Skip to main content

High on Hops: The Black Sheep Pub, Costa Rica’s Mountaintop Craft Beer Bar

I’ve been to the top of the mountain.

Perched on high, you can see the Pacific Ocean. In between you and the flat horizon line of bright blue water is a lush, tropical jungle. Howler monkeys scamper in the trees to your left. An immaculately manicured garden of native plants stands guard to your right.

And there is beer.

The craft-brewing boom has truly taken over the world, and now even the traditionally sweet-lager crazy country of Costa Rica has several boutique cerveza artesenal brands within its beautiful borders. If your travels take you outside of the capital city of San Jose, beers from Costa Rica’s Craft Brewing Company and TreintayCinco can be very hard –if not impossible –to find. Instead, long-established makers Imperial and Pilsen line the market shelves, leaving no space for these younger and more adventurous upstarts.

To find great craft beer in Nosara, one of Costa Rica’s most scenic beach towns, you need a four-wheel drive truck and directions to the Black Sheep Pub.

The drive from Nosara up the mountain to the Black Sheep feels nearly vertical in places. In the rainy season, the road can be washed away in large chunks. If coming from the north, you may have to cross rivers. At night, giant cows snooze in the middle of the road behind blind corners. Fortunately, it’s worth every nail-biting second.

The Black Sheep is owned by Joe Wygal, formerly of Massachusetts, and his wife Helen. Set slightly apart from his home and guest cottages, the bar is comprised of two indoor rooms – one strictly UK with English and Irish influences, and the other more widely European with a Belgian and Czech flair. Those spaces are complemented by an outdoor German Bier Garden.

To call the pub authentic would be a disservice. Walking inside from the wilds of an untamed landscape to find proper glassware, antique beer ephemera from the old country, and beer that excites as well as refreshes is nothing short of a mountaintop miracle.

There’s a traditional beer engine mounted to the gorgeous locally-made bar and multiple taps for the best selection of small-batch Costa Rican beers in the province. While pouring a pint, Joe is likely to tell you a story about attending the 1969 Woodstock Festival or meeting renowned beer critic Michael Jackson. Or better yet, the story of shipping all of his barware and paraphernalia, thousands of pieces, to Costa Rica on barges.

It’s a true pub in the European spirit, as The Black Sheep is not just a place for enjoying beer. It’s also a place for talking and forging friendships. Add that convivial atmosphere with the surrounding natural beauty and it becomes one of the most inspirational drinking spots on earth.

The Black Sheep may be hard to find, but it’s a must-visit destination for beer lovers touring Costa Rica. If it’s a pilgrimage you’d like to make, be sure to do it soon. The property is currently on the market and the last open event is scheduled for St. Patrick’s Day, 2015. It will be available by appointment until June when Joe plans to move The Black Sheep to a new location in San Ramon. You can make arrangements to visit by calling or messaging through Facebook.

Editors' Recommendations

The 11 Best Mexican Beers To Add To Your Craft Beer Collection in 2022

Taco Tuesday and Cinco de Mayo wouldn't be complete without a cerveza to wash things down, and if you want to keep things authentic, you’ll need to venture south of the border to get your liquor fix. But there’s more to the country’s beer scene than shoving a lime wedge into the neck of your Corona.

From big-name lagers to noteworthy American breweries paying homage to their southern brethren, the quality and diversity of craft brewing happening across Mexico deserve recognition. We’ve rounded up 11 of our favorites for you to add to your best beers collection. Some of them are available in the U.S. or via overseas merchants, while others require a passport. Nevertheless, these bottles are well worth the trip.
Baja Brewing: Por Favor Mexican IPA

Read more
How Harlem Hops, a Craft Beer Bar, is Giving Back to Harlem Students
brands giving back harlem hops craft beer bar founders

When the doors to Harlem Hops opened in 2018, its mission was to bring incredible beers to an incredible neighborhood. Three years later, the gastropub and its owners have become a thriving part of Harlem's restaurant renaissance, with their influence pouring far past the bar glasses and into the streets of the community around it.

After lamenting over the lack of locations uptown where beer lovers could enjoy high-quality, rare, innovative brews, partners Kim Harris, Stacey Lee, and Kevin Bradford turned their passion for pints and philanthropy into the first Black-owned craft beer bar in Harlem.

Read more
The 3 Best Scary Beers To Drink on Halloween
halloween beer

Our most revered Halloween ritual involves children donning costumes, armed with buckets, heading out into twilight to solicit their neighbors for candy. If you’ve found yourself too old to dress up as a toilet paper mummy, it doesn’t mean you still can’t enjoy a Halloween Cocktail or two on All Hallows’ Eve. If you need some inspiration for what to pair with your candy corn and fun-size chocolate bars, here are some spooky American craft brews. You may not associate chopped-up bodies, space warlords, and specters with craft beer options, these three Halloween beers will definitely scare up your taste buds and get you in the spirit.
Hopped in Half by 3 Floyds Brewing Co.

A few years ago, we announced Three Floyds as the “winner” of Halloween beer. The Indiana brewery celebrates gore and horror all year long with its unique beer-naming conventions and often disturbing artwork. Hopped in Half is a pilsner with 5.3% ABV and mild notes of pepper and lemon. You can’t miss this 22 oz bomber sitting on shelves thanks to its label, which showcases a brightly colored rendering of a demon beast cleaved into a cross section of itself. Hopped in Half was brewed with input from the death-metal band Obituary.

Read more