Skip to main content

David Fincher says he met with Warner Bros. for ‘Harry Potter’

This wasn't the last time the franchise flirted with hiring an autuer filmmaker.

Harry Potter holding a wand and looking disappointed.
Warner Bros.

David Fincher has dipped his toes into the world of blockbuster adaptations in the past, but his take on Harry Potter probably would have been quite different from the films we ultimately got. During a recent interview to celebrate the re-release of Se7en on 4K, the legendary director said that he met with Warner Bros. about directing the first film.

“I was asked to come in and talk to them about how I would do ‘Harry Potter,’” Fincher explained in an interview with Variety. “I remember saying, ‘I just don’t want to do the clean Hollywood version of it. I want to do something that looks a lot more like Withnail and I, and I want it to be kind of creepy.’”

Recommended Videos

Fincher explained that the studio was looking for something a little more traditional for what would become one of its tentpole franchises of the 2000s. “They were like, ‘We want Thom Browne schooldays by way of Oliver.’”

While Fincher never wound up making a Harry Potter movie, Warner Bros. did briefly let an auteur filmmaker into the franchise when Alfonso Cuarón directed Harry Potter and the Prisoner of Azkaban. That third installment in the franchise was a radical installment from the first two, but it also set the template for what the franchise would feel like moving forward. Cuarón and Fincher aren’t exactly comparable, but the two are both highly touted directors from the same era of moviemaking. Prisoner of Azkaban is today regarded as the best of the Harry Potter movies by most, in part because of Cuarón’s directorial sensibilities.

Joe Allen
Contributor
Joe Allen is a freelance culture writer based in upstate New York. His work has been published in The Washington Post, The…
HBO is eyeing a British Oscar-winner to play Dumbledore in their ‘Harry Potter’ series
The casting is not yet official, and negotiations haven't even begun.
Mark Rylance in Dunkirk

There have been questions swirling around the Harry Potter TV series ever since it was first announced. The series will adapt the same novels that were already adapted into a hugely popular film franchise, so adapting the same story again struck some as foolhardy. Even so, Warner Bros. is proceeding with the adaptation, and Variety is now reporting that they are eyeing a British legendy for the role of Dumbledore.

The publication is reporting that Mark Rylance, who won an Oscar for Steven Spielberg's Bridge of Spies, is in the mix for the crucial role in the new adaptation. While negotiations aren't underway yet, Variety is reporting that the studio has reached out to the actor's representation to gauge interest.

Read more
Warner Bros. tried to lure Christopher Nolan back with an enormous check
The director is set up at Universal for his next film, which is slated to hit theaters in 2026.
John David Washington and Robert Pattinson in Tenet.

After a saga in which Christopher Nolan felt that his movie, Tenet, was mishandled by Warner Bros., the director parted ways with the studio. Nolan had worked with Warner Bros. for most of his professional career, but the studio's decision to release many of its 2021 titles both in theaters and on HBO Max was profoundly upsetting to the director.

Since leaving Warner Bros., Nolan has set up shop at Universal Studios, which is where he directed Oppenheimer, earning the studio a Best Picture Oscar. Nolan has also set his next film up at Universal, but Variety is reporting that Warner Bros. made a concerted effort to get the director back. When he battled with the studio over Tenet, they agreed to release the movie theatrically if he agreed to forego certain fees that were part of his contract. Nolan agreed at the time, and Warner Bros. tried to lure him back by writing a seven-figure check with the money that he had foregone.

Read more
From Alien 3 to The Killer, these are the best David Fincher movies ranked
If you're a Fincher fan, add all these films to your must-watch list
Alien 3

Since he emerged on the scene with his own Alien sequel, David Fincher has gained a reputation for being exacting, precise, and brilliant. Whether he's making an unconventional thriller or a throwback to Hollywood's golden age, Fincher's movies are always distinctive, imaginative, and hugely engaging.

Over the course of his career as a director, Fincher has made more than a couple of genuine masterpieces. While he's yet to win any major Oscars, Fincher has always seemed most interested in following his own muse, and is less concerned about how his decisions will be viewed by those around him. You may think of Fincher as a thriller guy, but anyone who's followed his career closely knows that thrillers aren't the only thing he makes.

Read more