Skip to main content

Pro tip: Remember to shop around for new auto insurance every year

Cheap auto insurance plans may be around the corner — but you'll have to take a detour to find them

Black Friday and Cyber Monday have come and gone, and you made your decision on whether or not to move it or lose it on a new TV or laptop at a steeply marked-down price. Now, you’re likely looking ahead to  your New Year’s goals. Re-evaluating work-life balance, finances, and physical health may be high on your list.

One item that may not be: Ensuring you have the best car insurance. We know you’re probably busy, and you may have even set up “auto renewal” on your auto insurance. You shopped around years ago, found effective and cheap auto insurance, and called it a day. The automatic renewal feature gives you one less thing to do, right? 

Right, you may be missing out on the best car insurance for you for the next six months or year ahead. 

Earlier this year, a Redditor made it a point to check their auto insurance and had to do a double-take. 

“We’ve been with Geico for 11 years, and for some reason, they hiked our rates by a whopping 40% on our latest renewal[I] called in thinking it had to be a mistake since nothing had changed on our end, and the rep was like, ‘Yep, sorry. Inflation,’” the Redditor wrote.

The person shopped around and got a sweeter deal from USAA. Besides inflation, here are some other reasons you may want to check out other auto insurance before your renewal date rolls around.

close up of a black car
Image used with permission by copyright holder
  • Return to normal means a return to higher rates. Turns out, current events may be a reason for the ever-changing auto insurance rates, providing a reason to do some research before renewing. suggests shopping around at least once per year and notes that fewer cars on the road led to some auto insurance reducing rates in 2020 and 2021. With traffic inching closer to pre-pandemic levels, rates may follow suit.
  • Your finances may have changed. Inflation may be affecting car insurance companies, but it may also be impacting your wallet. PEW Research published in the spring of 2022 found that Americans listed inflation as their top worry. If you’re concerned about finances or finding that your dollars aren’t stretching as far right now, you may want to look into a cheaper auto insurance plan. There may be some parts of coverage you can skip. You may also opt for a higher-deductible plan (just beware: If you need to use your insurance, you’ll have to pay more out of pocket to hit that deductible before your company steps in to help.)
  • You’re adding drivers. Do you plan to add a teen driver to your policy this year? Shopping around is important in this case. Different plans offer different rates for newbie drivers, according to the website

Attempting to score sweet deals on electric cars may be the big auto trend right now. Shopping around for the best car insurance every year may not save you time, but it can save you money. Other factors, such as a clean driving record, can affect your plan. Drive safely and abide by the laws for the best chances at the lowest-cost insurance plans. Make sure you’re reading the fine print of your plan. While some low-deductible plans appear like great deals at first glance, you’ll likely have to pay more out of pocket if you get into an accident. You can compare prices easily by getting quotes online or speaking with an insurance broker who can provide more insights.

Editors' Recommendations

BethAnn Mayer
Beth Ann's work has appeared on and In her spare time, you can find her running (either marathons…
MINI debuts 5th generation 3-door MINI Cooper and MINI Cooper S with gas engines
Gas-powered Mini Coopers live on
2025 Mini Cooper S left front three-quarter view studio shot with shadows.

When Mini launched the 2025 Mini Countryman Electric battery-electric vehicle (BEV) via the Sphere in Las Vegas last year, the easy reaction could have been, "Well, that's it for Mini and ICEs." But Mini just proved that response wrong. BMW Group's Mini brand recently announced the fifth generation Mini Cooper and Mini Cooper S gas-powered fun-mobiles for the global market.

Why gas-powered Mini Coopers matter
The Mini Cooper's appeal to auto enthusiasts has endured since the original models debuted in 1961. Small, cute, economical, easy to park, and fun to drive, the Mini Cooper has become larger and more potent in the last 63 years. Mini EV models have captured the most recent headlines, but the revered auto brand will not abandon its heritage.
The new generation Mini Cooper C and Mini Cooper S 3-door gas-powered cars combine the Mini's classic, minimalist design features, updated digital assistance and convenience features, and the Mini's go-cart-like driving experience.

Read more
We love this handsome van-life wood paneling, and it’s sustainable too
Lightweight, durable, and eco-friendly, Garnica paneling might be the very best wood for your van life build
Luxury vanlife build using Garnica lightweight poplar wood paneling.

If there's one thing the modern van life movement taught us, it's that living in your car doesn't have to feel like living in your car. The design of today's best custom campervans resembles many luxury studio apartments with high-end materials, finishes, and fixtures throughout. If you're building out your own custom campervan (or even daydreaming about it), you know that few choices can make as much of an impact as investing in good wood for your interior. If you're planning to spend months or longer on the road in your van, you're going to be looking at the walls and floors of your vehicle a lot. So why not invest in paneling you love? That's where Garnica comes in.

Upgrade the look of your van with Garnica's lightweight poplar paneling
The Spain-based company produces some of the lightest, most handsome, and most sustainable paneling that's perfect for RVs, campers, and campervans. Its poplar plywood paneling is available in four varieties: Efficiency, Performance, Ultralight, and Ultralight HPL. Each option is purpose-built with a particular goal in mind. If you're looking for budget-friendly, the Efficiency is your man. For weight-conscious setups (which is most van life builds), the Ultralight and Ultralight HPL are the way to go. If money is no object, the Performance line is Garnica's most premium paneling option.

Read more
We drove the new Kia EV9: 5 things we love (and 2 we don’t)
The best and worst things about the Kia EV9
Kia EV9

Kia EV9 front Kia / Kia

When Kia approached us to fly out to California's beautiful Napa Valley to get our hands on their new all-electric EV9 SUV and see what it could do up close and personal, we booked our flight faster than the time it took to uncork our favorite bottle of cabernet to celebrate the occasion.

Read more