Skip to main content

A new analysis says streaming services now cost more than cable (but the truth isn’t that simple)

Is TV streaming really that expensive?

couple watching tv at home
cherryandbees / Adobe Stock

After millions of people ditched their cable packages for more a la carte streaming options, a new analysis is now claiming that cable is actually cheaper, on average, than the average person’s array of streaming services. According to an analysis in the Financial Times, thanks to price increases for subscriptions to Apple TV+, Max, Disney+, and Hulu, among others, streaming subscriptions now cost an average of $87/mo, compared to the equivalent cable package, which costs $83/mo.

This new analysis comes amid an array of bad news for streaming services, which have seen their stock valuations tumble due to stalled subscriber growth and growing concerns about whether they will ever be able to turn a profit.

Services like Netflix have also started introducing ad-supported tiers that adopt, at least in part, the model of traditional linear television and port it over into the streaming era. Crucially, though, all of these services have also started to raise their prices, in some cases quite substantially. Disney+, for example, raised their price from $7.99 to $10.99 and then again to $13.99, all in less than a single calendar year.

Hulu’s prices have also increased by 20%, and HBO Max rebranded to Max, increased its prices, and introduced a new ad-supported tier.

The price comparison is not always so simple

Although it’s undeniable that streaming services have grown more expensive in recent years, it’s certainly not the case that any combination of streaming services is going to be cheaper or more expensive than traditional cable. For one thing, cable costs can vary pretty wildly depending on what region of the country you live in (and numerous other factors), whereas streaming costs are the same for everyone in the same tier. For another, you can choose which streaming services to subscribe to, which allows you to choose which costs you incur. Cable has some selectivity, but the base costs are always much higher than they are with streamers.

As a result, it’s not really fair to say that streaming is always the more expensive option, although it’s now true that it can be the more expensive option. If you’re the kind of person who has trouble managing subscriptions and gets charged for services you never or rarely use, then the streaming era may even be costing you substantially more than you would have paid before.

Streaming may not be a sure-fire business model

Although we saw a definitive streaming boom in the second half of the 2010s and early part of the 2020s, it seems like we are now past the point of peak streaming services. Some are realizing that streaming’s costs were too high to ever be paid by subscription fees alone, and that remains true even as those fees increase.

At the same time, streaming services are slowly becoming more and more like linear television, adding ads and relying more heavily on shows that are cheaper to produce, including plenty of reality TV. Although it may not always be more expensive than cable, streaming no longer looks as much like the future of TV as it once did.

Joe Allen
Contributor
Joe Allen is a freelance culture writer based in upstate New York. His work has been published in The Washington Post, The…
Best SodaStream Prime Day deals: up to $100 off
cheap kitchen accessories that will change your life sodastream fizzi sparkling water maker

Prime Day might be behind us but there are still some leftover SodaStream Prime Day deals around to check out. If you missed a chance earlier this week, you could still reap some big savings on the best soda maker for your kitchen countertop. We've checked out all the best SodaStream deals available across all the major retailers online. We've also provided some buying advice so you know what to consider when buying a SodaStream. Check out these deals before they end very soon as time truly is running out.
Best Prime Day SodaStream deal
SodaStream Art Sparkling Water Maker -- $104, was $150

Making sparking water doesn't have to be complicated, and it's certainly easy with the SodaStream Art. You'll be able to turn flat water into sparkling water with the press of a button, and you'll have complete control over how much fizz you want in your drink. The carbonation process is manual using the device's lever, which means there are no batteries or electricity required. Combined with dimensions of just about 17.5 inches in height, 7.2 inches in width, and weight of 7.7 pounds, it will be easy to carry the SodaStream Art to any room in your home where it will be needed -- and it won't take up too much space anywhere you place it.

Read more
Best Garmin watch Prime Day deals: Up to $230 off right now
The Garmin Vivoactive 4 on a person's wrist.

Prime Day may be behind us but some awesome Garmin watch deals remain so you can still snap up a bargain if you missed out on the last couple of days of sales. If you're seeking a health-focused smartwatch, Garmin is one of the best brands around and it's a delight to see so many excellent Garmin watches reduced as they're usually typically quite expensive. We're also got some key buying advice so you know exactly what to look for when investing in one.
Best Garmin watch Prime Day deal
Forerunner 945 GPS -- $369, was $600

Athletes and those who are serious about achieving their health goals should have the Garmin Forerunner 945 strapped to their wrists. Designed for running and triathlons, the wearable device offers can track metrics such as VO2 Max and your training status, so you'll always be able to monitor your body as you challenge yourself to reach greater heights. The Garmin Forerunner 945 will also let you access full-color onboard maps to guide you during your runs, so you'll never find yourself off your planned path. The smartwatch also enables Garmin Pay, which will allow you to make contactless payments so you can leave your cash and cards at home.

Read more
Best Nectar mattress Prime Day deals: Queen beds under $1,000
A Nectar mattress.

Prime Day has ended but Nectar is continuing its sale meaning it's offering some exceptional mattress sales right now. If you still haven't bought a new mattress but you need to, take a look at these deals right now. Besides rounding up all the best Nectar mattress Prime Day deals, we've also come up with some key buying advice so you know exactly what to think about before you buy one. In no time, you'll have the best night's sleep you've had in years.
Best Nectar mattress Prime Day deal
Nectar Premier Mattress Memory Foam (Queen) -- $849, was $1,499

If you're having trouble sleeping, it may be because your mattress is all worn out and no longer comfortable. If that's the case, you should take advantage of this offer for the queen-sized Nectar Premier Mattress. It features a dual-action cooling system and the brand's ActiveCool HD phase change material that reacts to your body temperature to keep you cool through the night, and it's made of five layers across thickness of 13 inches. The mattress also offers minimal motion transfer, so you won't disturb whoever's sleeping on it whenever you get in or out of bed.

Read more