Skip to main content

Is exercise enough to combat the effects of sitting all day? New study dives in

Taking a quick walk when you get off work might not be enough to offset the health dangers of sitting for so long.

man wearing black t shirt exercising outdoors outside with blue steps
Gabin Vallet / Unsplash

One in four adults in the United States sits for at least eight hours every day. Research highlights that people who sit down for most of the day have a 34% higher risk of heart disease compared to those who have a more active workday. The detrimental impact of a sedentary lifestyle is widely known. On the other hand, exercise is good for your health, and many people think moderate exercise is enough to offset the adverse effects of sitting all day. If you sit all day at a desk but you work out afterward, does that exercise session negate the effects of sitting for all those hours? A new study dives in.

The study

Man working at desk tie
cottonbro studio / Pexels

A study published in the journal PLOS One involved data from an ongoing study of over one thousand former or current people from Colorado. The researchers focused on relatively young participants aged 28 to 49, with an average age of 33. The lead study author, Ryan Bruellman, explained that they chose this age group because younger adults “tend to think they’re impervious to the impacts of aging. But what you do during this critical time of life matters.” 

Recommended Videos

The majority of the participants sat for many hours, with an average of almost nine hours daily. For the study, there were different exercise rates ranging from 80 and 160 minutes of moderate physical activity every week to less than 135 minutes of vigorous exercise every week.

The researchers assessed every participant’s ‘heart age’ using two heart health indicators: body mass index or BMI and cholesterol levels. The cholesterol levels included total cholesterol and high-density lipoprotein. 

The results

The Fitbit Charge 5 during exercise.
Fitbit Morgan / Fitbit

The minimum daily exercise recommendations were about 20 minutes of moderate exercise per day. Even the study participants who met those recommendations still had higher total cholesterol and higher body mass index or BMI levels. In other words, when the researchers checked the heart markers, they determined that performing moderate exercise for about 20 minutes daily didn’t help or counteract the negative impact of sitting for an average of almost nine hours. As the sitting time increased, so did the heart aging.

The participants who performed ‘vigorous’ exercise like running, swimming laps, or playing basketball for around 30 minutes or more per day experienced changes in those markers and had cholesterol levels similar to sedentary people about five years and ten years younger. 

It seems that vigorous exercise helped counteract the harm from sitting. The researchers expressed the importance of getting up and moving around throughout the day, recommending trying standing desks and incorporating more vigorous exercise into your week. 

The best types of vigorous exercise

Man swimming freestyle.
Goroden Koff / Shutterstock

Taking a quick walk when you get off work might not be enough to offset the health dangers of sitting for so long. It might be time to up the ante and get those muscles moving more.

Here are some of the best types of vigorous exercise to try:

  • Hiking uphill.
  • Cycling at a brisk pace or steeply uphill.
  • Swimming fast or swimming laps.
  • Strength training.
  • Dancing.
  • Aerobic exercise.
  • Heavy gardening, such as digging.
  • Jogging or running.
  • Martial arts.
  • Sports involving lots of sprinting or movement, such as hockey, soccer, and basketball.
  • Tennis and court sports like racquetball and squash.
  • High-intensity interval training.
Topics
Steph Green
Steph Green is a content writer specializing in healthcare, wellness, and nutrition. With over ten years of experience, she…
Joe Rogan’s new kettlebell workout is challenging without pushing you to failure
Fitness buff and podcaster Joe Rogan knows how to stay in shape with kettlebells
Hand holding kettlebell close up

Research shows performing kettlebell exercises can improve functional strength, lower inflammation, and more. These cute teapot-shaped weights are worth picking up, swinging around with a kettlebell swing, and including in your weekly workout routine. Fitness buffs like Joe Rogan swear by the humble kettlebell.

Rogan has worn many hats over the years, from American podcaster and comedian to actor, television host, and UFC color commentator. Staying in shape is important for Rogan to keep up with his busy schedule, and recently on his JRE podcast, he shared how he also picks up those kettlebells to power up and stay fit. He goes with the flow and how he feels when choosing an activity, working out five days a week, and incorporating weightlifting, kickboxing, yoga, and more. 

Read more
How do cold plunges affect your gains and recovery? Interesting new research
Should you dip into the iciness after a workout? Will it hamper recovery?
two men in icy lake ice bath swim

Taking an icy dip for your health requires bravery and the power of the mind. Personally, I prefer a hot bath or a warm shower to a cold plunge, but I’ve seen the growing research on the benefits of cold therapy, including a protective effect against obesity, cardiovascular disease, and a range of metabolic conditions. Additional research suggests cold water immersion can reduce stress, improve mood, and potentially slow the progression of neurodegenerative conditions.

With all the positive benefits of cold plunges, I was surprised to hear about the recent research on how cold plunges impact muscle recovery and blood flow following a workout. Let’s take a look.

Read more
Do red light therapy blankets really work for exercise recovery and better sleep?
I tried a red light blanket for exercise recovery and sleep improvement
Red light therapy blanket

Red light therapy is currently having a moment, and here at The Manual, we’re right in the middle of it. Personally, I’ve covered the men’s skincare wands and face masks that use red light therapy, and I’ve been generally impressed. It’s an intriguing technology with some truly interesting potential.
Given all that, getting the opportunity to try a red light therapy blanket  for a very different purpose was more than welcome. The focus for this tryout was fitness, health, and wellness — specifically on exercise recovery and improved sleep quality.
To be transparent, my exercise profile includes running 35 to 40 miles a week, over half of them barefoot. My sleep background is sketchy at best — I’m a restless, fitful sleeper, so I went into the tryout open to any benefits the blanket could provide.   

Red light therapy blanket parameters and capabilities

Read more