Skip to main content

What do Toyota, Porsche, and Ford have in common? The most loyal customers, according to J.D. Power

Customer loyalty is important, and these three brands are tops

People having a conersation at a car dealership
The past few years have been challenging for the auto industry. For starters, car prices increased due to
record-high inflation and supply chain issues. On top of that, gas prices rose to unprecedented levels causing consumers to consider hybrid and electric vehicles that are cheaper to fuel than gasoline vehicles. Not to mention the labor union strike that has crippled GM, Ford, and Stellantis manufacturing operations.

But that’s not all; traditional gasoline car brands are slowly losing ground to EV brands such as Tesla and Rivian. Case in point? According to Green Cars, the Tesla Model Y was the best-selling car globally in Q1 2023, a position that was previously held by the Toyota Corolla. We’ve also seen the same trend in California, where Tesla is outselling Toyota. Well, you have to ask — is the market shifting, or consumers are changing their brand loyalty?

The car brands with the most loyal customers

In the latest J.D. Power report, Toyota has the most loyal customers than any other car brand. According to the data, 60% of Toyota customers buy from the same brand after reselling their used vehicles. Honda comes a close second with a loyalty rate of 55%. Additionally, Porsche is the leading luxury brand, with 56.8% of the customers staying loyal, followed by Mercedes-Benz at 50.5%.

Front end angle of 2021 Ford F-150 parked on a dirt trail in front of a red barn and trees.
Ford / Ford

When it comes to the most loyal pickup owners, Ford takes the number one spot with a loyalty rate of 64.6%. This is not surprising considering that the Ford F-Series has been the best-selling pickup truck in the U.S. for decades. In the SUV mass market segment, 61.1% of Subaru owners retain the same brand after reselling their existing vehicles. However, Volvo has the most loyal owners in the luxury SUV category, with a loyalty rate of 56.5%, closely followed by BMW at 56.5%.

Interestingly, popular brands such as Chevrolet, Hyundai, Kia, Nissan, and Jeep didn’t rank at the top of the list in any segment, according to the report by J.D. Power. They likely missed out, considering that J.D. Power analyzed data from September 2022 to August 2023. Tesla may also not have made it to the list because there is no EV segment — or it doesn’t rank high if you put it in alongside other traditional car brands in different categories.

Besides that, the last time J.D. Power made a list of the most reliable car brands, it ranked Nissan, MINI, Kia, Hyundai, Chevrolet, Genesis, Mitsubishi, Buick, Toyota, and Lexus with the highest scores.

Editors' Recommendations

James Dolan
James Dolan is an automotive writer with extensive work experience having been published on The Drive, Hot Cars, Green…
The 2025 Jeep Gladiator 4xe Hybrid: What we know so far
Jeep Gladiator at Retro Classics 2022

Look out, four-wheel-drive aficionados. 2025 is expected to be a significant year for Jeep. The new CEO, Antonio Filosa, spoke out recently and discussed Jeep's EV plans for the following year and the Jeep Gladiator 4xe Hybrid. 

You might have guessed it, but one way the brand is looking to increase profits is by releasing a new 2025 Gladiator 4xe Hybrid. Its plug-in hybrid powertrain may give this model an advantage over its competitors, such as the GMC Canyon and Toyota Tacoma. 

Read more
Driving the Rolls Royce Black Badge Ghost: It packs a V12, but sounds like an EV
A glance at the Rolls Royce Black Badge Ghost
Rolls Royce Ghost Black Badge Front

For those of us who aren’t wildly successful, it’s not every day you get to drive around in a Rolls Royce. However, I’ve been lucky enough to hop into the front and back of a Ghost on several occasions. My most recent jaunt involved a Ghost Black Badge edition -- which involves a lot of cosmetic touches and a small boost in horsepower.

The Rolls Royce Black Badge Ghost also contains what, for me, is one of the most impressive features of a Rolls Royce. Under the hood is a substantial 6.7 liter V-12. The sort of thing that could probably roar loud enough to make windows shake half a mile away. It’s essentially an upmarket truck engine. But if you press the start button and hit the accelerator pedal, you can’t really hear it. Rolls prides itself in stuffing an incredible amount of soundproofing into its engine bay. The engine in the Black Badge is very slightly larger and a touch more powerful than the one you’ll find in a Silver Badge Ghost, but the difference isn’t huge enough to justify the choice on its own. To be honest, it’s the styling elements that are the main selling points of this premium trim.

Read more
The top 7 JDM cars of the 1990s
Which JDM car from the 1990s is your favorite?

Back in the 1990s, long before the era of EVs and hybrid vehicles, the most technologically advanced cars you could buy all came from Japan.
However, the term "JDM car" can be somewhat misleading at times. While initially, it literally meant a car available for the Japanese domestic market, many enthusiasts have morphed its translation into simply a reference to a car that was built by a Japanese company with no regard for the actual market in which it was sold. So, we decided to split the difference and offer up the best seven cars of Japanese descent. With one lone exception, all of these cars were available in both Japan and the United States at one time or another.
It should also be noted that during the 1990s, Japanese automakers had an unspoken handshake deal that sports cars had to have a power cap of 276 hp. Of course, all the companies participated and quoted power peaks that mysteriously all seemed to touch that limit but never exceed it. Yet many of those same cars magically made gobs more power once they made it to our shores with little or no changes to their engines. Read on for the full list!

Mazda RX-7

Read more