Skip to main content

The Manual may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site.

How To Make the Perfect Sushi at Home, According To a Master Sushi Chef

Sushi, a culinary art form that is both elegant and complex, is now more accessible than ever to the ambitious home cook. Although high-level sushi still takes a lifetime of knowledge and practice, the market disruptions of the COVID-19 pandemic have made previously unattainable high-quality ingredients available to the consumer.

Derek Wilcox, the head sushi chef at Shoji at 69 Leonard Street in Manhattan, has a lot of insight into these developments. Born in upstate New York, Derek grew up in Virginia before moving to Japan after culinary school. His culinary experiences in Japan are unique — he is one of the only foreigners to ever train at Kyoto’s infamous kaiseki restaurant Kikunoi and Sushi Aoki in Ginza. Tokyo. In the Japanese culinary world, Derek is known as a shokunin,  ‘artisan’ in Japanese. To be a shokunin is a philosophy, a way of life where an individual is in a constant state of thriving for perfection, never ceasing to improve their particular art form.

Chef Derek Wilcox with an amberjack. 88tamashii/Instagram

Sushi Techniques

According to Derek, there are three key factors to high-end sushi — simplicity, quality of ingredients, and tradition. Simplicity of ingredients allows the ingredients (the rice or fish) to shine. Americanized rolls such as dragon rolls might be tasty for their purposes but the extra garnishes can mask the true flavor of both rice and fish. For quality of ingredients, use the best version possible — the finest Japanese rice, soy sauce, fresh grated wasabi instead of the standard tube version, and fish. Finally, tradition, a key factor as high-level sushi chefs train for decades. Sushi chefs spend a lifetime perfecting their rice, selecting the best fish, practicing knife skills, and combining flavors.

Because of the pandemic, the ambitious home cook can now access two of these factors — simplicity and quality of ingredients. Simplicity is more of a state of mind and knowledge. However, specialty importers who previously only served high-level sushi restaurants now also cater to the consumer. This gives the consumer (if one can afford it) the ability to purchase the same level of seafood previously only available to the best sushi restaurants in America. These importers were forced to adapt because of the pandemic dine-in shutdowns.

Where to Order Sushi Grade Seafood

Shawn Harquail/Flickr

There are several excellent importers now available for consumers. In Japan, sushi chefs frequent the markets such as Tsukiji fish market in Tokyo for the best products. In America, most high-end sushi chefs get their seafood from a specialty purveyor. The following are some of the best purveyors previously only available within the industry.

  1. True World Foods
  2. Regalis
  3. Yama Seafood

When choosing fish, start with your favorites. Tuna is always a good choice and has a good combination of both lean and fat. For those seeking a fish that popular in Japan but not common in America, try kinmaedai (splendid alfonsino in English). A red-skinned fish about a foot in length, every part of the kinmaedai is usable. Relatively easy to scale, the flesh can be used for sushi or sashimi and the bones and head are great in soup. The head is also delicious grilled. However, the skin is not edible unless it is blanched or seared. The skin can also be removed for a cleaner taste.

Sushi Rice (Shari, Sumeshi)

kimishowota/Flickr

(By Derek Wilcox, Shoji at 69 Lenard Street)

Like most sushi chefs, Derek considers the rice to be the most important part of the sushi-making process. In Derek’s opinion, if the rice is well-made, the sushi will still be delicious even if the fish is not perfectly sliced. Ideally, make the shari with Japanese grown koshihikari rice, although California koshihikari is an excellent substitute.

Ingredients:

  • 2 cups rice
  • 4 oz good quality rice vinegar
  • 1 1/4 tbsp good quality sea salt
  • 1 1/2 tsp sugar

Method:

  1. Wash 2 cups rice (using the cup that came with your rice cooker) and soak in water for 30 minutes.
  2. Cook in the rice cooker, but use 10-20% less water than usual.
  3. In the meantime, combine 4 oz rice vinegar, 1 1/4 tbsp sea salt, and 1 1/2 tsp sugar and whisk to dissolve.
  4. When the rice cooker finishes, transfer the cooked rice immediately to a wooden tub or bowl, sprinkle the seasoned vinegar evenly over the rice, and quickly mix with a paddle using cutting and folding motions.
  5. Fan the rice for 10-20 seconds, turning again once or twice, until it shines. Rest covered with a damp cloth for 20 minutes before forming sushi.

Fisherman’s Bone Broth (“Ushio-jiru”)

Shawn Harquail/Flickr

This is a great way to utilize the whole fish after the filets have be used for sushi. Serve before or after the sushi.

Ingredients:

  • Kinmedai (or any leftover fish) heads and bones
  • 6 1/2 cups water
  • 6 3/4 oz sake
  • 1 tsp dried kombu kelp
  • Salt
  • Yuzu peel and mitsuba herb to garnish

Method:

  1. Heavily salt fish heads and bones, leave for 30 minutes, wash, and pat dry. Refrigerate and let age for 1-2 days.
  2. Bring a pot of water to a simmer, just under a boil, and blanch the pieces of fish heads and bones for a few seconds, just until they turn white around the edges.
  3. Dunk in ice water and clean off any scales or blood. Discard the blanching water.
  4. Place the cleaned bones and head in a clean pot with 6 1/2 cups water, 6 3/4 oz sake, and 1 tsp dried kombu. Bring to a simmer, skim off and discard scum, and simmer for 30-45 minutes until reduced by about a third.
  5. Taste and adjust the seasoning with salt. Serve the broth with pieces of fish head in the bowl (the meat in the head is the best part!) Garnish with yuzu peel and mitsuba herb.

Editors' Recommendations

Hunter Lu
Hunter Lu is a New York-based food and features writer, editor, and NYU graduate. His fiction has appeared in The Line…
How to make a buttery hollandaise sauce like a professional chef
Here's everything you need to know about this mother sauce
Eggs Benedict from Hash Kitchen

As Chef Joey Maggiore of the Arizona Brunch restaurant chain Hash Kitchen said, "Perfecting hollandaise is not necessarily the hardest, but it is a less forgiving sauce. You must pay attention to detail when making hollandaise so that you get the consistency and taste you need for the perfect sauce." Chef Maggiore couldn't be more spot on. Hollandaise is one of the five mother sauces, meaning, it's the base sauce for other, more complex sauces like béarnaise, choron, and maltaise sauces.

Before the technological age of blenders, the old-school method of making the perfect hollandaise sauce took some practice. But now, with technology, there are more foolproof ways to make the mother sauce. We'll cover all those methods, plus give you some of Chef Maggiore's tips and tricks on how to make hollandaise sauce. Also, stick around until the end for an easy hollandaise sauce recipe.
Hollandaise sauce ingredients

Read more
How to make sweet and crispy Hawaiian fried chicken
It's not Kentucky fried, but Hawaiian fried chicken is still finger lickin' good!
Garlic Hawaiin fried chicken

When you think of Hawaii, chances are you think of something like the picture above -- beautiful beaches, blue water, and palm trees. If you think of Hawaiian food, you're probably thinking of the legendary Kona coffee, seafood, coconuts, or the local delicacy, poi (we are not talking about Spam).

Chances are you didn't think of fried chicken, but you should have. Hawaiian fried chicken is like no other, from fragrant garlic chicken to sweet mochiko chicken, Hawaii is a fantastic place for fried poultry. At first glance, many of these dishes resemble Japanese fried chicken (karaage) as both styles feature bite-sized pieces of dark meat chicken, often marinated in soy and ginger. However, Hawaiian fried chicken is unique, a creation of the island's rich blend of cultures and cuisines.
Hawaiian fried chicken recipes

Read more
How to make the Earthquake cocktail in just 4 simple steps
Make this simple cocktail to start and end your gatherings with a bang
Earthquake cocktail

According to legend, the Earthquake cocktail was a favorite of Post-Impressionist painter Henri de Toulouse-Lautrec, who served it at the frequent parties he hosted. Originally a 50/50 blend of cognac and good absinthe, the two-ingredient cocktail certainly had the potential to start and/or end the evening with a bang.

Over the years, drink makers have mellowed the recipe for those looking for less inebriating libations. Whether you stick to tradition or tinker with the ingredients, the Earthquake makes a brilliant cocktail to add to your repertoire. And who knows, it just might make you a better painter as well (although we doubt it).
The Earthquake cocktail

Read more