Skip to main content

Is binge-watching a dying TV model? Experts weigh in

Weekly releases vs. binge-watching: Which is the better model for streaming platforms?

Man and woman watching Netflix
Image used with permission by copyright holder

If you’re a diehard HBO fan, you’re probably still mourning the end of the first season of The Last of Us. The terrifying, yet heartwarming drama kept fans on the edge of their seats for almost two months, as everyone collectively discussed how the series was going to finish and whether it would stay true to the video game.

It’s hard to imagine the adventures of Pedro Pascal’s Joel and Bella Ramsey’s Ellie would have hit home in the same manner if the streaming service would have released all nine episodes in one fell swoop. Still, this binge-watching model is how many of HBO’s competitors have garnered success in the last decade, not the least of which is Netflix.

The world’s most famous streaming TV service helped revolutionize how people consume content. Some fans love the thrill of devouring an entire season of TV in one night, as it might resemble watching a super long movie. There’s clearly been a reversal of this model in recent times, though. Not only does HBO Max do weekly releases, but other streaming platforms like Hulu, Disney+, and Paramount+ all have patterned schedules for their programs. Does this mean the binge-watching model is dead? Let’s discuss this further!

Why did binge-watching take over the 2010s?

TV has always been about making a profit, just like any other business venture in a capitalist society. Netflix and HBO Max aren’t in the market to cater to consumers unless it is financially advantageous for them. Keeping this in mind, Netflix pioneered binge-watching by releasing its shows all at once and the streaming service did this because it made itself loads of cold hard cash. Subscribers would purchase packages with Netflix to catch up on all of their favorites and classics at once, and it still allowed flexibility for certain demographics that couldn’t watch TV on a weekly basis.

According to Francis Perdue, the founder of Scooter P Entertainment, the binge model opened up TV options for people who weren’t typically invested in regular programming. This sentiment still prevails for companies like Netflix in 2023. “Binge-watching for busy professionals, business owners, and even teenagers is helping them keep up with trends, news, and new seasons of shows that are actually released on a weekly TV schedule for new episodes of new seasons,” Perdue said.

Stranger Things
Netflix

Streaming services like Netflix make a huge profit from binge-watching because it’s addictive. Consuming one series leads to taking on another one, and yet another one. Netflix leads its customers down a rabbit hole of options because of the sheer amount of content and the accessibility of the shows available to them. After indulging in the sci-fi perfection of Stranger Things, viewers get suggestions of similar shows that will help Netflix garner loyalty and attention from their customers.

Perdue explained, “It is all about the subscription level or bundle the customer is on. That is where the revenue comes from, and when customers binge-watch, that gives the opportunity to promote more options of shows to watch and advertisements can be viewed as well.”

So, if there are so many pros to binge-watching, why has it been trending backward? There have to be several upsides to the tried-and-true method of tuning in at the same time every week, and anticipating the next episode of a show for seven days in between.

Succession fourth season

How has the weekly release seen a revival?

Weekly releases of TV have been the standard going back to the days of I Love Lucy and Gilligan’s Island. Tuning in on Wednesdays at 8 p.m. on ABC for Abbott Elementary or Sunday nights on HBO for Succession remains a highlight of the TV-watching experience, and channels like these have never swayed from this style of storytelling. Even as Netflix changed the game, old-school release schedules endured in certain sectors of television, because they are advantageous for profits in a plethora of ways. This helps explain why so many other networks and streamers have started to return to this model.

“Binge-watching is not the optimal model for profits,” says Scott Lieberman, the founder of TouchdownMoney.com. “The reason is simple. Customers can watch all the episodes of their favorite show and then easily cancel. There’s really no penalty. Just subscribe again when there’s another show they want to see on the service.”

“Survey data from Mintel revealed that nearly 20% of HBO customers would cancel the service after their favorite show stopped making new episodes. Knowing that they rely on the blockbuster TV show model (such as The Sopranos and Game of Thrones), HBO will milk a hit for all its worth.”

It’s easy to see how the weekly model has re-won the hearts of people worldwide. The aforementioned shows like The Last of Us and The Sopranos would have lost a lot of their luster by being watched in one sitting. These are literary masterpieces that tell a long-form story. The characters and the setting are meant to be absorbed in meaningful and patient ways. Episodes get lost in the shuffle when people binge.

The poignant LGBTQ+ story told in the third episode of The Last of Us would have been overshadowed by the bombastic season finale in a binged setting. The final season of Succession would already be over if it were on Netflix instead of HBO. The anticipation and the discussion surrounding TV when it’s released every week is undoubtedly a good thing for streamers who choose to go that route. People are forced to maintain their subscriptions for longer, and social media sites like Twitter and Reddit are inundated with fan theories and analysis, bringing more viewers to the party.

Disney Plus - icon

Where is streaming TV headed in the future?

After consulting with our experts and using personal preference to suss out the field, it feels like streaming TV will have a potpourri of options to choose from in the coming years. Netflix still brags about the number of subscribers it has and the minutes of content consumed by its original programming and acquired classics. On the other hand, HBO Max and Disney+ are riding high on the backs of their gradual releases week by week. Both models are financially feasible, but expect the OG way of watching TV to win this tug-of-war at some point in the next decade.

“This [weekly watching] is also the reason live sports programming is so profitable. It’s binge-proof. People want to watch in real time,” adds Lieberman. “That’s why the New York Yankees bought back their YES Network for $3.47 billion.”

TV is the most engaging entertainment medium on the planet. Staying true to its roots is the reason it will continue to captivate and enthrall people from all walks of life for the foreseeable future.

Editors' Recommendations

Shawn Laib
Shawn Laib is a freelance writer with publications such as Den of Geek, Quote.com, Edge Media Network, diaTribe, SUPERJUMP…
These are the best Disney Plus shows to add to your watch list in May
Disney nostalgia and awesome new shows to stream
The Mandalorian looks out over the sun

Disney Plus has finally created a competitive library of original series that can compete with other services like Netflix and Max. It is also a treasure trove of Disney nostalgia for anyone who grew up in the 90s and early 2000s. On top of all that, the streamer has released a few of the most popular TV series to come out in recent years, and those series, on top of the deep catalog, make a Disney Plus subscription worthwhile for any viewer or Disney fan.

With content from Star Wars, Marvel, and the Disney channel all available to stream right now, there's something for everyone, whatever you might be into. If you're looking for movies, take a look at our must-watch list of Disney Plus movies. Now, keep reading and check out the best Disney Plus shows you can stream this month.

Read more
These are the best movies to watch on Peacock in May
Peacock is a TV service, but it also has a great catalog of movies to stream, too
Jack Black in Bernie.

A fun bit of historic TV trivia is that the original NBC peacock logo was first implemented in 1956 to highlight the network's new color programming. Even though the logo has gone through numerous iterations since then, the network has stuck with the colorful bird, in one form or another, for going on six decades now. It’s fitting, then, that Peacock is known most for its TV programming, highlighted by shows like The Office, Parks and Rec, and the self-mocking (and hilarious) 30 Rock. If you are on Peacock for the shows, however, don't overlook that the platform is also home to a number of great movies spanning cinema history, including everything from great comedy to excellent sports movies.

Peacock streaming offers both free (registered) and paid accounts. As a result, some Peacock movies are available without a paid subscription, and others only for subscribers. This roundup culls titles from both groups. To be sure you can access all of these classics, you'll have to fork over a subscription fee. Happy streaming and keep reading to find the best movies on Peacock right now.

Read more
The best shows on Paramount Plus to binge in May
Stream these incredible shows on Paramount Plus
Penny Dreadful scene

Having a vast library of good television shows and films is the most important factor in the success of a streaming service. That's part of what transformed Netflix into a global phenomenon, and it's why services like Paramount Plus have worked hard to build a healthy library of series that subscribers can browse through. As is the case with all streaming services, Paramount Plus has a mix of original series that live only on the platform and older shows that were originally on broadcast and have now found a home on streaming.
Although these shows have varied histories, each one of them is a great staple in Paramount Plus's overall streaming library. Paramount Plus will likely continue to develop original content, but these Paramount Plus shows will stand the test of time, whether they're ongoing or have been over for a decade or longer.

Penny Dreadful (2014)

Read more