Skip to main content

The Mac and Cheese Cookbook

Allison Arevalo and Erin Wade met by happenstance, when they shared a table with their husbands at a crowded café one Sunday. Arevalo, who worked in marketing, and Wade, who was a lawyer, started chatting about their love of food. It only made sense because Wade had previously worked as a pastry and line cook in New York while Arevalo worked as a server there. The two decided they also had common goals, and opened Homeroom, a restaurant in Oakland, California, dedicated to everyone’s favorite comfort food, macaroni and cheese. Their new tome, The Mac + Cheese Cookbook, takes their favorite recipes from Homeroom, so that everybody from the United States (and the world!) can enjoy the delicious goodness of Homeroom’s macaroni and cheese. The Manual quizzed Arevalo and Wade on the first time they fell in love with macaroni and cheese, how their cookbook came about and the best macaroni and cheese to make on a date.

Do you remember the first time you each fell in love with macaroni and cheese?

Recommended Videos

EW: My father made a homemade mac and cheese that just kicked the pants off the stuff in the box and I was addicted to it from a pretty young age.

AA: My Italian grandmother was the star cook in our house, and she would make an amazing homemade Italian-style mac and cheese which is the mac and cheese I first fell in love with.

Why is it so popular?

Can you eat mac and cheese and not have it bring a smile to your face?  The satisfying combination of pasta in a rich and creamy cheese sauce is so comforting, decadent, and nostalgic, it’s hard not to love it.

You already own Homeroom, a restaurant in Oakland, California dedicated to macaroni and cheese, why do a cookbook?

We had both always been really into food and food writing, and it was a dream of both of ours to write a cookbook.  So when an editor at Ten Speed Press called us and said that they were interested in having us write a Homeroom cookbook, it was almost too good to be true.  We also think that although there are a few mac and cheese cookbooks already out there, that ours is really special because we give you all the details on the basics, and you can riff on it 100 different ways at home.  We’ve also served more mac and cheese than any other restaurant in the world (we’re pretty sure), so we’ve got some really helpful techniques and great recipes we thought would be fun to share.

What’s the secret to good mac and cheese?

A silky cream sauce and using good cheeses.

How did you decide on which recipes to put in the cookbook?

At Homeroom we have about 12 macs on our menu at any given time, but we have dozens of recipes we are always waiting to put into the rotation either as a seasonal special or to replace something on the menu.  So luckily the book pretty much wrote itself, since we had most of our recipes already.  There are some recipes though that we developed specifically for the cookbook based on frequent requests we’ve had from customers (i.e. the mac cakes) that were difficult for us to implement at Homeroom for various reasons, but were perfect to round out the cookbook.

Why did you decide to include sides and desserts in it?

Although Homeroom is a mac and cheese restaurant, we pride ourselves on really making mac and cheese a meal with delicious side dishes, homemade desserts, and beer and wine pairings.  We wanted the cookbook to convey the same idea– that mac can be amazing on its own but that it can also be the centerpiece to a fabulous dinner.

What are your favorites?

We really do love them all, but if we had to pick favorites we’d go for the classic cheddar (for nostalgia) or the Dungeness crab mac (if we’re feeling fancy).

What’s the best mac and cheese recipe for a guy to make for:

– A Date: The Truffle Mac or Dungeness Crab Mac — because they are a little fancier and will make a lady feel special.

– His Family: The Gilroy Garlic Mac —It is far and away our best seller and a huge crowd pleaser for all ages.

– His Guy Friends- The Jalapeno Popper or Chili Mac — We came up with them for a Super Bowl party to feature our favorite Super Bowl party ingredients and these macs definitely have “guys night” written all over them.

The Mac + Cheese Cookbook: 50 Simple Recipes From Homeroom, America’s Favorite Mac and Cheese Restaurant, $10.61 at amazon.com.

Ann Binlot
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Ann Binlot is a New York-based freelance writer who contributes to publications like The Economist, Wallpaper*, Monocle…
This NYC restaurant is upgrading burgers with a new type of American cheese
We tried the Double-Smash Cheeseburger at Hoexter's to learn all about this cheese
Hoexter's smashburger closeup

For many burger purists, there's only one suitable cheese for the classic American burger — creamy and salty American cheese. But for others, American cheese is overprocessed and lacks the depth of flavor compared to cheddar or Swiss. The good news is that there's something called "New School" American cheese, which combines the great melt of processed American cheese with higher-quality ingredients.

An excellent way to try out New School American cheese is the Double-Smash Cheeseburger at Hoexter's. An American brasserie in Manhattan's Upper East Side, Hoexter's is making a classic double patty smash burger that showcases this product. We interviewed them and tried the burger to learn more.
What is New School American Cheese?

Read more
The best cheese for burgers: Our top 7 favorites
Blue cheese? On a burger? Trust us, it's delicious.
Cheeseburger

Unless you're an insane person (or avoid dairy for dietary or ethical reasons—you get a pass), you turn your hamburgers into cheeseburgers. Cheese truly does make everything better, and burgers are perhaps the best example of this. But which cheeses should you select when it comes time to light the grill and crack open some cold ones? We've got the answers.
Cheddar

Ah, classic cheddar. This trusty staple is certainly the most popular cheese for most backyard burgers. And while cheddar may be the typical choice, it's far from mundane. This hard cheese has a crumbly texture, an easily melty consistency, and a slightly tangy, nutty flavor that works beautifully on a burger.
Monterey and Pepper Jack

Read more
American cheese isn’t really cheese: The truth behind the burger topping staple
What you need to know about American cheese
cheeseburger

 

American cheese pairs wonderfully with a juicy cheeseburger -- which is why it's often a go-to whether you're ordering a cheeseburger at burger joints or making a burger on the grill at home. Yet despite its name, many people are shocked to learn that American cheese is not truly a cheese by definition. So what exactly is American cheese and is it healthy to consume? We'll break down the details of this popular burger topping to help you prepare for a killer grilling season.
What is American cheese?

Read more