Skip to main content

Pilates vs. yoga: Which is right for you?

Yoga vs. Pilates: You can do both, don't worry

man doing rolling like a ball
Keifit / Pixabay

Studio fitness classes are a great way to combine working out and socializing. Exercising can be more fun when you’re powering through one last rep of burpees with your new friends. Not all fitness classes need to be high-intensity, though. Yoga and Pilates are two popular low-impact options . Besides being low-impact, both are lauded for improving posture, balance, and mobility. However, there are some key differences between the two disciplines. Knowing these distinctions can help you decide whether one or the other is the clear choice for you.

a black and white photo of a man on a beach
Artem Beliaikin/Unsplash / Unsplash

Yoga vs. Pilates: The basics

Before we deliver a verdict on the “yoga vs. Pilates” debate, let’s dig into what each exercise is about.

Recommended Videos

What is yoga?

Yoga has been around for centuries and likely originated in India. The ancient practice combines breath, meditation, and movement to connect the mind, body, and spirit. During a practice, people will pair poses with breath to move their bodies and center their minds.

Yoga comes in various types, including restorative, which leans heavily into the meditative aspects of a practice, power or hot, which emphasize strength and endurance. The type of yoga practiced also helps dictate how long someone holds poses and how intense a session is. Generally, yoga is hailed for having numerous benefits, including:

  • Stress relief
  • Anxiety management
  • Pain reduction
  • Improved mobility
  • Better flexibility
  • Improved sleep duration
  • Increased muscle strength
  • Improved quality of life

What is Pilates?

Developed in the early 20th century by Joseph Pilates to help injured dancers, Pilates is a full-body workout focusing on precise movement and mental concentration. The exercises don’t require big, sweeping movements, like a forward jump squat. Instead, you may watch someone do Pilates and wonder if they’re moving at all. Classic mat exercises like the hundreds require someone to lift their head off the ground and pump their arms, for instance.

Don’t be fooled — the small movements add up. Moreover, Pilates emphasizes drawing the belly button into the spine to engage the abdominal muscles. Only the person practicing Pilates knows if that is happening (and is feeling the burn).

Pilates boasts many benefits, including:

  • Muscle toning, particularly the core
  • Improved posture
  • Muscular endurance
  • More flexibility
  • A reduction in joint pain
  • Improved mental well-being

How are Pilates and yoga similar?

Yoga and Pilates have their share of differences. However, the two workouts offer some similarities. Both place a premium on breathwork, bringing mindfulness to movement and improving mental well-being on and off the mat. Each offers modified versions of exercises, making yoga and Pilates accessible to people of various fitness and experience levels. Both are beginner-friendly and low-impact, so either is often — but not always — considered a good fit for people cleared by their doctor to return to fitness. (Ask your doctor about the specific workout you plan to use for your comeback. Some injuries, like diastasis recti, may require you to lay off core work longer, even if cardio or gentle stretching is OK.)

What is the main difference between yoga and Pilates?

Generally speaking, Pilates is more focused on building strength, body control, and toning, while yoga emphasizes balance and flexibility. These concepts aren’t set in stone, however. For instance, power yoga certainly places a premium on muscular strength and endurance through quicker flows. However, you can typically expect yoga to be gentler.

Yoga also emphasizes spirituality as a way of finding peace and clarity. Instructors may take students through guided meditation, particularly during the final Savasana pose.

Kampus Production / Pexels

Pilates vs. yoga: The verdict

Which workout is better, Pilates or yoga? Is one harder than the other? These answers require some nuance. Here’s what to know.

Which is harder, yoga or Pilates?

Pilates is usually considered the more challenging of the two workouts because the exercises are focused on strength and endurance. Yoga emphasizes gentler stretches that bolster flexibility and balance. However, this answer depends on a few factors, including:

  • The exercises in your yoga or Pilates practice
  • The type of yoga you’re comparing Pilates to. For example, power or hot forms of yoga are known for being more challenging than slow-flow or restorative.
  • How a person modifies their workout — a full plank in yoga is more intense than a modified one in Pilates.

Which is better, yoga or Pilates?

There’s no correct answer to this question. Yoga and Pilates both offer physical and mental benefits. The question should be, “Which is better for you, yoga or Pilates?” Ask yourself these follow-ups:

  • Are you just returning from an injury or a long layoff from exercise? While either workout is likely OK, yoga is gentler.
  • Are you looking to build core strength or toning? Pilates is probably a better choice.
  • How much equipment do you want to use? Both workouts can be done using only body weight, but Pilates exercises often involve funkier equipment like Reformers. Yoga is a bit more accessible.

One more question: Do you actually want to choose? You don’t have to. Consider alternating between the two workouts, such as doing yoga on Mondays and Wednesdays and Pilates on Tuesdays and Thursdays. Working your muscles in different ways is a fantastic way to ward off injuries.

BethAnn Mayer
Beth Ann's work has appeared on healthline.com and parents.com. In her spare time, you can find her running (either marathons…
Topics
Sleepless night? This supplement might help your brain bounce back, study finds
Can this popular fitness supplement perk up your brain even if you're sleep deprived?
Man head in hands tired stressed laptop

I’m definitely not functioning at my best and fulfilling my true potential without a good night’s sleep. However, poor sleep doesn’t just hamper your productivity the next day or make your brain feel groggy; researchers have associated chronic insufficient sleep with a heightened risk of heart disease, obesity, cancer, and diabetes. Sleep is natural and protective for your overall wellness.

People try lots of ways to combat poor sleep, from guzzling cups of coffee to splashing water on their face and napping during lunch. In an interesting study, researchers investigated whether the popular fitness supplement creatine can enhance cognitive function following sleep deprivation. 

Read more
Active kids, healthier minds? Study explores kids’ fitness and mental health
Does being more physically active boost your child's mood and protect their mental health?
teen playing football

As a child, I ran and jumped around a lot and played with my friends, so I was generally quite active. Even then, I recall how moving my muscles made me feel better, both mentally and physically. Previous research concludes that physical activity is beneficial for improving mental health, anxiety, depression, stress, self-esteem, and social competence in typically developing children and adolescents, which aligns with what I experienced as a kid.

Recently, researchers wanted to explore whether children who took part in physical education classes and sports were less likely to experience anxiety, depression, and addiction as they became adolescents. Let’s look at the research.

Read more
Ruck pack vs weighted vest: Which is better for your fitness goals?
Which one will help you reach your fitness goals?
Man arms out exercise happy on rocks mountains nature rucking backpack rucksack

You have likely heard about adding extra weight to your body during workouts to burn calories and build muscle. This added weight can show up in numerous ways, from wearing a weighted vest while doing pull-ups to ankle weights during a Pilates class. As a fitness enthusiast myself, I find wearing a vest or heavy backpack while hiking can make quite a difference.

If you are looking to take your workouts up a notch, keep reading to learn about important factors to consider when choosing the best option for you, as well as find out how you stand in the ruck pack vs. weighted vest debate!

Read more