Skip to main content

Are You Drinking the Best Beer in America?

Bell's Brewery/Facebook

Every year, hundreds of craft beer contests and surveys are held around the world. From homebrewing to international, awards are given out at every level, recognizing the best beers in a given place and time.

One of the biggest (and most heavily-weighted) of these beer surveys is put out by Zymurgy magazine, the publication produced by the American Homebrewers Association. Now in its sixteenth year, the annual study asks the 46,000-members in the association to choose their five favorite commercially-available beers. For the second year in a row, Bell’s Two Hearted Ale earned the top spot.

Russian River Brewing Company Pliny the Elder
Russian River Brewing Company

The previous favorite, Russian River Brewings’s Pliny the Elder (which was the winner from 2009 to 2016), came in at No. 2. There are other easily-recognizable names in the top 10, including The Alchemist’s Heady Topper (third) and Sierra Nevada’s Pale Ale (tied for fifth). Bell’s also took fourth for Hopslam. Founders Brewing snagged two fifth-place finishes for Canadian Breakfast Stout (CBS) and Kentucky Breakfast Stout (KBS), a ninth-place finish for Breakfast Stout, and 10th place for All Day IPA, tying with WeldWerks‘ Juicy Bits.

“As brewers, the members of American Homebrewers Association can discern the subtle differences between a good beer and an outstanding beer.,” said Gary Glass, director of the American Homebrewers Association. “Zymurgy’s Best Beers in America survey showcases which commercial beers are truly the best of the best out there, and all the breweries who made the list should be proud.”

Best Beers in America

bells brewery bee pour map
Bell's Brewery/Facebook

1. Bell’s Two Hearted Ale*
2. Russian River Pliny the Elder*
3. The Alchemist Heady Topper*
4. Bell’s Hopslam*
T5. Sierra Nevada Pale Ale*
T5. Founders CBS (Canadian Breakfast Stout)
T5. Founders KBS (Kentucky Breakfast Stout)
8. Three Floyds Zombie Dust*
9. Founders Breakfast Stout
T10. WeldWerks Juicy Bits*
T10. Founders All Day IPA

Best Breweries in America

founders brewing co cbs
Founder Brewing Co./Facebook

1. Bell’s Brewery, Inc. (Galesburg, Michigan)*
2. Founders Brewing Co. (Grand Rapids, Michigan)
3. Russian River Brewing Co. (Santa Rosa, California)*
4. Sierra Nevada Brewing Co. (Chico, California, and Mills River, North Carolina)*
5. Firestone Walker Brewing Company (Paso Robles, California)*
T6. Deschutes Brewery (Bend, Oregon)*
T6. Dogfish Head Craft Brewery (Milton, Delaware)*
8. Stone Brewing (Escondido, California)*
9. The Alchemist (Stowe, Vermont)*
10. Three Floyds Brewing Company (Munster, Indiana)*

Top-Ranked Beer Portfolios

stone brewing
Stone Brewing/Facebook

On the portfolio end of things, anyone who has sipped a craft beer in the last decade should not be surprised by this list.

1. Stone Brewing (33 beers)*
2. Firestone Walker Brewing Co. (29 beers)*
T3. New Belgium Brewing (24 beers)*
T3. Founders Brewing Co. (24 beers)
5. Dogfish Head Craft Brewery (23 beers)*
T6. Avery Brewing Co. (22 beers)
T6. Hill Farmstead Brewery (22 beers)*
T7. Boulevard Brewing Co. (20 beers)*
T7. Trillium Brewing Co. (20 beers)*
T9. Bell’s Brewery (19 beers)*
T9. Deschutes Brewery (19 beers)*
T9. Odell Brewing (19 beers)*
T9. Sierra Nevada Brewing Co. (19 beers)*
T9. The Bruery (19 beers)*
T9. Three Floyds Brewing (19 beers)

For more information, the complete list can be found at the American Homebrewers Association website.

T indicates tie; *indicates small and independent craft brewers.

Editors' Recommendations

Sam Slaughter
Sam Slaughter was the Food and Drink Editor for The Manual. Born and raised in New Jersey, he’s called the South home for…
What is a Gose style beer? All about this unique drink
Get to know this sour, tart, salty beer.
Gose beers

To say that there are a lot of beer styles is a massive understatement. Beer beginners might feel overwhelmed even when it comes to classifying popular beer styles like lagers, stouts, and IPAs. This is before you even get into offshoots of the lager, such as pilsners and Vienna lagers or barrel-aged or imperial stouts and double IPAs, New England-style IPAs, and even milkshake IPAs.

While the ginormous beer tree seems to grow a new beer style branch every few months, there are roughly around 100 different styles currently being brewed worldwide. That’s an awful lot of beer to pay attention to, let alone be knowledgeable about. But fear not, ordering a pint at your local bar or brewery won’t come with a questionnaire asking you to name the various styles. Still, it’s always a good idea to learn a little bit about some of the lesser-known styles in case you ever want to carry on an intelligent conversation with a beer fan. Today, it’s the Gose style of beer’s turn.
What is a Gose?

Read more
The best bars in New York City: Our top picks
Here's where to belly up to the bar in NYC
The Quixote Bar.

If you're known as The City That Never Sleeps, you probably have a few good bars to your name. New York is the ultimate beehive, going strong regardless of the borough or time of day. That makes for a pretty rich NYC bar culture.

Sure, there are trending establishments that draw huge lines—look at you, Double Chicken Please. But there are also excellent dives, tremendous wine bars, and watering holes that make you reexamine the definition of a great cocktail.

Read more
Kolsch-style beers are perfect for spring, and these are our favorites
Perfect for spring, this beer style is known for its hoppy, criso flavor.
Close-up of a glass of beer

If you’ve never heard a Kölsch before, what are you waiting for? Not only is this beer style great any time of year, but it’s also particularly fantastic during the spring months. Made with top-fermenting yeast like an ale before being conditioned at cold temperatures like a lager, this hoppy, crisp beer has its origins in Cologne, Germany. But there’s a little more to it than that.
Kölsch is more than a name

Kölsch is similar to Cognac, Scotch, or Tequila in that, as of 1997, it has a protected geographical indication. Just like those other forms of alcohol that have specific geographic parameters, technically, Kölsch must be brewed within 31 miles of the city of Cologne. This hasn’t stopped American brewers from trying their hand at this fresh, crisp style. While some don’t pay close attention to the rules and call their beers Kölsch, others pay tribute to Germany by calling their brews Kölsch-style beers.
What does Kölsch taste like?

Read more