Chaney’s voice is an important part of that interpretation. Both powerful and warbling, it recalls Sandy Denny in its clarity and expansiveness, but remains unique nonetheless. “The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face” needs only the drone of a harmonium backing her. The result is a starkly beautiful take on the classic song. “Bonny May,” on the other hand, is bright with a bouncy, ear-catching melody. The song runs through its six-and-a-half minutes at a brisk pace, telling the story of a lover who goes off to (and eventually returns from) war.
Olivia Chaney’s voice is not the only one the album, however; Colin Meloy takes lead vocals on “Blackleg Miner,” a rollicking track about strikebreakers and the violence committed against them. He also performs a duet with Chaney on The Queen of Hearts‘ closing track, “To Make You Stay.”
The Queen of Hearts works amazingly as an homage to Britain’s psychedelic folk rock of the 1960s and 1970s, but it is not simply a recreation of that music. As often as Chaney, Meloy, and co. stay true to the sound on certain songs on the album, others deviate into new and interesting territory. Hopefully, Olivia Chaney and The Decemberists will join forces again to record and perform as Offa Rex.