Skip to main content
  1. Home
  2. Travel
  3. Features

The Amalfi Coast wasn’t what I expected — here’s how to do it better

Amalfi Coast
Emily Caldwell / The Manual

The world of social media has many perks, such as helping travelers like me hone in on which travel destinations to add to their bucket lists. A major downside, however, is the potential for overtourism, leaving places that were once beautiful gems as overcrowded, busy tourist hotspots. The Amalfi Coast, unfortunately, is one of those places that left me questioning the “hype”, as the crowds seemed to take away from the beauty of the place.

After spending months on “traveltok” watching videos of the beautiful Amalfi Coast, I set out to visit this popular area situated on the southern edge of Italy’s Sorrentine Peninsula. While beautiful, the experience didn’t quite live up to the image portrayed by social media. Here’s why — and how I’d do the Amalfi Coast differently next time, and how you can do it better.

Expectations vs. reality

The Amalfi Coast is as scenic and beautiful as it looks in every social media reel you’ve seen — but it’s important to recognize that every place has its shortcomings. Though I had high hopes for my day trip to Sorrento, Amalfi, and Positano, I felt disappointed with the reality of the day. The first and most notable reason for my disappointment is due to overcrowding (my mistake, visiting in August). The summer is one of the most crowded times of year to visit the Amalfi Coast, making it nearly impossible to walk through crowded, narrow streets. Since social media has made these scenic spots even more popular, tourism is on the rise, up nearly 9% since 2019. Social media says it’s ‘not that bad’, but I beg to differ.

Recommended Videos

Another factor playing into my experience was the rushed nature of my trip. Staying in Naples meant I only had one day to explore three cities in the Amalfi region, with only about 1.5 to 2 hours in each stop. The combination of overcrowding, brutal European summer heat, a rushed schedule, and my claustrophia left me with an unexpected disappointment. I’m not usually someone who minds crowds or tourists; however, I do start to get frustrated when I’m shoulder-to-shoulder with the person in front of me while just trying to walk around.

Tips for better Amalfi Coast travel

No matter where you’re traveling, it’s important to remember that what you see on social media isn’t always going to match the reality of a destination. As you scroll through videos of colorful houses and waterfront restaurants, it’s key to remember that everyone’s expectations of “ideal” travel can differ. If I were to visit the Amalfi Coast again, I would:

  • Go only during the shoulder season (September to October or April to May)
  • Avoid a day trip (staying for several days at a time) to avoid feeling rushed
  • Avoid visiting popular tourist hotspots that can easily get too packed

My experience visiting the Amalfi Coast shows why planning is everything when it comes to optimizing your travel for your preferences. If you have your heart set on visiting this trendy area, strategic planning could yield a better experience that feels less claustrophobic and crowded. Additionally, it may also be worth checking out a few Italian alternatives that offer a similar coastal scenic appeal to the Amalfi Coast, such as Ischia, a small island accessible by ferry in just one hour from Naples. Other alternatives include Cinque Terre in Northwest Italy and Costa Viola in Calabria, Italy.

Emily is a Features Writer at The Manual, where she specializes in food, beverage, and travel content. She focuses on weaving… Read Full Bio
Cafe Charmant, The Corner Store Crew’s Latest, Puts Food Ahead of the Scene
Clothing, Long Sleeve, Sleeve

I’ll be honest. If I weren’t a writer, there is no way in hell I could have landed a 7:15 Saturday night reservation at Cafe Charmant just a mere four weeks after its opening. The most recent jewel in the buzzy Catch Hospitality Group’s crown, the glitzy eatery is the newest IT restaurant to hit the downtown scene, so chalk it up to one of the perks of the job that I could walk in, order a drink, and be ushered to a corner table for two in under 10 minutes.

Though the state of making prime reservations in New York City may not come as a surprise to many, I’m still not able to reconcile with the current velvet rope of so many of this city’s restaurants. Sure, the 90s and early 2000’s had their Indochine, Moomba (if you remember that one, we need to grab a drink). The Waverly Inn, but for the most part, you could easily make a reservation or even walk in and wait for a table with a cocktail in hand at most popular establishments. And, let’s be honest, half the people weren’t even eating, if you know what I mean.

Read more
A tasting guide to Livermore Valley, California’s friendliest wine country
Adult, Male, Man

Livermore Valley sits in Northern California’s East Bay, where the hustle and bustle of neighboring Oakland and San Francisco give way to grassy rolling hills, big open skies, and over 40 tasting rooms. The region is home to some of the best wines I’ve tasted in the state, without the pretense and rigidity I’ve come to expect from other tasting rooms in the region.

And thanks to the valley’s marine-influenced winds, varied climate, and diverse soils, I tasted an unusually broad range of wines. Crisp whites, structured reds, and everything in between seem to be able to find their footing here.

Read more
High Society, Low Alcohol: A Trip to the Hamptons with Heineken 0.0
Ball, Sport, Tennis

After a multi-year bender of back-to-back press trips, I decided to swear off travel this past summer. The old dog was tired, and I desperately wanted to reconnect with old friends, visit family, and continue wooing a lovely lady in New York. Oh, and I needed to find time to actually write the stories I had promised publicists in exchange for gallivanting around the globe on their dime. I am, after all, a professional.

As summer raced by, my inbox swelled with tantalizing invitations. I turned them down one after the next with Spartan fortitude. A junket to the Loire Valley to review wineries? Thank you for considering me, but for the next few weeks, I’m committed to rekindling my relationship with my bed. A sailboat cruise on the Amalfi Coast? I hear it’s beautiful this time of year, but sadly, I’m in the weeds bingeing Landman.

Read more