Over My Dead Body’s Matthew Shaer on Making a Great True Crime Podcast

beards booze bacon over my dead body true crime episode the manual podcast

What new bourbon are we pumped about? Which hiking trail are we exploring? Why is the next supercar so cool? The Manual is dedicated to helping men live a more engaged life. Each week, our editors and guests get together for a round-table discussion about what’s new, exciting, and unique in the men’s lifestyle world. So pop open your favorite brew, step into your man cave, and start streaming.

For this week’s episode of Beards, Booze, and Bacon: The Manual Podcast, the round-table — managing editor Nicole Raney, food and drink editor Sam Slaughter, and the inimitable host, Greg Nibler — sit down with the creator and host of Over My Dead Body, Matthew Shaer, to talk about his podcast, true crime, and why we’re all so obsessed with it.

To start, we find out how Shaer came across the crime that the first season of his podcast focuses on: the murder of Dan Markel. (We’ll give you a hint: It all starts with some particularly demented rabbis). From there, the gang digs into what it takes to make a true crime podcast. How do you research a chase? How long does it take to create a single season of a show? How does it feel now that the season is done?

Finally, the group digs into the true crime genre as a whole. Why does it continue to rise in popularity? What does that say about us as a culture? Is true crime going anywhere?

If you’re a fan of true crime, or even if you’re just starting to get into it because half of your Netflix recommendations seems to be about murderers and crimes, then this episode is for you. There is more to creating a successful crime podcast than being obsessed with a crime, and Shaer discusses everything it takes and more.

Are you a true crime fan? What shows do you listen to or watch? Do you know the next Serial and want to share that with us? If you have a question or comment for The Manual podcast crew, give us a shout at podcast@themanual.com — we’re always around! You can follow us on Facebook and Twitter. Make sure to subscribe and rate on your favorite podcast app, too!

Further Reading

Food & Drink

Tips for How to Make Your Own Rotisserie Chicken at Home

Chef Marjorie Druker doesn't need a secret recipe to make her chicken delicious.
Podcast

Olympia Provisions’ Elias Cairo on Making Charcuterie and More

Time to meat the man behind Olympia Provisions, Elias Cairo.
Food & Drink

How to Grill Fish: A Quick and Easy Guide to Getting it Right Every Time

For some expert tips on how to grill fish, we turned to David Ezelle, Executive Chef of Bluehour in Portland, Oregon.
Fashion & Style

12 Best Men’s Athleisure Brands to Take You from Lay-Ups to Lounging

These brands will take you from the gym to the office to happy hour and back again.
Podcast

Learning to Cook with Cannabis and Chef Brandon Parsons

Want to learn how to take your cooking to a higher level? On this episode of The Manual podcast, we talk culinary cannabis infusions.
Podcast

Going Beyond City Limits: A Beginner’s Guide to Austin, Texas

If you've been considering a vacation to Austin and need a little more convincing, then this episode of The Manual podcast is for you.
Culture

Murray Carter Tells Us What It Takes to be a Master Bladesmith in the Modern Era

On this episode of The Manual podcast, we engage in some razor-sharp conversation with a modern bladesmith and the history of forging knives.
Podcast

Chef Justin Cucci on Why We Should Be Eating More Bugs

Ever thought about the alternative proteins we know better as bugs? The Manual podcast gang sits down with Cucci to get the 4-1-1 on eating some 4(+)-legged friends.
Podcast

Westland Distillery’s Matt Hoffman on the Rise of American Single Malt Whiskey

While most people probably think of single malt whiskey as a purely Scottish (or perhaps Irish) thing, the fact is that American producers have been quietly pumping out single malt whiskey of their own.
Podcast

The Craft, Art, and Journey of Woodworking, According to a Master Craftsman

On this episode of The Manual podcast, we talk with Gary Rogowski, director of The Northwest Woodworking Studio in Portland, Oregon.
Podcast

Zane Lamprey on What it’s Like to Get Paid to Travel the World and Drink

Host of Four Sheets (among other shows) Zane Lamprey sits down with the BBB crew to talk about hosting a show about drinking and more.
Podcast

Take a Walk on the Wild Side with the Oregon Zoo

For many, the image of a khaki-clad zookeeper feeding animals and going on television shows may be the only idea of a zookeeper they have.
Podcast

La Brea Bakery’s Jon Davis Teaches Us Baking Basics

On this episode of The Manual podcast, we sit down with Jon Davis of La Brea Bakery to discover the baking basics every first-timer needs to know — like cookies are an important learning tool.
Podcast

Our Food and Drink Editor Wants to Know If You’re Afraid of the Dark Rum

On the latest episode of The Manual podcast, we chat with our very own Sam Slaughter about his brand-new cocktail book: Are You Afraid of the Dark Rum? and Other Cocktails for '90s Kids.