Skip to main content

Dogfish Head Releases First-Ever Whiskey Called Alternate Takes

If you haven’t had the opportunity to visit Dogfish Head Brewing‘s restaurant Brewings & Eats in Rehoboth Beach, Delaware, any time between 2002 and now, you might not know, but the brewery famous for off-centered ales has been pumping out off-centered spirits since then too. Now, over a decade and a half later, DFH’s spirits arm, Dogfish Head Distilling Company, is releasing its first whiskey called Alternate Takes: Volume 1 Whiskey Finished in Rum Casks.

“We got our start in 2002 when Sam [Calagione] convinced some Dogfish Head World Wide Stout fans who were also engineers to help design a new 200-gallon still from reclaimed farm equipment,” says James Montero, Dogfish Head Distilling Company’s general manager. “Until 2015, Dogfish Head used this still, lovingly called ‘Frankenstill,’ to distill small-batch vodkas, gins, and rums primarily for folks visiting the Rehoboth area and Dogfish Head Brewings & Eats.”

Alternate Takes Volume 1 Whiskey Finished in Rum Casks
Dogfish Head Distilling Co./Facebook

These spirits helped them establish an audience, allowing them to keep growing the brand and increasing the quality of the spirits produced. Then, in 2015, the distilling operations moved to a new state-of-the-art distillery located in the heart of the Milton, Delaware, brewing campus, according to Montero. This allowed them to tap “all the same awesome malt suppliers, brewing expertise, equipment, and warehousing space that supports our off-centered ales.”

While this isn’t the first whiskey DFH has made, it is the first one that is being sold on its own. Previously, DFH has released Sonic Archaeology, a bottled cocktail containing a blend of DFH’s rum, brandy, and whiskey. The move to the larger facility, Montero says, has allowed the company to truly invest in a whiskey program.

Dogfish Head Distilling Co. Quick Sip Clip: Whiskey Finished in Rum Casks - Alternate Takes Volume 1

Alternate Takes Whiskey is first fermented using a blend of malted barleys and DFH’s proprietary ale yeast. It was aged for two years and spent the first two-thirds of the time in 53-gallon, charred, new American Oak barrels before it was transferred to casks that previously held another DFH spirit, Barrel Honey Rum, which helps imbue even more smooth caramel, vanilla, and (of course) honey notes. Further tasting reveals candied nuts, spicy cinnamon, and a cocoa and smoke finish.

While this is the first whiskey release, it certainly isn’t going to be the last from DFH.

“Under the Alternate Takes name, our fans should expect an experimental whiskey release once a year, usually around the holidays.”

“Because of our brewing heritage, we love malt and will continue to play with a variety of different style malted barleys to make new whiskies; we will also experiment with a variety of different barrel types and finishings,” Montero says. “Under the Alternate Takes name, our fans should expect an experimental whiskey release once a year, usually around the holidays. The type of finishing for this second volume of Alternate Takes will be announced at a later date.”

Currently, Alternate Takes (as well as DFH’s other spirits) are available in Delaware, Maryland, Washington, D.C., and northern Virginia. The company will be expanding distribution in 2019 to Pennsylvania and New Jersey, with hopes to continue expansion later in the year.

If you do make it toRehobothh, Montero suggests visiting DFH’s restaurants, Chesapeake & Maine or Brewings & Eats, because while there you can try some of the whiskeys in development and provide feedback, playing a part in future releases from the company.

Editors' Recommendations

Sam Slaughter
Sam Slaughter was the Food and Drink Editor for The Manual. Born and raised in New Jersey, he’s called the South home for…
The best añejo tequilas to prepare for Cinco de Mayo
Drin anejo tequila this Cinco de Mayo
Tequila shot with salt

When it comes to drinking holidays, there are two that stand out. The first is St. Patrick’s Day with its green beer, Irish whiskey, and dry Irish stouts. The second is Cinco de Mayo with its tequila and Mexican beer. While we honestly don’t know why we celebrate St. Patrick’s Day, we do know that Cinco de Mayo is not a celebration of Mexico’s Independence Day (that’s in September). It’s the day to remember the Mexican victory over France in the Battle of Pueblo.

Over the years, to celebrate Cinco de Mayo, we’ve enjoyed our fair share of blanco tequila shots and light Mexican lagers. As we’ve grown, we’ve realized we prefer something with a little more complexity. That’s why this year we’re going to sip añejo tequilas instead.
What is an añejo tequila?

Read more
Secrets revealed: Easy ways to elevate your cocktail game from a pro mixologist
How to improve your home mixology game
grasshopper cocktail

Making a top-notch cocktail is not implied. Even if you're working with a great drink recipe or all the necessary ingredients, you still have to execute. Fortunately, we know some people in the trade who have been turning out incredible cocktails for years.

That's certainly the case with Mike Milligan. He's the lead barkeep at Four Seasons in Oahu. From twists on classic cocktails to nailing a good egg white drink, he's the man for the job.

Read more
Clams vs mussels: The differences explained
These two delicious ingredients are more different than you think
Seafood pasta

For whatever reason, shellfish has a rather high-maintenance reputation. Perhaps it's simply the lack of familiarity in many American households. Clams and mussels are indeed a delicious indulgence when dining out, but they are not necessarily a staple of weeknight dinners at home—at least, not necessarily in non-coastal states. Salmon or shrimp may be the fish that grace our tables on seafood night, but seldom mussels or clams. This may be because shellfish can be tricky and unfamiliar.

The truth is that both clams and mussels are impressive, delicious ingredients that are truly easy to prepare in a variety of ways. Whether steamed, broiled, baked, sauteed, or grilled, these beautifully briney little mollusks make for meals that feel elegant and sophisticated but with very little effort and usually a relatively small price tag. But what's the difference between these two shellfish, and how are they best used in your dishes at home?
Clams vs mussels: Similarities and differences

Read more