Over My Dead Body’s Matthew Shaer on Making a Great True Crime Podcast

beards booze bacon over my dead body true crime episode the manual podcast

What new bourbon are we pumped about? Which hiking trail are we exploring? Why is the next supercar so cool? The Manual is dedicated to helping men live a more engaged life. Each week, our editors and guests get together for a round-table discussion about what’s new, exciting, and unique in the men’s lifestyle world. So pop open your favorite brew, step into your man cave, and start streaming.

For this week’s episode of Beards, Booze, and Bacon: The Manual Podcast, the round-table — managing editor Nicole Raney, food and drink editor Sam Slaughter, and the inimitable host, Greg Nibler — sit down with the creator and host of Over My Dead Body, Matthew Shaer, to talk about his podcast, true crime, and why we’re all so obsessed with it.

To start, we find out how Shaer came across the crime that the first season of his podcast focuses on: the murder of Dan Markel. (We’ll give you a hint: It all starts with some particularly demented rabbis). From there, the gang digs into what it takes to make a true crime podcast. How do you research a chase? How long does it take to create a single season of a show? How does it feel now that the season is done?

Finally, the group digs into the true crime genre as a whole. Why does it continue to rise in popularity? What does that say about us as a culture? Is true crime going anywhere?

If you’re a fan of true crime, or even if you’re just starting to get into it because half of your Netflix recommendations seems to be about murderers and crimes, then this episode is for you. There is more to creating a successful crime podcast than being obsessed with a crime, and Shaer discusses everything it takes and more.

Are you a true crime fan? What shows do you listen to or watch? Do you know the next Serial and want to share that with us? If you have a question or comment for The Manual podcast crew, give us a shout at podcast@themanual.com — we’re always around! You can follow us on Facebook and Twitter. Make sure to subscribe and rate on your favorite podcast app, too!

Further Reading

Food & Drink

Leftover Makeover: How to Cook with Stale Bread

Turns out, you can teach an old loaf new tricks. Katie Parla teaches us how to make dishes like stuffed mussels and pasta.
Food & Drink

10 Easy Cocktail Recipes You Need to Know

You don’t have to be a master mixologist to shake these babies up.

Celebrating World Whisky Day with Bacardi, Beards, Booze, and Bacon

World Whisky Day is March 27 and to celebrate we sat down with two Bacardi Single Malts Brand Ambassadors to talk all things Scotch whisky.
Food & Drink

A Beginner’s Guide to Gathering Your Own Shellfish

Gathering shellfish is an activity that requires little to no mussels.

Beards, Booze, and Bacon: The Holiday Travel Episode

Heading somewhere this holiday season? You'll want to listen to this first.

Beards, Booze, and Bacon: The Cajun Cuisine Episode

We do have a warning. Make sure you've eaten. We take no responsibility for any hangry actions you may take upon finishing this episode.

Beards, Booze, and Bacon: The Portland Podcast Festival Episode

Warning: This podcast episode contains multiple beers. And shots.

How to Start Homebrewing, According to a Homebrewer

This week, The Manual podcast crew learns what it takes to homebrew beer. From equipment to hacks, Parker Hall pours a pint full of knowledge.

The New Design Trends of 2019 and How They Fit in Your Home

What's in store for 2019? According to Kelsey Machado, the dissolution of the dining room, '90s colors, and Chinese money plants.

Learn All About the Best ‘Affordable Luxury’ Cigars from a Real ‘Cigar Aficionado’

We sat down with the executive editor of 'Cigar Aficionado,' David Savona, to pick his brain on all things cigar.

The Absolute Best Introduction to the Beauty of Tequila

Here's why the rhyme one tequila, two tequila is not the best way to go about drinking tequila.

Pucker Up: It’s Time to Talk About Sour Beers with Cascade Brewing

Never had a sour beer before and feeling a little intimidated? Check out the latest episode of Beards, Booze, and Bacon to find out everything you need to know about the category.

How Changing Your Diet Can Change Your Life

On this episode of The Manual podcast, celebrity chef Seamus Mullen dishes on how he changed his diet and improved his life.

Cheesemakers Whey in on Why Cheese is So Un-Brie-Lievable

Talking about cheese is something that just gets feta and feta.