This tiny archipelago eschews the chain resorts common in Jamaica and the Dominican Republic in favor of beautiful, historic, and just-right boutique hotels. Here are three of our favorites.
Frenchmans Hotel
It’s not the biggest, the most lavish, or the most luxurious. But, Frenchmans is a textbook example of what a Caribbean boutique hotel should be. Each of the nine rooms is an intimate, one- or two-bedroom standalone villa with full kitchens, luxurious bathrooms, and spacious balconies with stunning sea views. Its secluded location — tucked into a corner of the tiny island of Frenchmans Cay — affords a quiet, relaxed vibe that feels far more remote than it actually is. A private swimming lagoon, a waterfront plunge pool, a kayaking beach, and an upscale gourmet restaurant that’s as popular with locals as guests all ensure you’ll never need to venture off-property.
Peter Island Resort & Spa
Exclusive private island vacations aren’t just for the 1% anymore (although Peter Island Resort & Spa offers plenty of suitable, over-the-top accommodations for them too). Most of the villas on this stunning, 1,800-acre island, however, are luxurious, but not extravagant. There’s a reserved sophistication to the design that feels perfectly understated and “boutique.” All feature private balconies, couples showers, and sweeping views of the Caribbean Sea. Only a few dozen guests are allowed on the island at any one time. With five private beaches (including Honeymoon Beach — a long stretch of sand reserved for just two guests at a time), a pool, and two seafront restaurants, there’s no shortage of room to spread out. The private marina — with slips capable of accommodating 170-foot yachts — reminds guests that this is no ordinary Sandals resort.
Sugar Mill Hotel
Few hotels embrace the island’s rich history like the Sugar Mill Hotel. Set among the ruins of a 400-year-old sugar plantation, many beautifully preserved relics from the property’s former life, including redwood tables, fine china, and original iron boiling pots. The candlelit dining room at the on-site Rum House restaurant is among the most intimate and charming in Tortola’s West End (with prices to match). In recent years, the property has undergone substantial renovations to include a contemporary decor that’s sleek, chic, and befitting of a four-star boutique hotel. A private beach and a secluded pool with adjacent cocktail bar are all most guests need to unwind without ever having to leave the property.
