: 56.9%
  • Maserati Ghibli: 56.3%
  • Jaguar XF: 54%
  • Infiniti QX80: 52.6%
  • Cadillac Escalade ESV: 52.3%
  • Mercedes-Benz S-Class: 51.9%
  • Lincoln Navigator: 51.9%
  • Audi A6: 51.5%
  • Volvo S90: 51.4%
  • Ford Expedition: 50.7%

Saying that a car fell by over 50% in value over five years is one thing, but for some added context, the 7-Series sedan’s depreciation figure means it lost an average of $61,923 from its starting MSRP. That’s just over five years! The Ford Expedition, which seems like a great option from a resale standpoint compared to the 7-Series, lost an average of $32,674 from MSRP over five years.

The vehicles aren’t all that surprising. Everyone that’s ever spent some time searching for a used vehicle on Craigslist knows that German luxury cars depreciate like graphics cards after a crypto crash. If you have a few seconds, check out how much a used Mercedes-AMG model costs compared to a new one. It’s almost sad.

With SUVs being such hot commodities these days, we are a little puzzled to see a few SUVs on the cars-to-stay-away-from list. iSeeCars believes that high gas prices greatly affected how severely these large SUVs depreciated.

So, if you want a vehicle that will hold onto its value well, you’ll want to avoid luxury cars and large SUVs. Instead, choosing a vehicle with little depreciation, like the Jeep Wrangler (7.3%), Porsche 911 (14.6%), Toyota Tacoma (14.9%), Honda Civic (16.3%), and Toyota Corolla (19.8%), is a safe bet.

A rusted vintage car with a for sale sign attached to it.
Photo by Hilbert Hill via Unsplash

Why does auto resale value matter to consumers?

There are numerous reasons why auto resale value matters to consumers, and we have briefly notarized these reasons below: 

  • Car upgrade affordability: A vehicle with an excellent resale value can be an incredibly valuable asset when purchasing a new car. If your current vehicle has a high resale value, it means that you have more selling or trade-in value and won’t have to spend as much on a new vehicle. Essentially, if you have a car with a high resale value, you’re more likely to afford a new and improved vehicle as you’ll have access to a higher lump sum for a downpayment. 
  • Brand reliability and reputation: Often, vehicles with strong resale values are manufactured by reputable brands known for producing reliable vehicles that are worth their pricing. This means that if a car has a higher resale value, consumers enjoy the peace of mind of owning a vehicle that holds its value well. Essentially, high resale value signifies quality craftsmanship, dependable performance, and the likelihood of fewer mechanical problems while owning it.
  • Easier selling process: A well-maintained vehicle with good resale value is generally easier to sell in the United States and globally. This is because it has a higher demand in the used car market, with more people wanting to purchase your current car. So if you have a vehicle with a high resale value, it can expedite the selling process. This will most likely save you time and effort when it’s time to part ways with your beloved vehicle while leaving you with a better chance of a bigger purse.

These are only some of the reasons auto resale values matter.

Editors' Recommendations

Jason Collins
Jason is a busy writer, avid traveler, and a car fanatic.
Want to buy an EV? Don’t – this is why you should lease an electric car instead
Wait to buy an EV because leasing might be the best option
ChargePoint Home Flex EV charging station charging a white Tesla in a garage.

One of the sad ironies of being a car lover is how much of a pain the actual act of buying a car can be. Pushy salespeople, contract terms that require a JD and a magnifying glass to comprehend, and enough miscellaneous fees to make a cell phone company blush. So, more often than not, many of us tend to lean towards buying a car rather than leasing because who would willingly volunteer to go through that kind of patience-pumping torture every three years? But, the EV movement has begun more than an energy revolution in the automotive universe, and leasing might just be the new buying.

While it used to be that purchasing a car was a net positive in the long term - eventually, the payments ended, and when they finished, the buyer actually had something tangible to show for it. But, with the relatively new landscape that the electric vehicle world has brought about, there are plenty of reasons that it makes much more sense to lease than buy a new EV.

Read more
The BMW Z8 is an underappreciated gem (and maybe the best Bond car)
The BMW Z8 is arguably one of the best cars ever made
James Bond Z8

If you were to ask most BMW fans what their favorite model was, odds are it would start with an 'M.' Cars like the E30, E46, and E92 M3 are some of the most excellent drivers' vehicles in automotive history. In a separate yet related affair, if you ask any group of people what their favorite James Bond car happens to be, there is a better-than-average chance that they would probably mention one of his amazing Aston Martins. But what if there was a car out there that could, and arguably should, be the answer to both of those questions? Let us introduce, or possibly reintroduce, the magnificently underappreciated BMW Z8.

BMW 507 front view and BMW Z8 front 3/4 view Greg MG/Flickr / Greg MG/Flickr
From 507 to Z8: history repeats itself 
If the name Henrik Fisker sounds familiar, it's because he founded Fisker Automotive and designed the beautiful but short-lived Fisker Karma. But a decade before his own company began, Henrik was commissioned to pen the Z07 Concept, which was meant to be an homage to BMW's classic 507 from the 1950s. Keeping with the traditional long hood/short deck sports car template, Fisker created a beautifully flowing and muscular design that looked fast from any angle and could stop passersby dead in their tracks asking, "What is that?!"

Read more
The 10 most expensive collector cars in the world
Forget about six figures — these seven-, eight-, and nine-figure collector cars draw a lot of attention yearly
1955 Mercedes-Benz SLR “Uhlenhaut Coupé” overhead image with the gullwing doors open from behind in a white studio.

While most people worry about having a hard time finding a car or about how they could afford a large dealer markup, collectors spend ludicrous amounts of money on classic cars every year.

In fact, according to Classic.com, the top 10 most expensive collector's cars that sold at auction in 2022 represented a total of $250 million in sales. The most "affordable" car was sold at auction for $7,595,000, while the most expensive one was $146,588,400.

Read more